Best Renter's Insurance Companies in Evansville

Headquartered in Evansville, Michael D. DiLegge Insurance is a locally owned and locally operated business that delivers diverse insurance solutions throughout the Tri-State area. The company assists tenants in choosing the right renters' insurance plan that is most suitable for their needs and lifestyle. Its independent insurance agents represent multiple carriers to provide clients with various coverage options. The company also offers homeowners' and condo insurance. The firm has been insuring customers, particularly high-risk and hard-to-insure individuals, since 1985.

Randy Robertson has been a State Farm insurance agent for more than 30 years, servicing individuals, families, and businesses in Evansville. He educates clients about an array of health insurance products and assists them in filing claims as well as requesting a policy change. Additionally, he also provides assistance with Medicare supplements as well as supplemental health insurance plans. Randy's other products and services include renters' insurance, auto insurance, home insurance, and property insurance.

River City Insurance is an independent agency that serves clients in Evansville and the surrounding communities. It carries renters' insurance policies that enable the client to pay for repairs, replace lost items, and assist injured guests. It also provides personal insurance options that cover all-terrain vehicles, recreational vehicles, motorcycles, boats, mobile homes, and pets. In addition, the agency offers employment practices liability, general liability, cyber liability, and key person insurance packages.

Schultheis Insurance is a family-owned independent agency serving individuals and businesses in the Evansville community. Since 1944, it has been providing personal insurance policies such as renters', auto, life, and health insurance. Its renters' insurance plan covers tenants' damaged or lost valuables and personal liability. The company also offers commercial insurance plans, such as business, group health, and mine subsidence insurance. In 2014, Schultheis Insurance received the Agency of the Territory award from Accident Fund Insurance Company of America.

Based out of Newburgh, Self Insurance Services, LLC, serves the insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in Evansville and the surrounding Tri-State area communities. It carries property and casualty insurance packages like renters’ insurance, homeowners, RV, auto, motorcycle, and personal umbrella liability. Additionally, it provides commercial insurance plans like commercial auto, workers’ compensation, commercial property, catastrophic liability, and bonds. Charles E. Self established the firm in 2004, offering employee benefits. It started to offer property and casualty insurance in 2010.

Torian Insurance is a multi-line insurance company that serves policyholders in Evansville and the surrounding areas. Its wide variety of insurance products includes renters' insurance, protecting renters from property loss and specific emergencies. Related products include condo, landlord, and vacation property insurance. Torian Insurance is a family-owned firm that was founded in 1925. The majority of the company's employees have been working for it for over 10 years, with its principals having more than 20 years of experience each.