Laurels
Best Caterers
in Buffalo
2018

Why These Caterers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored caterers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best caterers in Buffalo, NY.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks775420

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Buffalos Best Grill

Buffalos Best Grill handles catering in Orchard Park. Customers can choose to hold an event at the grill or pick another location, and Buffalos will "bring the party." The company is the exclusive caterer for Kissing Bridge Ski Resort, is a featured vendor at The Botanocal Gardens and The Frank Lloyd Wright Boat House, and has often been the Backstage Caterer for concerts at Darien Lake. The group is known for working closely with clients to custom create packages for their needs and budgets.

Orchard Park, NY(716) 202-1270

Website

Cecelia's

Cecelia's has been catering in the Buffalo area for 15 years. The restaurant combines homemade Italian cooking with international flavors, and customers can order drop-off as well as in-house catering services for most any event including birthdays, anniversaries, holiday parties, retirements, and communions. Casual as well as formal menus are available, and contact information for the chef and owner can be found directly online for inquiries.

Buffalo, NY(716) 883-8066

Website

Chef’s Restaurant

Chef’s Restaurant dates all the way back to 1923 and caters for the Buffalo community. The famous Italian eatery provides drop-off buffet catering for a minimum of 20 people in disposable display containers and also offers full banquet services at its own location for up to 125 guests. Customers use the facility for breakfasts, lunches, and dinners for business gatherings, social events, holiday parties, and wedding receptions.

Buffalo, NY(716) 856-9187

Website

Claudette's Catering

Claudette's Catering has been an Amherst catering company for over 30 years. The group follows the motto of "Homecooking with a Personal Touch" and offers both à la carte and full service options for occasions with anywhere from two to 4,000 guests at any location. Dop-off services, pick-up packages, and take out options are also available, and menus can be viewed on Claudette's website.

Amherst, NY(716) 691-3315

Website

Country Club Catering

Country Club Catering is a Lake View catering company. The family-owned group provides top-notch guest experiences and quality food for a range of events including weddings, graduation parties, corporate events, communions, and family picnics. Customers appreciate the ability to choose from seasonal menus using ingredients sourced from local farms, and chefs can also accommodate customized menus, gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian items, and food sensitivities. The company won Top Caterers Off Site in 2014 from Buffalo Business First.

Lake View, NY(716) 713-6495

Website

Cozy Café & Catering

Cozy Café & Catering handles catering in Clarence. Customers can view and download the entire catering menu online, and services are available for corporate drop-offs, family reunions, breakfast meetings, and on-site full service as well. Menu options include breakfast, lunch boxes, dinner, homemade desserts, and Tea Party and Baby Shower packages as well as various hors d'oeuvres, platters, party salads, hot trays and sides, and homemade soups.

Clarence, NY(716) 631-9060

Website

Frontier Catering

Frontier Catering has served the West Seneca community with catering for over 25 years. The company is known for exceptional service, affordable pricing, attention to detail, and surpassing expectations and handles every aspect of an event from the location, linens, and decor to the menus tailored to each client's style and budget. Services include weddings, company picnics, grand openings, holiday parties, and dinner banquets.

West Seneca, NY(716) 674-4455

Website

Joseph's Catering Service

Joseph's Catering Service has been catering in the Depew area since 1975. Customers can opt to use the company's location or one of their own choice and view and download various menus online for breakfast, lunch, and dinner as well as for station service, funeral fare, and picnics. Joseph's won a WeddingWire Couples' Choice Award in 2014 and 2015 and was voted best Buffalo Wedding Caterer by thousands of brides on The Knot.

Depew, NY(716) 681-4538

Website

Lloyd Taco Trucks

Lloyd Taco Trucks has been a Buffalo catering company since 2010. The team sources from local farms, uses antibiotic/hormone free meats and organic black beans, and makes its own hot sauce. Services include truck-on-site catering for formal gatherings, family get-togethers, and wedding midnight taco bars. Drop-off catering is also available with five separate options for Taco Bars, Pre-Rolled Burritos, and a Tricked Out Nacho Bar as well as various extras such as guacamole.

Buffalo, NY(716) 863-9781

Website

Michael's Catering & Banquets

Michael's Catering & Banquets handles catering in Hamburg. The second-generation family-owned company offers full-service banquet management and kitchen staff to cater for events with anywhere from 15 to 700 guests in one of its five banquet rooms. Clients can also request full buffets or party trays for any outside location within 45 minutes of Michael's with complete party planners available or just servers for the food provided.

Hamburg, NY(716) 649-4038

Website

Mister Pizza Elmwood

Mister Pizza Elmwood caters for Buffalo residents. Aside from traditional and Specialty Pizzas, the spot also sells chicken wings, salads, subs, hoagies, tacos, wraps, dinners, and salads. The Family & Party Paks combine pizza with wings, and delivery to homes and businesses is available seven days a week. Mister Pizza has a reputation for its handmade Italian dishes made from fresh ingredients, and a complete Catering Menu is available as well.

Buffalo, NY(716) 882-6500

Website

Mythos

Mythos is a catering company serving the Buffalo community. The group offers up traditional Greek cuisine and can cater for employee meetings, business meetings, corporate entertaining, family reunions, anniversary parties, and fundraising galas of 10 to 100 guests with a variety of services including Party Platters, Banquet Buffet, and Light Luncheons. Mythos helps clients create a menu for their specific event, and customers should call for more information.

Buffalo, NY(716) 886-9175

Website

Oliver’s

Oliver’s is a Buffalo catering service. The restaurant opened up back in 1936 and today is the exclusive caterer for several venues including the Buffalo History Museum and Kleinhans Music Hall. Clients can see a full venue list online as well as peruse possible menus, and the group is known for its attention to every detail and working with each client's individual style and budget to create a special event.

Buffalo, NY(716) 877-9662

Website

Paula’s Donuts®

Paula’s Donuts® has been catering in Tonawanda since 1996. The shop is family-owned and features 30 unique varieties of freshly-baked, hand-cut donuts such as Glazed Sour Cream and Toasted Coconut Custard. Other items include pastries, muffins, bagels, breakfast sandwiches, carrot cake, coffee, tea, and other beverages. Clients can fill out and send in an online form to request special event and catering services, and Paula's has been fetaured online at The Buffalo News.

Tonawanda, NY(716) 862-4246

Website

Pizza Plant Italian Pub

Pizza Plant Italian Pub is a Buffalo catering company. Customers can order from a full menu of catering trays for delivery including salads, appetizers, wraps, meats, pasta, and veggies or can order à la carte catering and packages at Pizza Plant's banquet facilities for up to 50 people. The room features a 10-foor projection screen, integrated wireless microphone, and easy computer connectivity, and gluten-free menu options are available.

Buffalo, NY(716) 632-0800

Website

Prima Pizza & Pasta

Prima Pizza & Pasta has been serving the Buffalo area with catering since 1976. The family-owned pizzeria is known for quality ingredients and offers a catering menu for parties, events, and meetings including Hot Drop-Off Full Buffet, Hot Drop Off Lunch, Party Trays & Platters, Main Entrées, Salads, Subs & Wraps, Desserts, and Beverages. Box Lunches and Compliments are also available, and customers must phone in their orders.

Buffalo, NY(716) 852-5555

Website

Private Knives Gourmet Catering & Events

Private Knives Gourmet Catering & Events handles catering for Lancaster residents. The boutique catering and events production house has a reputation for cutting-edge design and cuisine and offers personalized menus, signature cocktails, and locally-grown organic produce for events including cocktail parties of 200 guests, weddings, and family-style dinners. The group also handles floral decor, event design, and management services including custom printed menus and rentals. Private Knives won Best of Thumbtack 2015.

Lancaster, NY(716) 361-7325

Website

Rich’s Catering & Special Events

Rich’s Catering & Special Events caters for Buffalo residents and businesses. The on-site and off-site service handles everything from weddings to picnics to corporate drop-offs with fully customizable menus. Clients have access to other event services as well including event planners, linens, and uplighting as well as an on-site venue for up to 600 guests. Rich's won a WeddingWire Couples' Choice Award twice, was voted WNY's Best Caterer by Buffalo Spree Magazine, and is a member of the Buffalo Bridal Association.

Buffalo, NY(716) 878-8211

Website

Siena Restaurant

Siena Restaurant is a catering company in Snyder. The spot is known for its contemporary Italian dishes and authentic pizzas with staff trained by a master pizzaiolo from Italy. Customers can order drop-off catering in disposable packaging or with servers and chef with a 48-hour notice or use the restaurant's banquet venue for full luncheons, corporate events, and social gatherings.

Snyder, NY(716) 839-3108

Website

Sun Restaurant

Sun Restaurant has been providing catering in the Buffalo area since 2012. The Burmese and Thai bistro features innovative Asian cuisine, sushi, a Black Rice Bar, and the first complete Black Rice menu with a customizable menu for catering lunches, dinner parties, and business meetings. Customers can view the full catering menu online, and Sun has been featured on Buffalo News.

Buffalo, NY(716) 447-0202

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: