Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Colorado Springs

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Colorado Springs Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 225 139 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Affordable American Insurance

For more than a decade, Affordable American Insurance has been offering competitive home insurance rates to homeowners throughout the Colorado Springs area. The company is locally-owned and operated. It offers insurance policies that cover the cost of repairs or loss related to theft, fire, natural disasters, or water backup. Additionally, the company provides homeowners with identity theft protection. Affordable American Insurance's partners include Safeco, Travelers, American Modern Insurance, and Progressive.

601 W Cucharras St
Colorado Springs, CO 80905


Alliance Insurance of Colorado Springs

Alliance Insurance of Colorado Springs is an insurance company that has been providing home insurance for residents in the local area and throughout Colorado for more than two decades. Agents work closely with clients to identify their needs and preferences for their home coverage to choose a suitable policy from one of the agency's many home insurance partners. Policies can cover liability, damage, loss, and personal property. The agency also provides auto, renters, and life insurance services.

2630 Tenderfoot Hill St Ste 203
Colorado Springs, CO 80906


California Casualty

California Casualty in Colorado Springs, Colorado, is an insurance company that offers home insurance services. Founded in 1914 and offering coverage in dozens of states, California Casualty provides comprehensive homeowner's insurance and can additionally provide coverage for floods. California Casualty provides discounts for combining auto and home insurance and for having a home security system. In addition, it offers benefits and discounts to teachers, fire fighters, police officers, and nurses.

1650 Telstar Dr
Colorado Springs, CO 80920


Cheyenne Mountain Insurance Solutions

Cheyenne Mountain Insurance Solutions is an independent insurance agency based in Colorado Springs, Colorado. Established in 2004, it provides standard home insurance policies through several regional and national underwriters. This husband- and wife-owned agency assists clients with separate earthquake and flood home insurance polices to supplement their basic coverage, as desired. Cheyenne Mountain Insurance Solutions also provides motorcycle, automobile, life, and renters insurance. Emergency personal support services are available 24/7.

620 Southpointe Ct Ste 195
Colorado Springs, CO 80906


CoWest of Colorado Springs

CoWest of Colorado Springs is an independent insurance agency that has been insuring homes in the Colorado Springs area since 1991. It is part of Colorado's CoWest Insurance Group Inc., which has 30 offices throughout the state. CoWest works with 25 different underwriters, including Liberty Mutual, Progressive and The Hartford to create unique coverage for each homeowner's needs. The firm provides homeowners insurance coverage for residents in city and rural dwellings and also offers rental property insurance.

500 N Circle Dr Ste 201
Colorado Springs, CO 80909


Freedom Insurance Inc.

Freedom Insurance Inc. is an independent insurance agency in Colorado Springs, Colorado. It offers homeowners insurance from several carriers for individuals and families in Colorado Springs, Pueblo, and Fountain. Insurance advisers explain comprehensive insurance options and help clients choose policies to cover property damage and account for specific risk factors. Agents also help clients design personal liability insurance policies to cover medical expenses, repairs, and other costs in case of a legal claim.

4729 N Carefree Cir
Colorado Springs, CO 80917


O'Donnell Agency Inc

O'Donnell Agency Inc. is an independent insurance agency serving homeowners and renters in the Colorado Springs, Colorado, metro area and throughout the state. The O'Donnell Agency works with a variety of providers, including Chubb, Foremost, The Hartford, Liberty Mutual, and Progressive. The agency offers comprehensive homeowners insurance policies covering real and personal property, liability, and medical and living expenses. O'Donnell also offers auto, condo, renters, boat, commercial property, and life insurance.

707 S Tejon St
Colorado Springs, CO 80903


Western Insurance Solutions

Western Insurance Solutions provides home insurance to residents of Colorado Springs, Colorado, as well as those living in the Denver Metropolitan Area and throughout the state. It has insurance options available for homeowners, renters, condo owners, and landlords, all of which cover events such as fire, theft, and vandalism. While all natural disasters aren't covered by these policies, supplemental insurance can be purchased to include protection against floods and earthquakes.

4740 Flintridge Dr Ste 115
Colorado Springs, CO 80918


Win Insurance Agency

WIN Insurance Agency in Colorado Springs, Colorado offers a variety of personal insurance products. Its home insurance policies are backed by top-rated carriers such as Nationwide and Progressive. Home insurance options are available to homeowners, renters, condo owners, and landlords. The company's agents are committed to finding its clients insurance policies that include the right amount of coverage for their needs at a reasonable price. WIN Insurance Agency also offers business, auto, and boat insurance.

3355 American Dr Ste 100
Colorado Springs, CO 80917


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: