hero image

Best Real Estate Agents in Columbus

Why These Real Estate Agents?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored real estate agents on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best real estate agents in Columbus, OH.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 309 193 20

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of Amy Clark  real-estate-agents/1.jpg

Amy Clark

Realtor Amy Clark is the team leader for The Clark Group with ERA Real Solutions Realty located in Westerville, Ohio, but serving the entire greater Columbus, Ohio, area. Her group has ranked as the #3 ERA team in the country. Amy focuses on commercial real estate, as well as residential properties, such as single-family homes, newly constructed homes, condos, and townhouses. She has experience with a wide range of lending options, including, HUD, VA, FHA, and USDA loans.

168 S State St
Westerville, OH 43081


cover image of Becky Warnement  real-estate-agents/2.jpg

Becky Warnement

Becky Warnement is a Realtor for Coldwell Banker King Thompson that serves clients throughout the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. She has more than 11 years of experience helping buyers and sellers of residential properties in the Grandview, Upper Arlington, and OSU neighborhood. Ms. Warnement is a lifelong resident of the area and uses her knowledge of the community and connections in the area to help first time home buyers, couples, and individuals downsizing, find the right neighborhood.

3160 Kingsdale Ctr
Upper Arlington, OH 43221


cover image of Carlton Shaffer  real-estate-agents/3.jpg

Carlton Shaffer

Carlton Shaffer is a Realtor and the owner of The Shaffer Group with RE/MAX Affiliates in Westerville, Ohio, where he has a decade of experience representing buyers and sellers throughout the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. Mr. Shaffer specializes in negotiating contracts for investment and renovation properties. By continually refining his marketing approach, he ensures properties for sale are exposed to the maximum number of buyers. Mr. Shaffer also specializes in relocation.

7239 Sawmill Rd Ste 210
Dublin, OH 43016


cover image of David Fairman  real-estate-agents/4.jpg

David Fairman

David Fairman is the co-owner and principal broker of The Realty Firm located in Columbus, Ohio. He primarily focuses on residential properties, with clients including both first-time home buyers and real estate investors. Mr. Fairman utilizes his education and professional-level training in negotiations to assist buyers and sellers in getting the best deals. He has received the Certified Negotiation Expert designation from The Real Estate Negotiation Institute in Los Angeles, California.

7801 Olentangy River Rd
Columbus, OH 43235


cover image of Kyle Alfriend  real-estate-agents/1.jpg

Kyle Alfriend

Kyle Alfriend is a real estate broker with RE/MAX who has over two decades of experience and serves the Columbus, Ohio, metro area in six neighborhoods. He markets single-family residential property with special attention to new construction homes, investor clients, and first-time home buyers. Mr. Alfriend has been a Dublin, Ohio, resident for over 21 years and feels that his long-time residence and heavy involvement in the community improve the quality of his consultation services.

7124 Muirfield Dr
Dublin, OH 43017


cover image of Lee Ritchie  real-estate-agents/2.jpg

Lee Ritchie

Lee Ritchie is a Realtor and team leader with RE/MAX Metro Plus who works with clients in and around the Columbus, Ohio, area. Ms. Ritchie has over five years of experience in the real estate industry. She guides a team of agents who offer superior digital marketing to assist with selling properties. Ms. Ritchie also offers relocation services to assist buyers outside of the Columbus area and maximize the buying experience.

502 S 3rd St
Columbus, OH 43215


cover image of Linda and Marty Soller  real-estate-agents/3.jpg

Linda and Marty Soller

Linda and Marty Soller are real estate agents at Coldwell Banker situated in Columbus, Ohio. They handle downsizing, home buying and selling, relocation, and property listing. Both dedicate themselves to reducing clients' stress and complexity involved in the buying and selling process by assisting them throughout the entire process. The agents also market homes to maximize their exposure and shorten the listing period. Linda and Marty Soller offer the latest property research services and provide clients with up-to-date information.

4535 W Dublin Granville Rd
Dublin, OH 43017


cover image of Marilyn Vutech  real-estate-agents/4.jpg

Marilyn Vutech

Marilyn Vutech is a Realtor and co-owner of Vutech and Ruff Team, HER Realtors in Columbus, Ohio. She has over 30 years of experience working with home buyers and sellers in downtown and suburban areas of Columbus. Ms. Vutech's business approach is to provide first-rate customer service and professionalism throughout the buying and selling processes. Clients recommend Vutech for her accommodating nature and for making the real estate process stress-free and enjoyable.

177 E Beck St
Columbus, OH 43206


cover image of Regina Tobin  real-estate-agents/1.jpg

Regina Tobin

Regina Tobin is a real estate broker and co-founder of Metro Village Realty, operating throughout the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. She works with buyers and sellers, with a focus on residential properties in Downtown Columbus neighborhoods, such as German Village, Harrison West, Upper Arlington, and Grandview. As an accredited buyer's representative and certified residential specialist, Regina specializes in historic homes and condos with distinctive features. She is fluent in both English and Spanish.

685 S Front St
Columbus, OH 43206


cover image of Rhiannon Ferrari  real-estate-agents/2.jpg

Rhiannon Ferrari

Rhiannon Ferrari is the owner and lead Realtor for the Ferrari Home Group, which operates in the Columbus, Ohio area. She has been working in real estate in Central Ohio for more than a decade, and she is passionate about improving the way real estate business is done in the area. In addition to managing her team of Realtors, Rhiannon Ferrari also works with residential clients for home sales and purchases.

1510 W Lane Ave
Columbus, OH 43221


cover image of Robert Pembertonn  real-estate-agents/3.jpg

Robert Pembertonn

Robert Pembertonn is a real estate agent with ERA Real Solutions Realty with over five years of experience. He is the leader of the ERA Love Where You Live real estate team. Mr. Pembertonn represents buyers and sellers in and around the greater Columbus area. He works with the members of his real estate team to meet client needs while providing a boutique experience that focuses on providing optimal customer service.

168 S State St
Westerville, OH 43081


cover image of Ryan Conway  real-estate-agents/4.jpg

Ryan Conway

Ryan Conway is a Realtor and the lead agent at the Conway Group with Keller Williams Consultants Realty that serves clients in the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. He has over 12 years of experience helping residential buyers and sellers navigate the real estate industry. Mr. Conway holds certification for foreclosure and short sales. He helps sellers optimize their sales with home valuation which allows them to see how their homes compare to nearby residences.

5400 Frantz Rd Ste 100
Dublin, OH 43016


cover image of Ryan Plowman  real-estate-agents/1.jpg

Ryan Plowman

Ryan Plowman, of Plowman Properties LLC, has over 25 years of experience in real estate and residential construction. He is a licensed Realtor, serving individuals from his office in Columbus and all throughout Ohio and North and South Carolina. Plowman offers a full range of services for buyers, sellers, builders, and investors of both pre-existing houses and new constructions. Ryan has connections to a large number of specialized contractors with which to support his customers' unique real estate needs.

Columbus, OH 43235


cover image of Ryan Reynolds  real-estate-agents/2.jpg

Ryan Reynolds

Ryan Reynolds is a real estate agent and head of the Ryan Reynolds Team with Keller Williams Consultants Realty who serves Columbus, Ohio, and several neighboring communities. He has been working with residential home buyers and sellers in Central Ohio since 2001 and lives in the area with his family, giving him first-hand knowledge of the local real estate market. His background in mechanical engineering provides him with excellent attention to detail.

5400 Frantz Rd Ste 100
Dublin, OH 43016


cover image of Sam Miler  real-estate-agents/3.jpg

Sam Miler

Sam Miller is a real estate agent, consultant, and property manager with Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate, operating in the Columbus, Ohio, metro area and throughout Franklin, Delaware, and Fairfield Counties. Mr. Miller focuses on helping first-time buyers, sellers, military buyers, and investors with residential family homes in the Linden neighborhood. He has a degree in real estate and property development, which he believes fortifies his market knowledge, negotiating skills, and understanding of construction.

104 Mill St
Gahanna, OH 43230


cover image of Sandy Raines  real-estate-agents/4.jpg

Sandy Raines

Sandy Raines is a Realtor, CEO, and owner of The Raines Group of HER Realtors in Columbus, Ohio. Raines and her team focus on luxury home buyers and sellers throughout central Ohio. For over 30 years, Raines has navigated clients through the complexities of the buying and negotiation processes. For luxury home sellers, Raines utilizes marketing strategies to reach global markets and expedite sales. Raines' business approach is to provide effective communication and deliver a standard of excellence in all real estate transactions.

5207 Hampsted Village Center Way
New Albany, OH 43054


cover image of Shaun Simpson  real-estate-agents/1.jpg

Shaun Simpson

Shaun Simpson is a Realtor and leader of the Make It Home Group at Cutler Real Estate who lists and sells properties throughout the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. He focuses on Worthington, Dublin, and other neighborhoods on the northern side of the city. Mr. Simpson handles residential and small commercial real estate, working with sellers, buyers, and investors. As a member of the Building Industry Association of Central Ohio, he has experience with new construction. He also offers property management services.

14 E Olentangy St
Powell, OH 43065


cover image of Sue Lusk-Gleich  real-estate-agents/2.jpg

Sue Lusk-Gleich

A licensed Realtor for over four decades of experience, Sue Lusk-Gleich is a part-owner of Keller Williams Capital Partners Realty in Columbus, Ohio, as well as the founder and team lead of The Columbus Team real estate group. Sue works with buyers and sellers and has extensive knowledge of relocations, reverse mortgages, and 1031 exchanges. Ms. Lusk-Gleich also holds accreditations as a Certified Residential Specialist (CRS), Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR), Certified New Home Professional (CHP), and Senior Residential Specialist (SRES).

100 E Wilson Bridge Rd
Worthington, OH 43085


cover image of Susan Wainfor  real-estate-agents/3.jpg

Susan Wainfor

Susan Wainfor is a Realtor with HER Realty who has over 31 years of experience working with buyers or sellers of residential properties in the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. She specializes in Upper Arlington, Hilliard, and Westerville. Ms. Wainfor helps clients prepare their homes for the market by employing a staging expert and professional photographer to create a high-quality listing, which she believes expedites the selling process. Her two full-time digital media specialists handle preliminary marketing.

4087 Trueman Blvd
Hilliard, OH 43026


cover image of William Robbins  real-estate-agents/4.jpg

William Robbins

William Robbins is a Columbus, Ohio, licensed Realtor with over 15 years of experience in real estate. He is also the co-owner of the Gledhill Robbins & Talis Group of HER Realtors. Mr. Robbins works with buyers and sellers on residential, commercial, and investment properties, HUD homes, short sales, and new construction, and assists with relocations. Having come from a prior professional background in customer service and management, Mr. Robbins puts that knowledge into his real estate practice.

583 S 3rd St
Columbus, OH 43215


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: