Best Wedding
Cake Bakers in

Why These Wedding Cake Bakers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored wedding cake bakers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best wedding cake bakers in Buffalo, NY.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks825617

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Baby Cakes Cupcake Diner

Baby Cakes Cupcake Diner is a Niagara Falls-based provider of custom cupcakes, suitable for weddings and other special events in the Buffalo Metro. Pricing varies depending on the type of event, the size of the cake, and the flavor being used. Customers seeking a unique spin on the traditional wedding cake can order one of Baby Cakes Cupcake Diner's beautiful cupcake towers.

Niagara Falls, NY(716) 427-6575


Blackbird Sweets

Blackbird Sweets is a small, independent bakery operating in Buffalo. Professional cake artist Andrea Amodeo has been creating edible art for over eight years, for birthdays, baby showers, bridal showers, bachelorette parties, and weddings. For weddings, Ms. Amodeo makes beautiful cakes, in a variety of styles. Customers can order a cake easily by visiting the "Cake Request" page on Blackbird Sweets' website.

Buffalo, NY(716) 253-1115


Blessings Bakery

Blessings Bakery creates organic desserts for weddings and other events. The Buffalo-based business, which in 2016 won the "Couples' Choice Awards" from WeddingWire, offers free cake consultations. Clients can discuss their ideas, dietary restrictions, and budget, and the team will give them a chance to taste potential options. An enormous range of flavorings and fillings is available.

Buffalo, NY(716) 712-5256


Buffalo Cake Pops

Buffalo Cake Pops makes cake pops and other sweet treats for eaters in and around Buffalo. For weddings, the team often makes special wedding cake pops. Available flavors include brownie, carrot cake, banana bread, avocado pound cake, red velvet, lemon poppyseed, and white wedding cake, among others. Traditional wedding cakes are also available, in six-inch, eight-inch, 10-inch, and 12-inch sizes. Interested customers can easily order a wedding cake through the company's online order form.

Buffalo, NY(716) 992-0868


Cake Crazy Bakery & Gourmet Catering

Cake Crazy Bakery & Gourmet Catering sells home-style cookies, sweet potato tarts, fudgy brownies, lemon bars, and other pastries from its Cheektowaga location. Additionally, the staff operates a full-service catering facility, providing desserts as well as hors d'ouvres for buffets, private gatherings, and corporate events, as well as weddings. For images of the team's stunning cake art, customers should visit the Cake Crazy Bakery & Gourmet Catering website.

Cheektowaga, NY(716) 235-8002


Carol's Cake Cupboard

Carol's Cake Cupboard, in Lockport, makes custom wedding cakes for clients all over the greater Buffalo community. Opened in 1997, the business bakes all of its cakes fresh for the occasion, using buttercream icing. Carol is the owner and baker, and she provides all of her customers with one-on-one service, working with them to make sure that the final product matches their needs and preferences.

Lockport, NY(716) 434-5027


Creative Creations Cakery

At Creative Creations Cakery, based in West Seneca, Shannon Pilarski makes cake art for Buffalo Metro area clients. Ms. Pilarski, who appeared on two Food Network cooking competitions in 2010, sees her role as creating edible art. She leads a team of extremely qualified cake artists, who collaborate closely with clients to ensure that the final product's taste and appearance are to their liking.

West Seneca, NY(716) 998-2210


Dessert Deli

Dessert Deli is a cake shop in Williamsville that, since 1987, has catered to customers from all over the Buffalo Metro. Available products include cupcakes, birthday cakes, and cookies, as well as wedding cakes. Customers planning to order a wedding cake can browse the bakery's selection of gourmet, intricately designed cakes through its menu. Online ordering is available, with price quotes offered for made-to-order specialty cakes.

Williamsville, NY(716) 689-2115


Fairy Cakes Cupcakery, LLC

Fairy Cakes Cupcakery, LLC creates wedding cakes and other desserts for customers in the greater Buffalo community. At the shop, which is located directly across from the Buffalo Zoo, a small cooking staff prepares all cupcakes, pies, and cookies from scratch, using high-quality ingredients from local providers. In addition to traditional wedding cakes, Fairy Cakes Cupcakery, LLC can make wedding cupcake towers. Interested potential clients should contact the business at least a week in advance to ensure availability.

Buffalo, NY(716) 688-0361


Just Say Cheesecake

Just Say Cheesecake is a bakery that, since it opened in 1990, has made countless customized wedding cakes. Brothers Jim and Dan bake traditional cake batter, using a recipe they learned from their grandmother. The business, located in Amherst, started out as a booth at a local farmer's market, where the brothers sold cheesecake.

Amherst, NY(716) 833-7233


Kith & Kin Bakeshop & Bistro

Kith & Kin Bakeshop & Bistro is a 100% gluten-free bakery in Lockport that makes pizzas, rolls, muffins, cupcakes, cookies, corn dogs, pierogies, pies, and quick bread, as well as cakes. Gluten-free customers planning a wedding can use the business's online ordering form to set up a free initial consultation.

Lockport, NY(716) 471-3305


Muscoreil's Fine Desserts & Gourmet Cakes

Since it opened its doors over 20 years ago, Muscoreil's Fine Desserts & Gourmet Cakes has crafted and served over 20,000 wedding cakes for Buffalo Metro area weddings. The bakery, located in North Tonawanda, uses ingredients that are fresh, never frozen. The staff includes more than 50 professionals, including not just chefs and culinary experts, but also designers and sculptors. These visual artists ensure that each of Muscoreil's Fine Desserts & Gourmet Cakes' productions is not just a culinary masterpiece, but an artistic masterpiece.

North Tonawanda, NY(716) 692-9081


Ohlson's Bakery

Ohlson's Bakery sells European-style pastries at its cafe location, which is open six days a week, pours fresh coffee using Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters beans, and has free Wi-Fi. Customers seeking a unique, artistic wedding cake can order one from the professionals at Ohlson's Bakery, who will create a visually appealing and delicious piece of cake art that is perfectly suited to the wedding. Delivery service is available.

Williamsville, NY(716) 626-7783


Romano's Italian Bakery

Romano's Italian Bakery is a Tonawanda bakery that creates wedding cakes, among other desserts. The business has been operating locally for more than four decades, during which time it has gradually expanded in size and reputation. Interested clients should view the Romano's Italian Bakery for a portfolio of past wedding cakes. This will give them a sense of the styles from which they can choose.

Tonawanda, NY(716) 837-2266


Sweet Beginnings Bakery

Since it opened in 2005, Sweet Beginnings Bakery has created wedding cakes and other specialty desserts for discerning eaters from throughout the Buffalo area. Leading the business is the husband-and-wife team of Darren and Jamie Wells. Jamie Wells, a graduate of Alfred State College's Culinary Arts program, and Darren Wells, who has a Baking degree from the Erie Community College Culinary Arts program, create custom cakes according to their clients' needs and specifications. In the Sweet Beginnings Bakery portfolio, clients can view images of their previous cake art.

Tonawanda, NY(716) 875-1431


The Village Bake Shoppe

The Village Bake Shoppe sells cookies, cakes, and other baked goods, both online and at its shop in Lewiston. Located near the Niagara River waterfront, it has been providing Buffalo Metro eaters with sweet treats since 1993. Customers seeking a wedding cake can order a dessert that will feed anywhere from five to 500 people. Available fillings include mousse, jam, cream cheese, and buttercream, with an array of cake flavors also offered. Clients who are gluten-free, dairy-free, sugar-free, or have other dietary restrictions can order cakes to suit their needs.

Lewiston, NY(716) 754-2300


Wolter's Bakery Inc.

Wolter's Bakery Inc., located in Williamsville's Georgetown Square, is a family-owned bakery that Heino Wolter founded in 1957. Now Mr. Wolter's daughter, Wendi, makes the same pastries her father made, including Danish pastries, French tarts, and German kuchen. Recently, Wolter's Bakery Inc. opened a secondary location on Transit Road. Because Wolter's Bakery Inc.'s services are in high demand, clients who want to order a wedding cake should contact the business well in advance.

Williamsville, NY(716) 632-3212


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: