hero image

Best Car Insurance Agencies in Jersey City

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored car insurance agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best car insurance agencies in Jersey City, NJ.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 148 93 12

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of BCG Advisors, Inc.  car-insurance/1.jpg

BCG Advisors, Inc.

BCG Advisors Inc. is an independent auto insurance agency that has been selling to the residents of Jersey City, New Jersey, since 1999. The broker maintains relationships with multiple large insurance carriers, such as Mercury, MetLife, and Progressive, allowing them to provide personalized insurance plans for its clients. It sells protection for traditional and antique vehicles, covering damage caused by accidents or natural disasters, as well as medical bills for those involved.

700 Plaza Dr Ste 216
Secaucus, NJ 7094


cover image of Bogle Agency Insurance  car-insurance/2.jpg

Bogle Agency Insurance

Bogle Agency Insurance is a family-owned and operated independent auto insurance company that has been serving the community of Jersey City, New Jersey, and the nearby cities since 1919. The company represents large insurance carriers, and sells comprehensive and collision coverage for traditional and vintage vehicles. This covers bodily harm liability, property damage, and uninsured and underinsured motorists. Bogle Agency Insurance also sells business, health, life, and homeowners and renters insurance.

200 Stuyvesant Ave
Lyndhurst, NJ 7071


cover image of Borgos Hanlon Henry & Garcia, Inc.  car-insurance/3.jpg

Borgos Hanlon Henry & Garcia, Inc.

Since 1920, Borgos, Hanlon, Henry, and Garcia Insurance has worked with drivers in Jersey City, New Jersey, to find auto insurance policies that suit their needs. It represents carriers such as The Andover Companies, Plymouth Rock Assurance, and Foremost Insurance Group and provides auto insurance policies that include options such as comprehensive and collision coverage. In addition to standard auto insurance, Borgos, Hanlon, Henry, and Garcia Insurance offers policies that cover vehicles such as antique cars, motorhomes, and boats.

593 Kearny Ave
Kearny, NJ 7032


cover image of David Kusel Associates Insurance  car-insurance/4.jpg

David Kusel Associates Insurance

David Kusel Associates Insurance is an auto insurance company that has been serving the residents of Jersey City, New Jersey, since 1957. This independent company sells coverage for traditional vehicles, RVs, watercraft, motorcycles, trailers, and classic collection cars. This covers property damage and medical bills for drivers and passengers in the event of a collision or a natural disaster. David Kusel Associates Insurance also sells commercial, homeowners, and renters insurance.

190 Moore St
Hackensack, NJ 7601


cover image of Gonzalez & Company Insurance Agency  car-insurance/1.jpg

Gonzalez & Company Insurance Agency

Based in North Bergen, New Jersey, Gonzalez & Company Insurance Agency has worked with a large selection of national insurers to find affordable auto coverage for drivers throughout the Jersey City area. Since 1987, the company has been insuring cars, trucks, and motorcycles, and its policies include a range of coverages such as liability, uninsured motorist, and medical. Founder Chris Gonzalez holds a Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter designation. Gonzalez & Company Insurance Agency also writes home and life insurance policies.

5833 Kennedy Blvd
North Bergen, NJ 7047


cover image of Insurance Center of North Jersey  car-insurance/2.jpg

Insurance Center of North Jersey

The Insurance Center of North Jersey is an independent insurance agency in Maywood, New Jersey, that has been serving customers in the greater Jersey City, New Jersey, area since 1927. The company offers auto insurance policies from select carriers to provide motorists with liability, personal injury protection, comprehensive, collision, and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. The Insurance Center of North Jersey also offers business auto insurance, as well as policies for classic and exotic cars.

25 E Spring Valley Ave Ste 275
Maywood, NJ 7607


cover image of ISU John C. Conklin Agency  car-insurance/3.jpg

ISU John C. Conklin Agency

ISU John C. Conklin Agency is an independent insurance agency providing auto insurance packages to clients within the Jersey City, New Jersey, metro area. It offers both personal and commercial insurance packages and covers a range of vehicles including standard cars and trucks, classic cars, motorcycles, and RVs. Coverage is available for watercraft and motor homes too. ISU John C. Conklin Agency also offers home and renter's insurance and specialty policies for a multitude of assets.

746 River Rd
New Milford, NJ 7646


cover image of Julius A Rose Inc Insurance Agency  car-insurance/4.jpg

Julius A Rose Inc Insurance Agency

Founded in 1901, the Julius A. Rose Inc. Insurance Agency services the insurance needs of residents of Jersey City, New Jersey, and the tri-state area, offering a range of auto insurance products from trusted carriers. Family-owned, this independent insurance agency has lasting relationships with national insurers and tailors policies to fit each motorist's unique requirements, including liability, comprehensive, and collision options. The agency also sells homeowners insurance and packages that bundle home and auto coverage.

194 Broadway
Bayonne, NJ 7002


cover image of Muller Insurance  car-insurance/1.jpg

Muller Insurance

Founded in 1906, Muller Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in the Jersey City, New Jersey, metro area. Auto coverage professionals work with over a dozen carriers, such as Progressive, the Foremost Insurance Group, and travelers, to help drivers get the right amount of insurance at a fair rate. Liability is required by state law to cover property damage and bodily harm and motorists can add collision and comprehensive coverage to pay for repairs and vehicle replacement.

930 Washington St
Hoboken, NJ 7030


cover image of Otterstedt Insurance Agency  car-insurance/2.jpg

Otterstedt Insurance Agency

Otterstedt Insurance Agency, which was founded in 1919, has expanded throughout New Jersey as a prominent auto insurance provider. With multiple locations throughout the state, including Englewood Cliffs, Otterstedt partners with several auto insurance providers to find competitive rates for its clients. Policies can offer coverage for bodily injury and medical payments, uninsured motorists, collision, comprehensive physical damage, property damage, rental car reimbursement, driver of the other car, and personal injury no-fault protection.

540 Sylvan Ave
Englewood Cliffs, NJ 7632


cover image of Preferred Choice Insurance Agency  car-insurance/3.jpg

Preferred Choice Insurance Agency

Preferred Choice Insurance Agency, based in Jersey City, New Jersey, is an insurance brokerage that works with Progressive, Mercury, and eight other carriers to provide clients with auto insurance. The agency offers collision and comprehensive coverage to motorists with automobiles, motorcycles, and recreational vehicles. Policies cover vehicle repairs and medical expenses caused by accidents, for both the policyholder and other involved parties. Preferred Choice also assists clients with home and business insurance.

110 Central Ave
Jersey City, NJ 7306


cover image of SAS Insurance Agency, Inc  car-insurance/4.jpg

SAS Insurance Agency, Inc

Since 1965, SAS Insurance Agency Inc. has worked to provide personalized insurance advice and coverage to residents of Jersey City and the rest of New Jersey. This agency works with most major insurance companies, including Progressive, Travelers, MetLife, and Providence Mutual. It helps clients find homeowners, flood, and commercial property coverage, as well as automobile and life insurance policies. SAS Insurance Agency is a Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agent, and agents speak multiple languages including Spanish, Greek, and Portuguese.

233 Kearny Ave
Kearny, NJ 7032


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: