hero image

Best Car Insurance Agencies in Winston Salem

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Winston Salem Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 135 85 12

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Affordable Insurance Services, LLC

Affordable Insurance Services LLC is an independent agency based in Winston Salem, North Carolina, serving the surrounding areas since 1992. The agency is an auto insurance specialist that provides policies for motor homes, motorcycles, and for drivers with DWI on their records. It searches the policies of its many insurance carriers to find one that will fit the needs of their clients, including inexperienced drivers and those with previously canceled policies. The agency offers discounts for drivers with good records.

3635 Reynolda Rd Ste A
Winston Salem, NC 27106


Alliance Insurance Services LLC

Founded in 2004, the Alliance Insurance Services LLC is an independent insurance agency located in Winston Salem, North Carolina, with other offices in Mount Airy, Salisbury, and Walnut Cove. Auto policy specialists work with several carriers to help drivers find the right amount of coverage at a competitive rate. Options include the minimum amount to cover property damage and bodily injury liability, and drivers can add extra protection with collision and comprehensive, and uninsured and underinsured motorists coverage.

348 Summit Square Blvd
Winston Salem, NC 27105


Fortress Insurance Group

Located in Clemmons, North Carolina, the Fortress Insurance Group is an agency that provides independent insurance advice to its English and Spanish-speaking clients throughout the Winston Salem metro area. Founded in 2002, the personal and commercial auto insurance specialist tailors policies provided by its partners and ensures its clients understand the details and are introduced to recommended and optional add-ons. These can include roadside assistance, protection against accidents involving uninsured/underinsured drivers, and umbrella insurance to protect against the unexpected.

2255 Lewisville Clemmons Rd Ste C
Clemmons, NC 27012


Jones and Peacock Insurance

Located in High Point, North Carolina, Jones and Peacock Insurance is an independent insurance agency that has served Winston Salem area residents since 1917. The agency partners with a variety of carriers to provide car, truck, and motorcycle owners auto insurance that includes an array of coverages such as liability, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist. Travelers and The Hartford are just a couple of its partners. Jones and Peacock Insurance also offers earthquake and homeowners insurance.

1812 Eastchester Dr
High Point, NC 27265


Mark Thompson Insurance

Mark Thompson Insurance is based in High Point, North Carolina, and was founded in 1999. The company offers auto insurance services, including car and motorcycle coverage, non-owner insurance, and policies for motorists who have recent DUI/DWI offenses. Additionally, the company caters to private individuals and commercial drivers. Discounts are available for good drivers and owners of multiple vehicles. Mark Thompson Insurance also provides home, life, commercial, and workers' compensation policies.

810 Eastchester Dr
High Point, NC 27262


Piedmont Triad Insurance

Piedmont Triad Insurance is an independent insurance company in Winston Salem, North Carolina, that represents over 20 highly-rated insurance providers. With locations in Wentworth, Greensboro, and Jamestown, Piedmont provides motorists across the state with auto insurance solutions. Comprehensive coverage generally includes reimbursement of losses from theft, natural disaster, and fires. Piedmont Triad offers renters, travel, and motor home insurance policies. The agency also works in the business and life insurance industries.

300 W 7th St
Winston Salem, NC 27101


Protective Insurance Agency, Inc.

Protective Insurance Agency Inc. serves the Winston Salem, North Carolina, metro area, working on behalf of clients to find rates for auto insurance policies. The agency commonly procures coverage for bodily injury, liability, collision, and comprehensive circumstances as mandated by law, and it explores additional coverage areas upon client request. This company is versed in low cost auto insurance, and its business model focuses on obtaining the lowest possible rates for clients seeking discount policies.

653 Peters Creek Pkwy
Winston Salem, NC 27103


Summit Insurance Agency, Inc.

Founded in 1986, Summit Insurance Agency Inc. is an independent insurance company located in the Winston Salem, North Carolina, metro area. Auto experts work with several A-rated carriers, including AAA, Diaryland Auto & Cycle Insurance, and Progressive, to help drivers get the right policy. Options include liability, collision, comprehensive, non-driver, and medical coverage. Summit Insurance Agency Inc. also handles home, renters, umbrella and commercial auto, property, trucking, and general and excess liability policies.

2605 Randleman Rd Ste B
Greensboro, NC 27406


The Phoenix Company

Founded in 1932, The Phoenix Company is an insurance company based in Winston Salem, North Carolina. To provide clients with a range of auto insurance solutions, the company works with multiple insurance companies and is a member of the Correll Insurance Group. Agents work with clients to develop a personalized auto insurance plan to provide coverage for property damage, bodily injury, and physical damage. The Phoenix Company is also able to provide coverage for businesses, homes, and life insurance.

1396 Westgate Center Dr
Winston Salem, NC 27103


Whitley-Reavis Insurance

Whitley-Reavis Insurance, formerly known as Roy A. Whitley, Jr. General Insurance, was founded in 1977. It's a family-owned and operated business that offers auto insurance from a wide range of top-rated carriers. It has policies for all types of vehicles, including cars, trucks, motorcycles, RVs, and snowmobiles. In addition to auto insurance, Whitley-Reavis Insurance sells high net worth, travel, valuable items, home, and boat insurance policies. Its carrier partners include Progressive and Nationwide.

6201 Towncenter Dr Ste 110
Clemmons, NC 27012


Wilson Insurance Services

Wilson Insurance Services Inc. is headquartered in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, and serves drivers all over the state. Its auto insurance policies are affordable and include liability coverage, as well as optional collision, personal injury, medical payments, and comprehensive coverage. In addition to standard auto insurance, the company provides rental car insurance, as well as home insurance options to renters and homeowners. Wilson Insurance Services Inc. is a Trusted Choice independent insurance agent.

3288 Robinhood Rd Ste 102
Winston Salem, NC 27106


Worley Insurance Agency

Worley Insurance Agency has been offering auto insurance policies to drivers in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, and surrounding areas since 1982. Its coverage options include comprehensive, collision, liability, underinsured motorist, and medical payments insurance. It works with a variety of insurance providers to find adequate coverage for its clients at the lowest possible rates. In addition to auto insurance, Worley Insurance Agency offers disability, health, life, and homeowners insurance, as well as financial services, including retirement planning and financial planning.

107 N Main St
Lexington, NC 27292


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: