hero image
Laurels

Best Car Insurance Agencies in Boise
2020

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored car insurance agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best car insurance agencies in Boise, ID.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 128 81 12

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of Access First Insurance  car-insurance/1.jpg

Access First Insurance

Access First Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Eagle, Idaho, that was founded in 2005 with a client-focused business model. Serving residents throughout the Boise metro area, the agency works with over 15 insurance providers to provide drivers with auto insurance. Coverage types include liability, collision, and comprehensive. The agency's other policies help clients pay medical expenses for themselves and any uninsured motorists involved in the accident. Access First specializes in creating insurance plans for drivers with SR-22 filings.

849 E State St Ste 101
Eagle, ID 83616

Website

cover image of Affordable Insurance  car-insurance/2.jpg

Affordable Insurance

Affordable Insurance in Caldwell, Idaho, is a full-service independent insurance agency serving the greater Boise, Idaho, area with an experienced team of auto insurance agents. Offering liability coverage to protect clients who cause loss for others in addition to no-fault coverage which ensures the client and their passengers are protected no matter who is at fault, the company guides clients in finding the right auto insurance for their needs and location. It also writes collision and comprehensive insurance policies.

1117 Cleveland Blvd
Caldwell, ID 83605

Website

cover image of Cole Insurance Center Inc  car-insurance/3.jpg

Cole Insurance Center Inc

Cole Insurance Center Inc. is an insurance provider that has served the Boise, Idaho, area since 1980. It offers personal auto, health, and life coverage. The auto insurance policies include coverage for collisions, towing, and repairs for cars, motorcycles, special value vehicles, trailers, and RVs. Cole Insurance Center also offers commercial property insurance that covers builder's risk, electronics, and machinery. The company provides liability insurance for personal and commercial purposes.

611 S Orchard St
Boise, ID 83705

Website

cover image of Dailey Insurance Exchange LLC  car-insurance/4.jpg

Dailey Insurance Exchange LLC

Located in Boise, Idaho, Dailey Insurance Exchange is an independent insurance agency. Founded in 2013, it represents carriers like MetLife and Dairyland Auto, amongst others. The agency finds its clients auto insurance policies that provide appropriate coverage for their needs. It can find a wide range of policies, from basic to comprehensive, including non-owners and foreign drivers. The agency's areas of coverage include insurance for homeowners, renters, landlords, and small to specialty businesses.

1542 S Timesquare Ln # LN101
Boise, ID 83709

Website

cover image of FIG Financial Insurance Group  car-insurance/1.jpg

FIG Financial Insurance Group

The FIG Financial Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency based in Boise, Idaho. A full-service agency, its advisors find competing personal auto insurance products from its insurance providers and negotiates a price. It ensures the products meet the legal requirements of the state and lender and advises clients on recommended and optional add-ons. The agency also services its personal and business clients from offices across Idaho, western Montana, and Carson City, Nevada.

13965 W Chinden Blvd Ste 106
Boise, ID 83713

Website

cover image of Hartley Insurance  car-insurance/2.jpg

Hartley Insurance

Hartley Insurance has been offering customized auto insurance policies to drivers throughout the Boise, Idaho, metro area since 1982. Its policies are customized to clients' coverage needs and usually include liability and property damage. With comprehensive coverage, the agency ensures clients can repair or replace their vehicle after losses from fire, theft, or vandalism. Hartley Insurance has experience insuring all types of vehicles, including RVs and motorcycles. The company also offers umbrella policies.

931 S Allante Pl
Boise, ID 83709

Website

cover image of Higgins & Rutledge Insurance, Inc.  car-insurance/3.jpg

Higgins & Rutledge Insurance, Inc.

Since 1951, Higgins & Rutledge Insurance Inc. has provided automobile insurance to individuals and businesses in Boise, Idaho. With a diverse group of insurance carrier options, Higgins & Rutledge helps clients choose the right insurance solution to fit their needs and budget. The company's agents advise clients on potential risks and gaps regarding their current automobile policies. Higgins & Rutledge Insurance also sells home, farm, umbrella, and professional liability insurance.

1661 W Shoreline Dr Ste 100
Boise, ID 83702

Website

cover image of Idaho Select Insurance  car-insurance/4.jpg

Idaho Select Insurance

Established in 2015, Idaho Select Insurance, provides personal and commercial automobile coverage to clients in Meridian and Boise metro area. The independent agents at Idaho Select Insurance advise Idaho drivers on the minimum legal liability requirements and extra coverages for maximum protection. For businesses, the company assesses the levels of protection needed and suggest a variety of options to fit any budget. Idaho Select Insurance also sells watercraft, motorcycle, renters, umbrella, and life insurance.

3023 E Copper Point Dr Ste 203
Meridian, ID 83642

Website

cover image of Insurance4Idaho  car-insurance/1.jpg

Insurance4Idaho

Boise, Idaho-based Insurance4Idaho is an independent insurance agency that has been covering local cars, trucks, and motorcycles since 2005. The agency can tailor clients' auto policies to their budgets and concerns, with most policies including liability, medical, and property damage coverage. Seasonal drivers can switch their coverage to comprehensive only when their vehicle is stored to save money. The agency partners with a variety of leading insurers, including Travelers and The Hartford. Insurance4Idaho also writes renters and homeowners policies.

8660 W Emerald St Ste 182
Boise, ID 83704

Website

cover image of Integrity Insurance  car-insurance/2.jpg

Integrity Insurance

Integrity Insurance, an independent insurance agency based in Meridian, Idaho, provides auto insurance options for drivers throughout the greater Boise area. With 25 years of combined insurance industry experience, the agency's team provides risk assessments for drivers to help steer them toward the right policies with coverage, premiums, and deductibles that match their needs. Its relationships with top insurance carriers allow the agency to identify the best options for its clients prior to policy purchase.

2680 S Eagle Rd Ste 100
Meridian, ID 83642

Website

cover image of Mustard Seed Financial & Insurance  car-insurance/3.jpg

Mustard Seed Financial & Insurance

Mustard Seed Financial & Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in the Boise, Idaho, metro area, with offices in Meridian and Twin Falls. The company is licensed in several states, including Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Utah, and Wyoming. Auto insurance specialists work with several carriers, such as AIG, Nationwide, and The Hartford, to help drivers get the right policy at an affordable rate. Options include Liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured and underinsured motorist, personal injury protection, and medical payments coverage.

501 S Main St
Meridian, ID 83642

Website

cover image of Silver Key Insurance  car-insurance/4.jpg

Silver Key Insurance

Silver Key Insurance is a local and independent insurance agency in Boise, Idaho. Since 2006, it has been helping clients from across the state of Idaho obtain auto insurance that is tailored to meet their specific needs. The agency works with several trusted insurance carriers to provide options including collision and comprehensive coverage, liability coverage, and road trouble service. The vehicles it can provide coverage for include motorcycles, classic cars, boats, ATVs, and motor homes.

10588 W Business Park Ln
Boise, ID 83709

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: