Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Milwaukee

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Milwaukee Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 351 214 9

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect. has been in business for more than a decade and offers affordable home insurance to residents of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The company is independently owned and operated and offers insurance policies from a variety of providers. Its policies cover structural damage to the home when it occurs as the result of a covered reason such as fire or natural disaster. Some coverage is also typically included to cover the cost of replacing personal belongings, and personal liability coverage is included to protect the homeowner from financial hardship in the event a guest is injured on the property.

3005 N Main St Ste 222
Racine, WI 53402


Brew City Insurance

Brew City Insurance in South Milwaukee, Wisconsin, serves the home insurance needs of residents in the Milwaukee metro area. With more than 25 years of industry expertise, president and vice president Debbie and Bob Larson maintain relationships with a portfolio of national insurance carriers to give their clientele the best rates and coverage on home insurance policies that guard against liability and loss. Brew City Insurance works with top companies including Progressive, Safeco, Foremost, and GMIC. It sells policies for homes, condos, renters, and rental properties as well as umbrella insurance.

2937 S Chicago Ave
South Milwaukee, WI 53172


Frank Medina Insurance

Frank Medina Insurance in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, serves clients in Wisconsin and Texas as an independent insurance agent selling home insurance. Founded in 2013, FMI offers home insurance options that include products that protect second or seasonal homes, as well as flood and landlord insurance. The company also offers car, business, life, and recreational vehicle insurance. FMI also provides branding, search engine optimization, online marketing, and social media services. Frank Medina Insurance was voted best insurance agent on, is accredited with the Better Business Bureau, and is a SCORE mentor.

342 N Water St # 600
Milwaukee, WI 53202


Gramoll & Associates - American Family Insurance

Founded in 1994, Gramoll & Associates is a locally owned and operated independent insurance agency located in Shorewood, Wisconsin, and also serving customers in Arizona, Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota, and Utah. The team has eight licensed associates with a combined 60 years of experience in the insurance industry. Gramoll & Associates provides customized home coverage, and the policies cover dwellings, detached structures, personal belongings, temporary living expenses, and personal liability. Added coverage is available for equipment breakdown, water backup, and siding protection. The agency also offers life, auto, and business insurance services.

4484 N Oakland Ave
Shorewood, WI 53211


Jeff Van Dam - American Family Insurance

With more than 20 years working in the insurance industry, Jeff Van Dam founded American Family Insurance in 2013. The independent agency serves individuals and businesses in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and the surrounding area. One area of specialization is homeowners insurance. American Family Insurance works with multiple carriers to provide homeowners with a customized package designed to fit the individual's needs. Coverage protects the dwelling and everything in it from events such as theft, vandalism, fire, floods, tornadoes, ice, snow, and falling items. It also includes other's personal injury or property damage while on or as a result of the insured's property.

13620 W Capitol Dr Ste F
Brookfield, WI 53005


R&R Insurance Services

Founded in 1975, R & R Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency located in the Milwaukee, Wisconsin, metro area with offices in Waukesha, Appleton, Beaver Dam, Green Bay, and West Bend. Home coverage specialists work with several top-rated national and regional carriers to provide quality protection policies at competitive rates. Common plans cover the dwelling, personal items, temporary living costs, and liability against accidents on the homeowner's property. Additional coverage is available for flood, earthquake, and pet damage. The company also offers insurance for condos, renters, automobiles, and recreational vehicles, such as motorcycles, boats, ATVs, and RVs.

N14 W23900 Stone Ridge Drive
Waukesha, WI 53188


Reed Street Insurance Agency

Reed Street Insurance Agency provides assistance and sales services to clients seeking home insurance policies in the Milwaukee, Wisconsin, metro area. As an independent agency, it works with a wide variety of providers including Erie Insurance, Safeco Insurance, MetLife, and Progressive. Its agents consult clients on standard coverage areas and provide assistance with special categories including flood insurance, protection for high value items such as jewelry or art pieces, and liabilities inherent to the unique nature of the property. Reed Street Insurance Agency also provides auto insurance services both for individuals and businesses with wide-scale needs.

414 S 2nd St
Milwaukee, WI 53204



The Bellante Agency Inc. is an American Family insurance agency in Hales Corner, Wisconsin, that sells home insurance in the Milwaukee metropolitan area. Since 2011, the Bellante Agency has offered insurance products that protect homeowners against fire and smoke, damage from ice or snow, leaking roofs, theft, lightning, wildfires, hail, windstorms, riots or vandalism, power surges, and other unforeseen events that can damage homes or possessions. The agency also offers specific insurance policies that include coverage of cars, businesses, and RVs. The Bellante Agency is licensed in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Arizona.

11951 W Janesville Rd Ste C
Hales Corners, WI 53130


West Suburban Insurance Agency, LLC

West Suburban Insurance Agency, LLC. is an independent agency servicing the insurance needs of homeowners in Brookfield and Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and the surrounding area. It relies on its network of nationwide home insurance carrier partners to help local homeowners find the very best policies for their particular needs. Its agents analyze each customer's risks to help them select the right policy from the right insurer. In addition, the agency provides periodic reviews of clients' insurance coverage to be sure each customer is adequately insured. It also sells flood, auto, and personal umbrella policies.

13035 W Bluemound Rd Ste 104
Brookfield, WI 53005


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area