Best Car Insurance Agencies in Newark

9 Best Newark Car Insurance Agencies

  • Our selection process
  • View our top picks

We scored 166 Car Insurance Agencies in Newark, NJ and Picked the Top 9

Abbott Insurance Agency is a full-service insurance firm located in Bloomfield, New Jersey. Established in 1959 by William Abbott, the family-owned business provides auto insurance to residents throughout the Newark metro area. Policies may include comprehensive, collision, and liability coverage. Reimbursements for third party medical bills and personal injury protection may be included. The agency also offers homeowners, renters, and personal umbrella insurance. Services are provided in English and Spanish.

Barrood Agency is a full-service insurance brokerage in New Brunswick, New Jersey, that operates throughout Central New Jersey. With over 78 years of experience in the industry, the company provides motorists with auto insurance plans that include liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Personal injury protection and uninsured motorist policies may be added on to any insurance package. Barrood also assists clients with recreational vehicles, rental dwellings, and home insurance. Services are available in English and Spanish.

Established in 1983, Berkshire Hathaway GUARD serves New Jersey clients from its Summit location, and it has eight other locations, including its Wilkes-Barre home office. It is partnered with over 5,500 independent insurance agents and brokers. This agency provides nationwide commercial auto insurance policies which include liability, physical damage, and statutory coverage. While a personal auto insurance policy isn't mentioned, Berkshire Hathaway GUARD's personal umbrella policy does include auto liability within its coverage provision.

Established in 1979 by Alan Geisenheimer, the Geisenheimer Insurance Agency provides personal and commercial automobile insurance for clients in Saddle Brook, New Jersey. With a strong focus on assisting small businesses, Geisenheimer Insurance Agency guides commercial clients through the eligibility, exclusions, and limits of insuring vehicles and employee drivers. For personal automobile needs, Geisenheimer Insurance Agency aids New Jersey drivers with the legal state requirements and uses various insurance carriers to meet their needs and budgets.

Hanson & Ryan Inc. is based in Totowa, New Jersey, and has been insuring the residents of the Newark metro area for more than a century. The agency insures all types of automobiles and customizes quotes to address clients' concerns. Most policies include standard coverages such as liability and medical payments. Allstate and Mercury Insurance Group are just a couple of the carriers the company works with. Hanson & Ryan Inc. also handles health, life, and disability insurance.

James A. Connors Associates Inc. in Morristown, New Jersey, is a second-generation, family-owned agency assisting drivers with auto insurance coverage purchases in the greater Newark area. Established in 1925, it has an array of relationships with leading insurance companies, and it leverages that network to help drivers get needed coverage with deductibles and premiums that work for their situations. Most policies include bodily injury and property damage liability, collision, medical payments, and UM/UIM coverage.

National Independent Truckers Insurance Company (NITIC) is an underwriting firm focusing on auto insurance for trucks. Founded in 2001, NITIC operates in Linden, New Jersey. It has an operating license issued by the South Carolina Department of Insurance and is permitted to provide insurance services in 48 states. The insurer specializes in insurance plans for trucks, trailers, cargo, and third-party liability. As a Risk Retention Group, NITIC extends ownership to policyholders and boasts the AM Best's Financial Strength Rating.

With locations in Newark and seven other locations throughout New Jersey, Otterstedt is a prominent auto insurance provider. It works with multiple insurance companies to find competitive rates for customers and offers several coverage options, including collision, comprehensive damage, bodily injury and medical payments, uninsured motorists coverage, property damage, and personal injury no-fault protection. Rental car reimbursement is also offered. The company has been recognized in Insurance Journal as one of the Top 50 Insurance Agencies in the country.

Active since 1943, Reiner Insurance is a Newark, New Jersey-based agency representing clients throughout the metro area. Auto insurance policies are a major aspect of its business and this agency partners with several providers including Progressive and Liberty Mutual to sell clients policies covering bodily injury, property damage, comprehensive liability, and more. Reiner Insurance provides home and business insurance services as well. Clients can combine multiple insurance categories into umbrella policies for lower rates.

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: