hero image

Best Car Insurance Agencies in San Diego

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored San Diego Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 734 444 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

American Tristar Insurance Services Inc.

American Tristar Insurance Services Inc. is an independent insurance agency based in San Diego, California, that has provided insurance services to motorists in the area since 2003. The firm takes an individualized approach to tailor custom insurance coverage that meets all its clients' needs. The basic coverage options available include personal liability, medical payments, uninsured or underinsured motorist, and personal injury protection, while optional coverage includes extras such as rental reimbursement and roadside assistance. The firm also offers home, renters, and business insurance.

5945 Mission Gorge Rd Ste 6
San Diego, CA 92120


Belltown Insurance Agency Inc.

BIG Belltown Insurance Group Inc. is an independent insurance brokerage in San Diego, California. The company has an additional office in Seattle, as well. It offers auto insurance policies for drivers of all ages and experience levels. High-risk policies are available, as well as policies for classic and high-value autos, RVs, and boats. BIG Belltown Insurance Group In. also offers home and life insurance options, and is a Trusted Choice independent insurance agent.

3911 5th Ave Ste 200
San Diego, CA 92103


BJA Partners

BJA Partners, established in 1983, is a San Diego-based auto insurance firm that works with a vast network of insurance carriers, including Guardian and Aetna. Agents build insurance policies for motorists with automobiles, boats, and motorcycles, providing both collision and comprehensive coverage. Policies generally pay for repair costs and bodily injury liability protection. BJA Partners also handles homeowners and renters insurance. Annual reviews of insurance rates are included in all packages.

11405 W Bernardo Ct
San Diego, CA 92127


Fusco & Orsini Insurance Services

Founded in California in 2010, Fusco & Orsini Insurance is a locally-owned independent insurance agency serving businesses and people around its location in San Diego. It offers a wide range of policies through its many carriers, including auto insurance, which it can tailor to the needs of individuals, families, or businesses. The agency's advisors take each client through the fine print and ensure their unique policy is appropriate should they need to claim for repairs, replacement, or personal liability.

5095 Murphy Canyon Rd Ste 200
San Diego, CA 92123


Hotwire Insurance Services

Hotwire Insurance Services is a full-service, independent insurance brokerage based in Chula Vista, California, serving the greater San Diego area. The firm can find policies to cover auto, motorcycle, boat, home, and business. The agents answer client questions and offer them advice on the best coverage options to include in their policies. Hotwire Insurance Services has an online portal and app to allow clients to manage all their insurance plans in one place, including filing claims.

555 Broadway Ste 2018
Chula Vista, CA 91910


Integrity Insurance Services

Integrity Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency in San Diego, California, that provides area business owners with the commercial auto insurance they need to guard against liability on the road. Its long-standing relationships with leading insurance carriers allow it to generate comparative quotes from multiple companies at once, making it easy for businesses to explore their coverage options. Integrity Insurance Services also sells other types of business insurance, including general liability and contractor's liability policies.

4025 Camino del Rio S Ste 300
San Diego, CA 92108


Kostyo Insurance Agency

Established in 2000, Kostyo Insurance Agency specializes in obtaining budget-friendly auto insurance for high-risk drivers in the San Diego, California, metro area. Drivers requiring SR22s can get policies that include a variety of coverages such as liability, comprehensive, and property damage. Uninsured motorist coverage is also available, enabling policyholders to receive compensation when the other party is at fault and lacks insurance. Progressive, Safeco, and Travelers are a few of its partners.

4456 Vandever Ave
San Diego, CA 92120


Snapp & Associates Insurance Services, Inc.

Snapp & Associates Insurance Services Inc. is an independent agency that sells auto insurance in the San Diego, California, metro area. Established in 1947, the company provides auto insurance to protect vehicle owners against liability as well as offering both collision and comprehensive coverage for their vehicles. Snapp & Associates Insurance Services offers a full range of both personal and insurance options, including life coverage, flood insurance, data and cyber liability protection, and health coverage options.

438 Camino del Rio S Ste 112
San Diego, CA 92108


The Insurance Place

Located in San Diego, California, The Insurance Place has provided vehicle insurance solutions to thousands of clients in the area and its surroundings since 1994. The independent insurance agency has partnered with a cluster of select top insurance providers in the region to bring its clients quality, reliable auto insurance coverage. It assists clients to insure their automobiles, marine vehicles, recreational vehicles, and motorcycles and also handles home, life, and business insurance.

2611 Denver St
San Diego, CA 92110


The Insurance Store

Founded in 1973, The Insurance Store is a family-owned and operated insurance agency in San Diego, with four offices in California and one in Glendale, Arizona. As an independent brokerage, the agency works with over 20 insurance carriers to provide motorists with comprehensive car insurance. The company specializes in coverage for commercial vehicles such as tow trucks and dump trucks. The Insurance Store also assists clients with motorcycle, boat, and recreational vehicle insurance.

10981 San Diego Mission Rd Ste 220
San Diego, CA 92108


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: