Best Car Insurance Agencies in Plano

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Plano Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 165 104 14

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Buchanan Insurance

Buchanan Insurance is an independent insurance brokerage based in Farmersville, Texas, that serves motorists throughout the Plano and Leonard metro areas. The agency works with multiple insurance carriers, such as Allstate, Nationwide, and Germania, to provide clients with collision and comprehensive coverage policies. The company's auto insurance can also cover personal injury protection, medical payments, and liability for injuries caused to third parties or their property. Buchanan also offers homeowners and business insurance.

301 Hwy. # 380 East
Farmersville, TX 75442


Century Insurance Agency, Inc.

Century Insurance Agency Inc. is an independent agency that has been insuring North Texas drivers since 1996 from its offices in Denton and Flower Mound. It works with 25 insurance carriers, including Progressive and State Auto, to provide clients with affordable auto insurance. There are discounts available for good students, a safe driving record, and having no prior claims. Flexible payment options are available from some carriers. The company also offers homeowners, life, and business insurance.

3200 Long Prairie Rd Ste 200
Flower Mound, TX 75022


CNC Insurance Brokerage Services

Located in Frisco, Texas, CNC Insurance Brokerage Services is an independent agency licensed to serve clients in Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Georgia, Ohio, Tennessee, and Oklahoma. Patrons can go online to obtain a quote for their auto insurance. CNC Insurance offers collision, comprehensive, liability, and no-fault auto insurance through national insurance carriers. The firm, which has over 25 years experience in the insurance industry, also offers renters, investment property, landlord, homeowner, and flood insurance.

8765 Stockard Dr Ste 402
Frisco, TX 75034


Dagley Insurance

Since 2001, Dagley Insurance has served clients with automobile insurance needs in Plano, Texas. With locations throughout Texas and Colorado, Dagley Insurance advises clients of their state's minimum requirements for automobile insurance, offering additional protection for collision, loss of use, and underinsured/uninsured motorists. The company focuses on building individualized insurance plans that take into account individual risk, age of vehicle, driving habits, and budget. Dagley Insurance has commercial automobile coverage options for all vehicle types owned by businesses of all sizes.

8000 Coit Rd Ste 500
Plano, TX 75025


Gant Group Insurance

Gant Group Insurance is an independent insurance company serving clients in the Plano, Texas area. Multiple agents work with numerous insurance underwriters to customize personal and commercial auto insurance policies to each customer's needs. Gant Group Insurance offers collision and comprehensive insurance, liability-only policies, and coverage for medical payments related to an auto accident. Special coverage options include rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, and towing. The company also provides insurance policies for recreational vehicles and watercraft.

1807 West St
McKinney, TX 75069


Harrison Insurance Agency

Based in Addison, Texas, Harrison Insurance Agency is a brokerage firm offering a list of personal insurance coverage options for a diverse clientele. The company helps motorists, boat owners, and motorcycle riders to find affordable insurance policies that can get them back on the road as soon as possible if their means of transport gets damaged or stolen. They match clients with a list of the most reputable and financially stable insurance carriers in the state, such as Progressive and Safeco Insurance.

15601 Dallas Pkwy Ste 900
Addison, TX 75001


HI Agency

Based in Frisco, Texas, Haeussler Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that has been serving drivers in the DFW metroplex since 2005. HI Agency customizes auto insurance policies to clients' requirements and budget levels with coverage such as comprehensive, liability, and property damage. To find the most affordable premiums, the agency works with a variety of insurers, including Safeco and Progressive. HI Agency also offers life insurance and umbrella policies as part of its suite of services.

5899 Preston Rd Ste 1301
Frisco, TX 75034


Legacy Insurance Partners

Legacy Insurance Partners is an insurance agency based in Carrollton, Texas, and founded in 2007. It is an independent agency that has access to more than 100 insurance carriers that it works with to create car insurance policies that are tailored to clients' specific needs. The firm's auto insurance provides property coverage to cover damage to vehicles, liability coverage to pay for injury and damage to others, and medical coverage that pays for treating injuries and lost wages.

1205 W Trinity Mills Rd
Carrollton, TX 75006


Mike Leonard Insurance Agency

The Mike Leonard Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company based in Carrollton, Texas, with over 35 years of experience serving drivers in the Plano metro area. Auto coverage specialists work with several top insurance carriers, such as Nationwide, Metlife, Progressive, Kemper Preferred, Safeco Insurance, and The Hartford, to find clients the right amount of coverage for a price within their budget. It also provides home coverage and packages auto and homeowners policies for a discount.

1930 E Rosemeade Pkwy Ste 215
Carrollton, TX 75007


Milestone Insurance and Investment Services, LP

Milestone Insurance and Investment Services LP is an independent insurance agency based in Plano, Texas. Coverage specialists work with several A+ rated carriers, such as Chubb, State Auto, Progressive, and Travelers, to find drivers the protection they need at a competitive rate. Options include the state minimum liability for bodily injury and property damage, and policies can cover vehicle damage through collision and comprehensive plans. Some carriers also offer accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, GAP insurance, and ambulance coverage.

3369 Premier Dr Ste 200
Plano, TX 75023


Prosper Insurance Center

Prosper Insurance Center is a Plano, Texas-based agency helping clients throughout the metro area with auto insurance policies. The agency believes it can offer clients a higher quality of service because of its long established relationships and dedication to the local community. It is experienced in coverage for bodily injury, property damage, and comprehensive and liability coverage areas. Outside of auto insurance, Prosper Insurance Center performs home, life, and health insurance services and offers various umbrella policies.

900 N Preston Rd Ste B
Prosper, TX 75078


Sills Insurance Agency

Sills Insurance Agency is an independently owned and locally operated company in Plano, Texas. It has been working with several top carriers to help customers obtain auto insurance since 1998. Its team is experienced in providing customers with policies that are tailored to suit their specific needs. These policies can include protection against vehicle damage and theft as well as against medical and legal expenses resulting from injury caused by an accident.

2817 Regal Rd Ste 101
Plano, TX 75075


Tri-Star Insurance Professionals

With over 70 years of experience, Tri-Star Insurance Professionals serves the personal and commercial insurance needs of Plano, Texas, and the surrounding area. Personal auto insurance packages cover bodily injury liability, property damage, medical payments, and uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injuries. Tri-Star Insurance Professionals also offers collision and comprehensive coverage. Commercial auto insurance policies cover company-owned vehicles, included those that are rented, loaned, or leased, as well as liability coverage for business use of employees' cars.

4949 Hedgcoxe Rd Ste 250
Plano, TX 75024


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: