Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Durham

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Durham Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 136 85 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

All About Insurance

Since 1993, All About Insurance has worked with Nationwide Insurance Company to provide a variety of insurance solutions to residents of Durham, North Carolina, as well as those living in Chapel Hill, Raleigh, Eden, Burlington, Cary, Garner, Graham, Hillsborough and Madison. It specializes in offering home insurance, with coverage options that include property, homeowners liability, condo, scheduled property, in-home business, and landlord insurance. All About Insurance is affiliated with the Greater Durham Chamber of Commerce.

3604 University Dr
Durham, NC 27707


Bull City Insurance

Bull City Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Durham, North Carolina, leveraging years of industry expertise for homeowners in search of quality home insurance. Its agents strive to analyze the insurance needs of every client based on risks and protection of assets. Agents then assist homeowners in finding the right policies with deductibles and premiums they can manage from a network of trusted insurance carriers to safeguard against common perils, loss, and liability.

4819 Emperor Blvd Ste 400
Durham, NC 27703


Dominick Huckabee Noblin & Trent Insurance Agency

Founded in 1987, the Dominick, Huckabee, Noblin, & Trent (DHN&T) Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company located in Durham, North Carolina. The company serves clients with personal and commercial insurance needs. DHN&T works with a select group of insurance providers to deliver homeowners and personal property coverage. As an independent agency, DHN&T offers clients liability, collision, and medical options to fit their auto insurance needs. Whether a new retail shop or an established manufacturer, DHN&T matches the right program with the business.

3604 Shannon Rd Ste 105
Durham, NC 27707


High & Rubish Insurance Agency

Founded in 1963, the High & Rubish Insurance Agency is located in Chapel Hill and proudly serves the entire state of North Carolina, including the Durham area. Partnered with reputable insurance carriers such as Erie Insurance, Builders Mutual, and Progressive, the agency helps homeowners and farmers secure home insurance policies that protect their properties against liability and loss from damage due to natural disasters. High & Rubish Insurance Agency also assists individuals, families, and businesses with auto, pet, and group insurance plans.

6015 Farrington Rd Ste 101
Chapel Hill, NC 27517


Insurance of the Carolinas

Insurance of the Carolinas is a full-service insurance agency located in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Established in 1960, Insurance of the Carolinas has three other office locations throughout the state and works with homeowners to provide insurance coverages for dwellings, personal property, loss of use, and liability. The professionals at Insurance of the Carolinas also offer solutions for condos and rental units. Other areas of coverage include earthquake, flood, health, and life.

112 Perkins Dr Ste 100
Chapel Hill, NC 27514


Insurance People of North Carolina

Insurance People of North Carolina is an independent insurance agency serving homeowners and renters in the Durham, North Carolina, area and throughout the state. Insurance People partners with a variety of insurance companies, including Bankers, Chubb, Mutual of Omaha, Safeco, and Travelers. The agency offers packaged and comprehensive home insurance solutions, including homeowners, renters, condo, and secondary home insurance. Other types of insurance provided by Insurance People include auto, business, and watercraft.

1920 Front St Ste 750
Durham, NC 27705


Joyner Insurance Agency

Joyner Insurance Agency is an Independent company in Cary, North Carolina. The agency offers a wide variety of home insurance plans from their partnered insurance companies. The home insurance package covers properties from natural disasters, including floods, fire, and other hazards. Homeowners can also benefit from the company's unique condominium insurance policy, which provides liability and personal property coverage for fixtures, walls, floors, and cabinets. Joyner Insurance Agency also offers auto, business, and life insurance coverage.

200 Cornerstone Dr Ste 202
Cary, NC 27519


Superior Insurance

Superior Insurance, located in Durham, North Carolina, is a multi-office insurance agency serving the Raleigh-Durham area. The company's homeowners policy covers damage from most disasters, which includes the home's structure, personal belongings, liability, and living expenses in the case of relocation due to damage. The agency also offers supplementary coverage for floods and earthquakes. Offering an array of personal insurance plans, the agency works with six different insurance carriers to provide homeowners, auto, motorcycle, boat, business, and life insurance.

3825 S Roxboro St Ste 118 # Ste
Durham, NC 27713


Superior Insurance of Durham

Superior Insurance of Durham is an agency that provides its clients with independent advice and services. Located in Durham, North Carolina, the home insurance specialist searches for the right policy from its list of carriers, then tailors the policy to their client's unique circumstances. The agency provides services for condos with single occupants to estates with large families, ensuring their clients have appropriate coverage and that they understand the benefits and limitations of their coverage.

3825 S Roxboro St Ste 118
Durham, NC 27713


The Insurance Pros

The Insurance Pros in Durham, North Carolina, is an independent insurance agency that provides home insurance, commercial coverage, and other insurance products to people in the Durham metropolitan area. Founded in 2008, the agency provides home insurance coverage that includes protection against liability as well as damage or destruction of structures on the premises. The Insurance Pros won the F. W. Hirt Quality Agency Award in 2015 from Erie Insurance.

1210 Cole Mill Rd Ste 101
Durham, NC 27705


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area