Best Wedding
Cake Bakers in

Why These Wedding Cake Bakers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored wedding cake bakers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best wedding cake bakers in Rochester, NY.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks684818

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Cheesy Eddie's

Cheesy Eddie's has been a Rochester favorite since 1976, serving homemade pastries, cheesecakes, and custom cakes for weddings and special events. The company's bakers make unique, artistic weddings cakes designed to perfectly highlight the wedding's theme, colors, and style, offered in a range of sizes and shapes for a custom look. Customers can order dessert trays for parties and family gathering, or stop by the bakery and choose from a large selection of fresh-baked cookies, brownies, and tarts for an afternoon treat.

Rochester, NY(585) 473-1300


Delicious Designs by Sherry Thomas

Delicious Designs by Sherry Thomas is a Marion custom cake company that offers gourmet wedding and event cakes designed to please any taste and style. The company's baker has more than 345 years of professional experience in creating beautiful wedding cakes, and customers can choose from options like almond, fudge, vanilla, or buttercream frosting, handmade sugar flowers, or real fresh flowers. Customers can call the company to schedule an in-person consultation to design the perfect cake for any special event.

Marion, NY(315) 926-4887


Donna Marie's Gluten Free Bakery

Donna Marie's Gluten Free Bakery is Rochester's first official gluten-free bakery, using the finest ingredients and special facilities guaranteed to be safe for customers with celiac's and gluten intolerance issues. The company also offers options for customers sensitive to soy, peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, corn, and eggs, providing an amazing selection of treats for people with limited diets. The company specializes in creating custom weddings cakes, beautifully decorated and baked with the customer's allergies and diet in mind.

Rochester, NY(585) 254-0706


Genesee Bakery and Deli

Customers love the friendly staff and top-quality menu at Genesee Bakery and Deli. The company offer handmade sandwiches, subs, and pastries, made fresh with the finest ingredients. The company also offers custom wedding cakes in a range of flavors like chocolate, carrot, red velvet, and marble, and customers can rent cake stands and fountains for extra savings and convenience. Customers can stop by the deli for lunch, or to enjoy a selection of gourmet pastries like cannolis, apple dumplings, pie, and strudel.

Rochester, NY(585) 244-5360


Get Caked

Get Caked is an award-winning gourmet bakery that offers a range of traditional desserts, custom cakes, and treats for people with food allergies and special diets. The company's bakers can accommodate gluten-free, kosher, and vegan diets, letting customers enjoy delicious desserts full of natural flavors. The company offers custom wedding cakes starting at just $2.75 per serving, as well as custom cakes for birthdays, retirement parties, religious ceremonies, and other special events. Customers can call or stop by the bakery to request a custom cake.

Rochester, NY(585) 319-4314


Gruttadauria Bakery

Gruttadauria Bakery has earned the reputation as "The best Italian Bakery in Rochester', offering a selection of freshly made pastries and cakes created with the finest ingredients and four generations of baking experience. The company specializes in creating custom wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and special event cakes, and customers can order a sweets table full of delicious treats for parties and events. The bakery also sells a range of fresh cookies, Taralli, Cucidati, and cannoli, as well as pizza and gelato.

Rochester, NY(585) 454-6979


Incredibly Edible Cookie Company

Incredibly Edible Cookie Company is an artisanal bakery that offers an extensive selection, of fresh, creative treats for special events and everyday enjoyment. The company's bakers make delicious cookies, brownies, and bars, using fresh ingredients and a passion for sweets. The company also offers world-class wedding cakes, custom-designed and decorated to highlight the wedding theme and colors perfectly. Customers can purchase gift assortments for friends and loved ones, or order gourmet custom desserts for parties and special occasions.

Penfield, NY(585) 455-9213


J-Cakes Bakery

The artistic bakers and friendly staff at J-Cakes Bakery are committed to providing the highest quality of service and offer a range of handmade cakes and cookies to suit any taste. Customers can order creative custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, christenings, and any special event, and choose from delicious cake flavors like apple spice, raspberry coconut, almond, and red velvet. The company also makes custom decorated cupcakes, mini cannoli trays, and gourmet cookie trays filled with freshly made treats.

Rochester, NY(585) 216-5316


Martusciello's Bakery

Martusciello's Bakery has been a local favorite for more than 50 years, offering an extensive selection of fresh deli foods and baked goods made with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Customers can stop by the bakery to enjoy a fresh-made sub, pizza, or pie, or top pick up a loaf of Martusciello's famous bread. The company also makes custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, and special occasions, filled with delicious flavors like raspberry jam, whipped cream, and Bavarian cream.

Rochester, NY(585) 247-0510


Rochester NY Wedding Cakes

Rochester NY Wedding Cakes provides custom made cakes for weddings and special events, and the company's award-winning Executive Pastry Chef is passionate about creating amazing, artistic, and one-of-a-kind cakes using the freshest natural ingredients. The company's website features an extensive list of cake, filling, and frosting flavors, including gourmet flavors like Italian lemon curd, lemon and mixed berry mascarpone, and carrot and cherry amaretto. The company also offers custom cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, retirement parties, and other special occasions.

Rochester, NY(585) 366-4749


Savoia Pastry Shoppe

Savoia Pastry Shoppe has been serving world-class homemade treats since 1929. The company sells freshly made cookies, cakes, and pies, as well as breads, pizzas, and pastries made with the finest ingredients and a dedication to quality. Customers in Rochester have been coming to Savoia Pastry Shoppe for generations to buy delicious custom wedding cakes, decorated to match the wedding theme and colors, and prices start as low as $67 for a two-tier wedding cake. The company also offers pastry trays for parties and events.

Rochester, NY(585) 482-1130


Scratch Bakeshop

The talented artists at Scratch Bakeshop have been making creative, unique, delicious treats since 2013, using the freshest ingredients to create customized desserts for every taste. The company offers custom wedding cake design, gourmet cupcakes, shortbread cookies, brownies, and French macarons, and specialized desserts can be made for customers with food allergies, food sensitivities, and special diet restrictions. Customers can call, stop by the shop, or use the contact form on the company's website to order custom cakes and treats.

Rochester, NY(585) 360-4844


Sinful Sweets

Sinful Sweets is an innovative artisan bakery that serves homemade treats with a creative twist. The company sells freshly made cupcakes, sheet cakes, and art cakes filled with sinfully delicious flavors like vanilla-bacon, dark chocolate stout, pink champagne, and spiced chocolate-chili. The company makes specialty cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, and special events, and world-class wedding cakes using the latest decorating techniques to make amazing, creative, edible works of art. Customers can call the company to schedule a wedding cake consultation.

Rochester, NY(585) 483-0349


Something Delicious Bake Shop

Something Delicious Bake Shop is a Rochester bakery that specializes in wedding cakes and delicious, homemade treats. The company's wedding services include an initial consultation to let customers taste samples and choose from a range of amazing flavors, designs, and shapes. Custom cakes are also available for birthdays, anniversaries, and special events, and the company's bakers make a variety of fresh cupcakes in flavors like Oreo cookie, lemon blueberry, Boston cream, and almond raspberry, and French macaroons in a range of flavors.

Rochester, NY(585) 730-7876


Sweet Melissa's Bake Shoppe

Sweet Melissa's Bake Shoppe is an award-winning custom order bakery that offers artistic sweets, gluten-free options, and first-class customer service. The company's bakers specialize in creating beautiful, innovative wedding cakes, decorated to match the theme and colors and exceed expectations. Customers can choose from a range of cake flavors like key lime, red velvet, Guinness chocolate, and apple spice, and filling flavors like Bavarian cream, creamsicle, and Bailey's Irish buttercream. Custom cakes are also available for birthdays and other special occasions.

Fairport, NY(585) 729-3168


Sweet Memories by Marina Sarra Barigelli

Sweet Memories by Marina Sarra Barigelli is a custom cake company that offers creative, artistic, edible art for weddings and special events. Customers can choose a buttercream cake starting at $3.25 per slice, or a rolled fondant cake for an extra artistic touch, starting at $4.25 per slice. Special occasion cakes are available for smaller events starting at $1.20 per slice. The company's bakers also create a selection of elegant Italian cookies like almond paste macarons, Neapolitans, chocolate dipped shells, and fruit filled sandwiches.

Rochester, NY(585) 426-7079


Sweet Sammie Jane's

Sweet Sammie Jane's is a family-owned pastry shop and catering company that offers traditional baked treats the whole family will enjoy. Customers can stop by the bakery to try the homemade cookies, cupcakes, macarons, and custom cakes, filled with natural flavors and high-quality ingredients. The company designs custom wedding cakes and offers a fun dessert truck that can be rented to cater to parties, weddings, and special events, and the catering menu can be downloaded from the company's website.

Rochester, NY(585) 474-3100


Sweets By OMG

Sweets By OMG is a Rochester specialty cake company that designs creative custom cakes for special occasions of all kinds. Customers can look at the custom cake photo galleries on the company's website for inspiration, custom decorated to meet and exceed every customer's expectations. The company offers wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and anniversary cakes, filled with natural flavors and fillings like chocolate, vanilla, lemon, fudge, blueberry, and raspberry. Customers can call the company to request a custom cake.

Rochester, NY(585) 698-1561


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: