Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Boston

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Boston Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 355 217 11

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Baltic Insurance Agency

Baltic Insurance Agency is a family-owned and operated home insurance company that has been serving the residents of Boston, Massachusetts, since 1953. As an independent company, it maintains relationships with multiple large insurance carriers, such as Travelers, Mapfre, and Liberty Mutual. It utilizes these relationships to provide clients with multiple options for covering their homes or condos. The policies cover home damage, property loss, liability, and medical and living expenses due to loss of use.

138 Old Colony Ave
South Boston, MA 02127


Boynton Insurance Agency

Boynton Insurance Agency in Needham Heights, Massachusetts, is family-owned and operated and offers a full range of home insurance products. Established in 1919, this independent insurance agency also has offices in Easton and Georgetown to service the needs of homeowners throughout Eastern Massachusetts. It partners with more than 100 A-rated insurance carriers to give clients a broad choice when it comes to coverage options and offers expert advice to help its customers fully understand their insurance needs.

72 River Park St
Needham Heights, MA 02494


Child-Genovese Insurance Agency Inc

Established in 1892 and located in Hingham, Massachusetts, Child-Genovese Insurance Agency provides home and business insurance services to the Boston metropolitan area. Homeowner policy options cover physical structures and personal belongings against damage from floods, fire, and theft. Personal property and unit interior insurance is available to condominium owners along with liability protection against property damage to others. The company provides comprehensive jewelry business insurance services as well as auto, personal, and umbrella coverage plans.

99 South St Ste 101A
Hingham, MA 02043


David E. Zeller Insurance Agency, Inc.

Based in Lynn, Massachusetts, David E. Zeller Insurance Agency Inc. is an independent specializing in home insurance, serving the Greater Boston area. Founded in 1978, it's access to over 40 nationally recognized insurance carriers provides it with the means to find the best solutions for its clients. The core of its homeowner policies includes liability insurance, protection if someone is injured on the client's property, as well as personal belongings and structure to reimburse the client if the worst happens.

370 Lynnway
Lynn, MA 01901


Downey Insurance Agency

The Downey Insurance Agency is based in Marlborough, Massachusetts, providing insurance services throughout the Boston area. Founded in 1928, Home insurance is one of the many specialist services it provides. The agency represents a range of carriers, giving it the flexibility to identify and shape the right policies for its clients. Its packages can include protection for the physical structure of the home, its contents, living expenses if temporary accommodation is needed, and personal liability if a visitor is injured.

190 E Main St
Marlborough, MA 01752


D’Attilio Insurance Agency

D'Attilio Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Dedham, serving the Greater Boston area of Massachusetts and beyond. Founded in 1956, its aim is to act as a trusted advisor to its clients. The agency represents multiple insurance carriers, including Travelers and N&D, finding and shaping the most suitable home insurance coverage for its customers. It ensures basic coverage forms part of the policy and optional extras such as water back-up/sump overflow and earthquake/earth movement are included if appropriate.

347 Washington St
Dedham, MA 02026


Eagle Trust Insurance

Established in 1989, Eagle Trust Insurance is an independent agency serving Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Florida. Located in Somerville, Massachusetts, it's portfolio of products includes homeowners insurance, as well as protection for condos and renters. The agency combs through the policies of its numerous insurance carriers for the one that fits their clients unique circumstances and price range. Coverage typically includes protection against flood, fire, and theft, with optional add-ons for particularly valuable objects and umbrella insurance for unexpected accidents.

707 Broadway
Somerville, MA 02144


Kaplansky Insurance

Kaplansky Insurance is an independent agency serving residents across Brookline, Massachusetts, since 1974. The company's agents help buyers enroll in policies to protect their homes from possible risks. Its homeowners insurance covers damages and loss of contents caused by unexpected events, including theft, fire, and liabilities such as medical expenses for injuries sustained by guests. Other policies available at Kaplansky Insurance include auto, renters, umbrella, and condo insurance for both individuals and businesses.

114 Harvard St
Brookline, MA 02446


LoPriore Insurance Agency

Founded in 1995, LoPriore Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company located in Stoneham, Massachusetts, and serving renters and homeowners in the Boston metro area. LoPriore works with a variety of carriers, including American Modern, The Hartford, Progressive, and Travelers. The agency offers home insurance solutions for a variety of dwelling types, including single and multifamily homes, condos, and rental properties, for homeowners as well as renters. The personal property coverage included in homeowners policies affords worldwide protection.

426 Main St Ste 2
Stoneham, MA 02180


Murphy Insurance

Murphy Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Malborough, Massachusetts. A specialist in home insurance, it provides clients in the Greater Boston area with policies that provide coverage for structural issues, fire, and theft. It can negotiate coverage with its insurance partners for additional insurance like liability protection and home business protection. The agency can also offer discounts for new construction and homes fitted with burglar alarms and smoke detectors. It also sells renter, condo, and mobile home insurance.

200 Main St
Marlborough, MA 01752


Robert T. Fowler & Sons Insurance Company

Robert T. Fowler & Sons Insurance Company is an independent agency located in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts. It has served the Boston area since 1905. Owner Stephen Fowler has over 25 years of experience providing homeowners policy coverage and knowledgeable customer service to clients. The firm works with each client to customize coverage needs. Policies include liability coverage and protection against damage to personal property within the home. Robert T. Fowler & Sons Insurance Company also offers auto, flood, and renters insurance.

743 Centre St
Jamaica Plain, MA 02130


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area