Best Insurance Agencies in Madison

12 Best Madison Insurance Agencies

  • Our selection process
  • View our top picks

We scored 65 Insurance Agencies in Madison, WI and Picked the Top 12

Abell Insurance Agency LLC serves clients in Madison and throughout its surrounding areas. This independent insurance agency specializes in personal insurance solutions, including life, home, and auto insurance. Policies are underwritten by carriers such as Erie Insurance, Progressive, and Madison Mutual Insurance Company. Customers can typically choose to bundle insurance policies for reduced monthly rates. Abell Insurance Agency LLC offers an online customer portal that allows its policyholders to file claims and make policy change requests online.

Anew Insurance Agency Inc. is an independent company whose agents have more than 50 years of combined experience arranging life and health polices for individuals and businesses. It represents more than 30 carriers, giving it plenty of scope to find its clients the best policy. Typical health polices include Individual and Family plans for the self-employed and Small Business/Group plans for new and growing businesses. The company also arranges insurance for special circumstances, such as weddings.

Cliff Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that's been serving clients in the Madison area since 1956. The company specializes in personal insurance solutions, including life insurance. Working with top carriers, its agents help clients shop around for adequate coverage at reasonable rates. Clients can generally choose from term, universal, or whole life insurance policies and are often able to customize their policy to include cash-out options and living benefits.

Evolve Insurance Solutions was founded in 2019 by Charles J. Busch after 11 years working for captive and independent agencies. The company can arrange a variety of insurances, including life and health. Partnered with more than 40 insurance providers, it can find polices to suit its client's coverage needs, whether it's a group plan for health or an individual life insurance plan. Evolve Insurance Solutions also arranges auto, business, home, and farm insurance policies.

Gary Ellis Insurance is a health insurance company in Madison. It works with a broad range of insurance carriers to provide its clients with life and health insurance options. Agents are careful to help clients analyze their needs and show them quotes and policies that are in line with what they're looking for. Life insurance options include permanent and term policies. Permanent policies include a death benefit and living benefits that can be accessed in the event of a critical illness or injury.

Keitel Group Insurance Inc. serves clients in the Madison area. It provides a variety of life and health insurance products for individuals and groups, including disability income insurance, annuities, and long-term care policies. The company's agents are dedicated to helping clients ensure they receive a product that's suited to both their needs and budget and work hard to compare quotes and policies on clients' behalves. Companies that Keitel Group Insurance Inc. represents include National Specialty Insurance, Illinois Mutual, and Progressive.

Red Barn Insurance Agency is a life insurance company in Madison. The company offers group and individual life insurance options, as well as long-term care insurance and small business health care tax credits. The company's owner and sole insurance agent is a certified dementia trainer who specializes in working with seniors and their loved ones. She is dedicated to helping her clients understand the insurance process and find an adequate policy that they can afford.

Ryan Gilbert Rural Mutual Insurance Agent provides life insurance policies for clients in the Madison metropolitan area. He has been working in the industry for more than two years, providing his clients with policies that protect the financial health of their loved ones after they're gone. In addition to insurance products, this independent agency also offers financial advisory and wealth management services. Clients can access their account online to make payments, view statements, and request policy changes.

Talcott Group LLC was founded in 1956. This privately held life insurance agency in Madison provides group and private life insurance policies, as well as disability income insurance plans for those who are unable to work due to illness or injury. When working with commercial clients, the company helps to create customized employee benefits plans. Talcott Group LLC worked exclusively with the Capital Area Health Consortium from 1993 to 2017 to provide disability insurance products that were specifically tailored to residents' needs.

The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America is a life insurance agency in Madison. The company exclusively specializes in group and individual life and health insurance and sells a broad range of policy options, including disability, dental, vision, critical illness, and cancer insurance. Health plans are managed within a single network to provide clients with an easy way to access care without a high co-pay. Life insurance options include universal, whole, and term policies.


Thomas Bradley Insurance is an independent life and health insurance company in Madison. Its agents are dedicated to assisting clients in finding the right coverage for their needs and take the time to learn about their family and finances before shopping for life and health insurance quotes from its network of insurance carriers. They aim to find policies that provide adequate financial coverage in the event of an unexpected medical emergency or death while staying within clients' budgets.

WIA Insurance is an independent insurance company. It objectively assesses the risks for each client and approaches several established insurance providers to arrange the best policy available within their budget. The company can arrange Final Expense insurance to pay for the funeral and burial costs of a loved one. It also arranges individual life insurance policies, available in term, universal, or whole life options, each offering different levels of payment options, flexibility, and coverage.

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: