Close
Get Listed
Laurels

Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Madison
2021

We scored 138 Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Madison, WI and Picked the Top 7

Here are the Picks:

Anton Insurance

Compliance Insurance

Homewood Insurance Agency

Prairie Land Insurance Agency

The Curtis Agency

The WIN Group Insurance Agency

Vicki Wagener Agency - American Family Insurance

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Madison Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 138 85 7

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Read more about our selection process

Anton Insurance

Anton Insurance is an insurance agency based in Columbus, Wisconsin, serving clients throughout the greater Madison area and from all over the state. Founded in 1994, the firm has extensive experience in the delivery of customized auto insurance solutions to a range of clients, including motorists with multiple cars and businesses with commercial automobiles. As an independent insurance agency, the company offers clients a wide variety of choice for comprehensive coverage policies, making it easy to shop and compare different plans. Anton Insurance also offers home, renters, farm, and recreational vehicle insurance.

Click to Call

137 W Mill St
Columbus, WI 53925

Website

(920) 623-9305 Website

Reputation: A+

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

4.6 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

15 (Better)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Compliance Insurance

Compliance Insurance is an independent, family-owned agency that has served the Madison, Wisconsin, community since 2007. Founders Heather and Mike Wilson are a father and daughter team with over 50 years of experience. Policies include a wide range of providers and comprehensive home insurance options covering natural disasters, repair expenses, personal liability, and damage to personal property. Other products include auto insurance, and the company provides dependable protection against loss. Its agents handle high-risk auto policies with immediate issuance of SR 22 forms. Compliance Insurance also offers snowmobile and watercraft coverage.

Click to Call

6602 University Ave
Middleton, WI 53562

Website

(608) 836-1001 Website

Homewood Insurance Agency

Homewood Insurance Agency is a firm based in Madison, Wisconsin, with another office in Sun Prairie. Opened in 1989, the firm has extensive experience in finding suitable insurance policies for homeowners throughout the region. The agency helps property owners and renters in the hunt for comprehensive insurance coverage that suits their unique needs, and at a fair price. Policies cover homes against perils such as vandalism, hail damage, fire and smoke destruction, and windstorms. Personal belongings, such as appliances and jewelry, can also be included. Homewood Insurance Agency also provides auto, business, and motorcycle insurance.

Click to Call

583 Donofrio Dr Ste 1012
Madison, WI 53719

Website

(608) 442-6666 Website

Reputation: A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

4.8 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

6 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Prairie Land Insurance Agency

Prairie Land Insurance Agency operates throughout the Madison, Wisconsin, metro area, consulting clients on home insurance policies and facilitating their negotiation with several providers. Its agents typically structure policies consisting of protections for structural damage, personal injury and liability, and personal belongings. This agency covers a range of property types including single family homes and condominiums as well as motor homes and rental properties. Renters insurance is available to clients who have belongings inside their leased property and need coverage for cases of natural disaster, fire, or burglary. Prairie Land Insurance Agency also sells coverage for automobiles and watercraft.

Click to Call

2045 Atwood Ave # Ave # 113A
Madison, WI 53704

Website

(608) 251-3009 Website

Reputation: A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

3 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

The Curtis Agency

With offices in Madison, Wisconsin, The Curtis Agency is an independent insurance agency and financial advisor that sells home insurance. Founded in 2006, the agency provides insurance for homeowners that covers their dwellings and personal possessions on the premises and protects the owner against liability. It offers free quotes through the website for homeowners, condo owners, and renters through a secure online platform. The Curtis Agency also offers stock and options trading, as well as auto, life, commercial, and health insurance through reputable carriers, such as Zurich, Capital, and Travelers.

Click to Call

1334 Applegate Rd Ste 204
Madison, WI 53713

Website

(608) 250-2501 Website

The WIN Group Insurance Agency

The WIN Group Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Columbus, Wisconsin, that provides home insurance to residents in the area. The agency provides home insurance to protect against damage by fire or natural disaster, liability coverage, theft or vandalism, and for mortgage purposes. It offers discounts on its insurance products for full payment, buying multiple policies, and initial binding verbal agreements. The WIN Group Insurance Agency belongs to the BWO Insurance group and provides products from over 60 top insurance carriers, which include Hanover, Kemper, Integrity, Nationwide, MetLife, and Travelers.

Click to Call

1082 Park Ave
Columbus, WI 53925

Website

(920) 350-0800 Website

Reputation: A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

2 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Vicki Wagener Agency - American Family Insurance

Vicki Wagener Agency is an American Family Insurance agency in Madison, Wisconsin, that offers home insurance. Established in 2012, Vicki Wagener Agency offers home insurance products that include coverage for damage caused by leaky roofs, fire and smoke, lightning, theft, snow and ice, wind, hail, tornadoes, and power surges. The agency provides all American Family insurance and other financial products, including life, auto, and commercial insurance. Vicki Wagener was American Family agent of the year in 2016 and 2018 and believes in providing dependable protection, flexibility, and service to all her clients.

Click to Call

1633 Thierer Rd
Madison, WI 53704

Website

(608) 249-2184 Website

Reputation: A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

2 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area