Best Car Insurance Agencies in Mesa

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Mesa Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 279 174 17

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

A and H Insurance

A and H Insurance is an auto insurance agency with an office in Apache Junction and Mesa, Arizona, and five offices throughout Nevada. Founded in 1957, the firm partners with over 30 insurance carriers to provide protection to motorists with cars, boats, motorhomes, and ATVs. A and H believes its history of working with legislators and being involved in local politics gives its agents a better understanding of insurance laws. The agency also offers commercial, health, and life insurance. As of 01/01/2020, Judy Holder Insurance is part of the A and H family.

1959 S Val Vista Dr Ste 130
Mesa, AZ 85204


American Family Insurance - Mike Stapley Agency, Inc.

Founded in 1998, American Family Insurance-Mike Stapley Agency Inc. is an independent insurance company based in Mesa, Arizona. Licensed agents work with top carriers to help drivers get the right amount of coverage at competitive rates. Options include liability for bodily injury and property damage, and clients can seek additional insurance to cover vehicle repairs and replacement costs, medical expenses, personal injury protection, and depreciation gaps between the car loans and value. Services are available in English and Spanish.

4850 E Baseline Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ 85206


Arizona Insurance Agency

Arizona Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency based in Tempe, Arizona, serving clients throughout the greater Mesa region and beyond. The firm's goal is to provide quality, affordable insurance solutions to motorists regardless of their history or circumstance. It offers auto insurance buyers a list of the most comprehensive coverage options to choose from at the most competitive rates. Besides auto insurance, Arizona Insurance Agency provides homeowners, motorcycle, commercial, and Mexico tourist insurance.

1713 E Broadway Rd
Tempe, AZ 85282


Arredondo Insurance

Arredondo Insurance is an independent, family-owned and operated insurance agency in Tempe, Arizona. Founded in 1988, the brokerage serves motorists in the Tempe and Mesa metro areas, working with a carefully selected group of eight insurance companies to provide collision and comprehensive auto coverage. The agency carries insurance packages for boats, antique cars, motorcycles, and off-road vehicles. Vehicles that are stolen, vandalized, or destroyed by natural disasters are covered. Arredondo also offers homeowners, renters, and commercial insurance.

2130 S Rural Rd
Tempe, AZ 85282


Bryant Insurance Agency

Bryant Insurance Agency connects motorists in Mesa, Arizona, to needed auto insurance through its partner network of trusted, nationally known insurance carriers. Its certified agents provide comparative rate analyses for customers to find the right auto insurance policy for each driver from companies such as Progressive, State Auto, and Safeco. In addition to basic liability coverage, comprehensive/collision coverage, and personal injury protection policies, the agency also insures classic cars, motorhomes, RVs, and motorcycles.

2941 N Power Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ 85215


Gates Insurance

Gates Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving clients throughout the Mesa, Arizona, metro area, where it's located. The agency partners with a wide array of insurers to help clients obtain a policy with an affordable premium in addition to standard coverages such as liability, property damage, and medical payments. Whether adjusting deductibles or inquiring about other cars for a multi-vehicle discount, the company strives to save clients as much as possible. Gates Insurance also provides life and home insurance.

3654 N Power Rd Ste 167
Mesa, AZ 85215


Hegarty-Haynes Insurance, Inc.

Hegarty-Haynes Insurance Inc. is an insurance agency that provides personal and commercial automobile insurance solutions to customers in Tempe, Arizona. The professionals at Hegarty-Haynes advise clients on the best solutions for collision, comprehensive, and liability coverage in the Mesa area. In addition, Hegarty-Haynes Insurance offers personal all-terrain vehicle and watercraft coverage. For businesses, Hegarty-Haynes works with clients to find the right coverage including all auto designation, additional collision endorsements, and vandalism protection.

4500 S Lakeshore Dr Ste 265
Tempe, AZ 85282


Insurance Professionals of Arizona, LLC

Insurance Professionals of Arizona LLC is an independent insurance agency in Mesa, Arizona, that provides auto insurance throughout the metro area. The company offers protection against vehicular damage or loss due to collision or other factors through its auto insurance coverage, including for tourists driving in Mexico. Insurance Professionals of Arizona provides personal and commercial insurance protection through partnerships with a variety of carriers, including Liberty Mutual, ASI, Acuity, CNA, Encompass, and Kemper.

3521 E Brown Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ 85213


INW Insurance Group

INW Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency that has provided auto insurance solutions to residents in the Mesa, Arizona, area for more than a decade. INW offers auto insurance policies designed to protect policyholders' assets with a variety of coverage options, including liability, uninsured motorist, and medical. Policies with comprehensive coverage ensure drivers can repair or replace their vehicles after damages caused by fire and vandalism. Hagerty, Foremost, and National General are just a few of INW Insurance Group's partners.

4455 E Broadway Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ 85206


Red Rock Insurance

In operation since 2010, Red Rock Insurance is a Mesa, Arizona-based auto insurance provider partnering with various insurance companies to sell clients policies that protect them legally and financially following serious accidents. While bodily injury and property damage liability coverage is required in Arizona, other areas are not, so Red Rock Insurance regularly helps clients explore what their options are based on what they can afford and what risks they are willing to take. This agency also sells homeowners insurance.

4140 E Baseline Rd Ste 100
Mesa, AZ 85206


The Mahoney Group

Founded in 1915, The Mahoney Group provides automobile insurance for clients in Mesa, Arizona, and surrounding areas. With 11 other offices throughout the western United States, The Mahoney Group is an independent agency that works to provide the best coverage to meet individual and family automobile insurance needs. Locally owned, the company focuses on personalized customer service and was named to the Top 50 Fastest Growing Companies in Arizona by The Business Journal.

1835 S Extension Rd
Mesa, AZ 85210


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: