Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Louisville

Laurels

We did the research for you!

Licensing
User Reviews
Mystery Shopping Calls

Local Car Insurance Agencies FAQs 〉

Local Car Insurance Agencies FAQs

Last updated: October 1, 2022

Assure America

806 Stone Creek Pkwy, Suite #11, Louisville, KY 40223

Assure America is an independent agency that caters to individuals, families, and businesses in the Louisville metro and the surrounding communities. It offers full coverage auto insurance policies, which pay for medical expenses and damage caused to the policyholder's car and another driver's car. Other types of car insurance coverages such as collision, comprehensive, and liability are also available. In addition, the firm provides health, home, and life insurance plans. Assure America has been operating since 1920. It represents carriers like Aetna, Progressive, and Travelers.

Bluegrass Insurance Advisors, LLC

9850 Von Allmen Court, Louisville, KY 40241

Auto Insurance

Bluegrass Insurance Advisors, LLC, is an agency that provides its products and services to clients in Louisville and the surrounding areas. One of its products includes auto insurance which offers financial protection against theft of and damage to the vehicle. It offers coverages for uninsured motorists, bodily injury liability, and medical payments. Bluegrass Insurance Advisors aims to protect families and individuals, as well as their assets. Its other products include home, life, disability, renters, business, and ATV insurance.

Carr Insurance

102 Daventry Ln Ste 2, Louisville, KY 40223

Founded in 1975, Carr Insurance provides automobile insurance coverage to clients in Louisville, Kentucky. With additional locations in Centerville, Ohio, and Knoxville, Tennessee, the independent agency collaborates with clients to complete a comprehensive needs assessment to find the right coverage for individuals and families. Carr Insurance apprises clients on the state legal requirements for automobile insurance and advises them on adding additional coverages for property damage, bodily injury liability, medical payments, and underinsured/uninsured motorists.

Clear Choice Insurance

6801 Dixie Hwy 216, Louisville, KY 40258

Bundling Option

Clear Choice Insurance caters to individuals and businesses in the Louisville area. Car owners can get coverage for the aftermath of a road crash, such as vehicle repairs and medical bills for injured occupants. The policy also provides compensation for theft, vandalism, and damage caused by uninsured drivers. In addition, Clear Choice Insurance offers policies for other vehicles, like boats, ATVs, RVs, and motorcycles. It has commercial insurance for worker compensation claims and general liability suits.

Cornerstone Insurance Agency, LLC

7321 New La Grange Road Suite 140, Louisville, KY 40222

Multiple Carriers
Bundling Option

Cornerstone Insurance Agency, LLC, serves individuals, families, and businesses throughout Louisville and the neighboring areas. This multi-line insurance solutions company protects drivers and motorists against accidents, liabilities, and uninsured drivers with an auto insurance policy. Its independent agents have an extensive network of insurance providers that can provide customers with coverage that suits their needs and resources. The agency's other insurance lines include life, commercial, health, and homeowners' insurance policies.

Dick Watts Insurance

12200 Shelbyville Rd #112, Louisville, KY 40243

Bundling Option

Dick Watts Insurance is a family-owned independent agency that caters to individuals, families, and businesses in the Louisville metro. It offers a wide variety of insurance products, including personal auto, commercial auto, homeowners', and renters'. Its car insurance plans are designed to cover expenses in repairing damage caused by collisions, thefts, and natural disasters. The local agency also provides coverage for bodily injury, uninsured, and underinsured liabilities. Dick Watts Insurance has been in the industry for more than 20 years.

Dolack Insurance Agency

4050 Westport Rd, Suite 206, Louisville, KY 40207

Boats

Since 1956, Dolack Insurance Agency has been serving individuals and families in Louisville. Its agents offer personal line products, including car insurance covering medical payments, liability collisions, and roadside assistance. They also provide insurance products for ATVs, boats, motorcycles, and classic cars. In addition, they walk clients through the process of choosing life, health, home, and business insurance policies from various providers like Progressive, MetLife, and The Hartford, including filing for claims. The agency's business insurance products include bonds, EPLI, and liquor liability.

Higdon Insurance Agency

678 Metts Drive, Louisville, KY 40033

Bundling Option
Motorcyle & ATV
Boats

Higdon Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that specializes in auto and personal insurance services in Louisville and neighboring areas in Kentucky. Headed by owner and principal agent Bruce Higdon, who has been in the insurance business for six years, the agency offers comparative quotes from different insurance carriers to make sure their clients will get the auto insurance that is suitable for their needs. They also offer services for homeowners, renters, businesses, and life insurance. The agency partners with carriers like Erie Insurance.

Hoak Insurance Services

1200 Payne Street, Louisville, KY 40204

Hoak Insurance Services is a family-owned and family-operated agency that serves policyholders throughout the Louiseville area. For 18 years, it has been providing various personal insurance products, such as watercraft, auto, valuable possession, umbrella, and secondary home insurance. Its automobile policies cover RV, classic car, off-road vehicle, and motorcycle. Its team of independent insurance agents and advisors worked in a variety of business industries, including auto body shops, franchise car dealerships, and garage repair shops. The firm has served 11,000 customers in five states, including Pennsylvania.

Jecker and Edelen Insurance Agency, LLC

9322 Taylorsville Road Suite 1-A, Louisville, KY 40299

Multiple Carriers

Jecker and Edelen Insurance Agency, LLC is an independent company operating in Louisville and nearby areas. It offers auto insurance with coverage options including liability, no-fault, comprehensive, and collision. The insurance plan protects the policyholder from financial losses caused by unexpected circumstances like theft, fire, or road accidents. Coverages are also available for classic cars from manufacturers like Corvette, Mustang, and Thunderbird. The company represents multiple insurance companies including Banner Life, Genworth Financial, and State Auto Insurance.

Jeremy Graham

5438 New Cut Road Suite 102, Louisville, KY 40214

Bundling Option

Jeremy Graham is a State Farm insurance agent that has been helping families in Louisville achieve their financial goals since 2013. He offers auto insurance coverage options that match clients' needs. Coverage may vary in levels of financial protection against car accidents. Coverages may include collision, comprehensive, liability, car rental and travel expenses, and medical payments. He also provides homeowners' and business insurance solutions, as well as retirement planning and relocation services.

Jerry Kays Insurance

3701 Taylorsville Rd Ste 1A, Louisville, KY 40220

Multiple Carriers

Jerry Kays Insurance serves individuals, business owners, and families in and around the Louisville metro. The agency provides a wide selection of insurance products, such as auto, life, recreational vehicle, general liability, workers' compensation, and homeowners' insurance. Its auto policies offer liability, property, and medical coverage. In addition, its team of independent insurance agents collaborates with a variety of carriers, including The Hartford, Berkshire Hathaway Guard Insurance Companies, American Modern, Foremost Insurance Group, and ClearPath Mutual.

Joe Maupin Insurance Agency, Inc.

4229 Bardstown Road, Louisville, KY 40218

RV & Motorhome
Boats
Motorcyle & ATV

Joe Maupin Insurance Agency, Inc., is an auto insurance provider serving Lexington and nearby locations. It offers coverage options for clients with personal or commercial auto insurance needs. The company crafts policies that may include coverages for collisions and comprehensive risks. Its team of agents is committed to providing a personal approach to assist policy buyers by educating them about their rights and their options and by helping them process claims.

Kentucky Shield Insurance

8003 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY 40222

Multiple Carriers

Kentucky Shield Insurance offers its services to individuals, families, and businesses in Louisville and the surrounding areas. Its agents connect drivers with various reputable insurance carriers in order to obtain car insurance plans that will fit their personal needs and assessed risks. The agency’s insurance partners include Travelers, Progressive, State Auto Insurance Companies, and AAA. Kentucky Shield Insurance also provides assistance to get coverage for other types of vehicles, including motorcycles, recreational vehicles, boats, classic cars, and travel trailers.

Kiely, Hines & Associates

6100 Dutchmans Lane, 10th Floor, Louisville, KY 40205

Multiple Carriers

Kiely, Hines & Associates is an insurance agency that caters to clients in the Louisville area. Its auto insurance provides compensation for damage in a road accident, along with injuries sustained by the passengers. The policy also covers theft, vandalism, and harm caused by uninsured drivers. In addition, the company insures vehicles like motorcycles, RVs, and boats, along with homes and rental properties. Kiely, Hines & Associates merged with Hyland Insurance on December 2021 and works with more than 30 providers.

Linville Insurance Agency - Richmond

1060 Center Drive, Louisville, KY 40475

Multiple Carriers

Linville Insurance Agency - Richmond is a family-owned insurance firm that has been serving Richmond and the surrounding communities in Kentucky since its founding in 1974. Its agents can provide drivers with the assistance they need to acquire an auto insurance plan that will meet their specific requirements and individual risks. Insurance policies usually cover damage, liability, and medical payments. They can also help clients customize their policy to accommodate the installation of custom auto features or cover business use.

Local Choice Insurance

13117 Eastpoint Park Blvd. Ste. D, Louisville, KY 40223

Multiple Carriers

Local Choice Insurance caters to clients in Louisville. Car owners can obtain coverage for theft, vandalism, and damage from road crashes. The policy provides compensation for injuries to the vehicle occupants and repairs to the car. The firm also offers insurance for other vehicles like classic cars, motorcycles, and RVs, along with policies for homes, condos, and rental properties. It helps businesses obtain coverage for workers' compensation, professional liability, and vehicle fleets. Local Choice Insurance is part of the Hardin County and Jeffersontown Chambers of Commerce.

McCormick Advantage Insurance Agency, LLC

9200 Shelbyville Rd Suite 103, Louisville, KY 40222

Bundling Option

McCormick Advantage Insurance Agency, LLC, is an independent agency that serves individuals, families, and businesses from Louisville and the surrounding areas. Its team of professionals provides auto insurance policies with coverage options such as collision, comprehensive, and liability coverage. Other personal insurance products it offers include homeowners', renters', and condo insurance. It also provides commercial insurance policies such as commercial auto, commercial general liability, and workers' compensation. The agency has been in operation for more than two years.

Nicholson Insurance Agency

2017 Allison Ln, Jeffersonville, IN 47130

Located in Jeffersonville, Indiana, Nicholson Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company that has served residents throughout the Louisville metro area and Indiana for more than two decades. Clients seeking auto insurance can obtain policies that range from state-minimum liability to robust full-coverage policies with comprehensive, medical, and uninsured motorist coverage. In addition to insuring all types of vehicles, the agency's partnerships with carriers such as AAA and Progressive enable it to insure drivers of all ages.

Palacio Miller Agency

3103 Breckenridge Ln, Suite 6, Louisville, KY 40220

Bundling Option

Palacio Miller Agency offers personal and commercial insurance products and services to clients in Louisville and the surrounding areas. Its independent agents, who have over three decades of combined industry experience, provide auto insurance options to meet clients' needs. Auto insurance gives coverage for property damage, liability, and medical expenses. Additionally, this locally owned and operated agency works with multiple companies offering home, recreational, and life insurance. It allows 24-hour access to policy information.

Reynolds Insurance Group

11820 Ransum Way Suite 201, Louisville, KY 40243

Multiple Carriers
Bundling Option

Reynolds Insurance Group is a firm that serves individuals and business owners in Louisville and its surrounding areas. It offers policies covering vehicles, such as auto, motorcycle, ATV, power sports, and recreational transportation insurance. Its commercial options include business, contractor, cyber liability, property, and restaurant insurance. The agency grants insurance options for commercial vehicles and churches. Its team is also equipped to handle policies involving surety, lost title, license, and permit bonds.

Rick Hickman Insurance Agency

6801 Dixie Hwy Ste 212, Louisville, KY 40258

Multiple Carriers

Rick Hickman Insurance Agency is a company based in Louisville that caters to individuals and businesses in the area and surrounding communities. It offers personal and commercial car insurance products that provide coverage for bodily injuries, property damage, collisions, and personal injury protection. It also helps the policyholder to pay for damage caused by uninsured and underinsured drivers. Other products include home, renter, life, motorcycle, boat, and RV insurance. Rick Hickman Insurance has been in business since 1972.

Schwartz Insurance Group

2950 Breckenridge Ln Ste 8, Louisville, KY 40220

Located in Louisville, Kentucky, Schwartz Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency that has specialized in providing customized auto insurance solutions since 1956. Drivers seeking the minimum coverage required can obtain a liability-only policy, while clients looking for the greatest protection against losses lean towards its full coverage insurance plans that include comprehensive, uninsured motorist, medical, and property damage. Cars, trucks, and motorcycles are eligible, and the agency also offers earthquake and flood insurance.

St Matthews Agency

201 S Sherrin Ave, Louisville, KY 40207

Multiple Carriers

St Matthews Agency offers a wide variety of insurance products—including auto, home, farm, health, and life policies—to clients in Louisville. Its car insurance plans are designed to cover collision expenses including property damage repairs and medical treatments. The agency's manager, Denzil Blevins, assists clients with choosing and adjusting car insurance policies parallel to their needs and budgets. The agency is part of the Kentucky Farm Bureau network, which has been in the insurance industry for over 74 years.

Steve Woodrum

101 Saint Clair Street, Louisville, KY 40601

Bundling Option

Steve Woodrum has been part of State Farm since 1994, working his way up to become an insurance agent for the company in 2000. He provides car insurance plans to clients in Louisville and the nearby areas. Steve is one of the people who pioneered the Annual Toys for Tots Fireman’s Chili Cook-Off, a charity event that started 18 years ago. State Farm has been serving its customers for over 97 years, with insurance plans that cover homes, life and health, business, and condos and renters.

Stoess, Nethery & Associates

6317 W Highway 146 Ste 2, Crestwood, KY 40014

Stoess, Nethery & Associates is an independent insurance company in Crestwood, Kentucky, serving the Louisville metro area with auto insurance selected from top carriers, including Progressive, Liberty Mutual, and Auto-Owners Insurance. The company's agents create customized policies with different levels of injury liability, property damage, and collision insurance to fit each client's needs. Options like comprehensive coverage are offered to enhance a client's auto insurance to include protection from noncollision damage and loss such as fires, floods, vandalism, and theft.

Sullivan Insurance Agency

635 North Broadway, Louisville, KY 40508

Multiple Carriers
RV & Motorhome
Boats
Motorcyle & ATV

Sullivan Insurance Agency is an independently owned and locally operated company that has been serving the auto insurance needs of customers in Louisville and nearby areas since 1962. The agency represents various insurance carriers to help clients find the auto insurance plan with the best value. It offers insurance policies that help policyholders get back on the road quickly if their vehicle gets destroyed or damaged by fire, accident, theft, or other covered events. The agency also aids in insuring individuals who are considered high-risk drivers.

The Insurance Artist

Louisville, KY

Multiple Carriers
Bundling Option

The Insurance Artist is an independent agency that serves individuals and families in Louisville and the surrounding locations. Its agents educate clients on the insurance process and help them get policies based on their needs. It offers a range of auto insurance coverage, from medical bills to damage caused by fire, other cars, and collisions. Other vehicle insurance products available from the agency include boat, motorcycle, yacht, and RV policies. The Insurance Artist is a member of the Insurance Agency Owners Alliance.

Tom Lease Insurance, LLC

4100 Taylorsville Road, Louisville, KY 40220

Multiple Carriers

Tom Lease Insurance, LLC, serves clients in Louisville and the surrounding metros. The locally owned and operated business provides a variety of personal and commercial insurance plans, including auto insurance. As an independent insurance agency, its agents represent multiple local carriers and assist clients in selecting the best coverage option for their specific needs. The team also handles homeowners', motorcycle, life, health and disability, and business insurance. Tom Lease, a local insurance broker, founded the company in 1974.

Turner Insurance Agency, Inc.

2460 Shelbyville Rd, Shelbyville, KY 40065

For over 30 years, Turner Insurance Agency Inc. has been serving the people and businesses of the Louisville, Kentucky, area. Based in Shelbyville, this independent insurance agency offers coverage options such as liability, medical, and property for auto insurance policies. Commercial auto coverage offerings include medical payments, personal injury protection, comprehensive, collision, and liability. The company also offers RV, motorcycle, and classic car insurance. It works with top-rated insurers and is BBB accredited.