Close
Get Listed
Laurels

Best Car Insurance Agencies in St. Petersburg
2020

We scored 150 Car Insurance Agencies in St. Petersburg, FL and Picked the Top 12

hero image

Here are the Picks:

Bentley DeNight Insurance

Charles M Hicks Insurance LLC

Crews Insurance Agency

CROSSLET INSURANCE INC

Great South Insurance Agency

Harr & Associates Insurance Inc

Hartselle Insurance

Insurance Resources, LLC

Moore Resources Insurance

Patrons Insurance Agency, Inc.

Sihle Insurance Group

Wallace Welch & Willingham

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored St. Petersburg Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 150 94 12

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Bentley DeNight Insurance

The staff at Bentley DeNight Independent Insurance Services help residents of Saint Petersburg, Florida, to find auto insurance policies for a range of vehicles from a long list of carriers, such as HCI, Progressive, and Foremost Insurance Group. The company offers comprehensive and a la carte insurance policies for standard and non-standard autos. In addition to auto insurance, Bentley DeNight Independent Insurance Services offers property, business, and flood insurance policies.

Click to Call

6524 1st Ave N
St Petersburg, FL 33710

Website

(727) 344-4500 Website

Charles M Hicks Insurance LLC

Charles M. Hicks Insurance LLC is a St. Petersburg, Florida, independent insurance company. Founded in 1978, it offers competitive auto insurance rates from brands such as Mercury Insurance Group, Progressive, and Travelers. Auto insurance policies provide property, liability, and medical coverage, with agents identifying the optimal auto insurance policy for each customer. The company also offers home, life, and flood insurance. Charles M. Hicks Insurance is a Trusted Choice agency whose agents have over 30 years experience.

Click to Call

4625 E Bay Dr Ste 101
Clearwater, FL 33764

Website

(727) 474-3870 Website

Crews Insurance Agency

Crews Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company based in Seminole, Florida. Representing over 25 carriers, the company has more than 100 years of industry experience and has been serving drivers across Florida for over 50 years. Crews Insurance agency finds the best rates across major carriers, tailored to fit the needs of each individual driver. The company can bundle auto insurance with home, flood, and life insurance for better rates.

Click to Call

9355 Seminole Blvd
Seminole, FL 33772

Website

(727) 595-4127 Website

CROSSLET INSURANCE INC

Crosslet Insurance Inc. is an insurance agency serving Clearwater and Saint Petersburg, Florida. For more than four decades, the agency has helped match clients with a variety of local and national auto insurance providers. Auto insurance policies are required by law for all licensed drivers in the state of Florida. In addition to auto insurance, Crosslet Insurance Inc. can also assist clients in obtaining home, recreational vehicle, motor home, and umbrella insurance policies.

Click to Call

13246 38th St N
Clearwater, FL 33762

Website

(888) 471-0818 Website

Great South Insurance Agency

Great South Insurance is an independent insurance agency with more than two decades of experience writing auto insurance policies for residents of the Saint Petersburg, Florida, metro area. The company provides customized policies that range from protecting drivers against all hazards with full coverage to being just legal enough to drive with state minimum liability. Homeowners, life, and renters insurance are a few of the other products that Great South Insurance offers.

Click to Call

111 2nd Ave NE Ste 300
St Petersburg, FL 33701

Website

(727) 685-5888 Website

Harr & Associates Insurance Inc

Harr & Associates Insurance Inc. is an independent insurance agency located in Largo, Florida, that has been crafting custom auto policies personalized to the needs of drivers in the Saint Petersburg metro area for more than a decade. The agency handles cars, trucks, and motorcycles, and offers clients a variety of coverage options, including uninsured motorist and personal injury protection. By partnering with numerous insurers, Harr & Associates Insurance Inc. ensures clients receive the most competitive rates.

Click to Call

11401 Seminole Blvd
Largo, FL 33778

Website

(727) 393-9146 Website

Hartselle Insurance

Hartselle Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in Seminole, Florida, and serving the St. Petersburg metro area. It has been providing personal and commercial auto insurance from multiple industry-leading insurance agencies for over 30 years. It can provide policies featuring protection against bodily injury and property damage liability, medical bills, and damage to a covered vehicle, as well as uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. The agency also provides homeowners, life, flood, and fire insurance.

Click to Call

8200 113th St Ste 201
Seminole, FL 33772

Website

(727) 393-5000 Website

Insurance Resources, LLC

Founded in 1999, Insurance Resources LLC is an independent insurance agency located in St. Petersburg, Florida. By choosing a full-coverage policy, auto insurance clients gain peace of mind knowing their cars, trucks, and motorcycles are protected against all scenarios with coverage such as comprehensive, property damage, and liability. For drivers seeking to meet the minimum coverage requirements to stay legal, Insurance Resources LLC offers liability-only policies. The agency partners with a variety of insurance carriers, including Nationwide and Progressive.

Click to Call

6620 1st Ave S
St Petersburg, FL 33707

Website

(727) 345-0242 Website

Moore Resources Insurance

Established in 2008 in St. Petersburg, Florida, Moore Resources Insurance is an auto insurance specialist serving the metro area and beyond. The agency's aim is to identify and minimize it's client's exposure to risk. It represents multiple national carriers, enabling it to negotiate competitive pricing for its clients. Auto insurance policies are available to drivers of all age ranges and experience, with optional additions that protect the client when driving in states with laws that vary from Florida's no-fault ruling.

Click to Call

4563 Central Ave
St Petersburg, FL 33713

Website

(727) 323-0206 Website

Patrons Insurance Agency, Inc.

Patrons Insurance Agency Inc. assists clients in the Saint Petersburg, Florida, metro area. It provides auto insurance services, helping clients to purchase coverage for bodily injury liability, personal protection, property damage, and other circumstances. In additional to personal clients, this agency serves businesses, providing commercial auto insurance policies for fleet vehicles, tow trucks, and other automobile related business needs. Patrons Insurance Agency Inc. also offers assistance with home, life, and business insurance.

Click to Call

11322 Seminole Blvd
Largo, FL 33778

Website

(727) 394-1890 Website

Sihle Insurance Group

Sihle Insurance Group is an auto insurance company in Clearwater that serves residents of the Saint Petersburg metro area and statewide. With nine other offices throughout Florida, Sihle Insurance Group works with various insurance companies to provide motorists with personalized policy solutions. Discounts are available to clients with good driving records and those who enroll in the company's paperless billing plan. The company also offers life, business, and homeowners insurance.

Click to Call

2653 McCormick Dr
Clearwater, FL 33759

Website

(727) 531-6800 Website

Wallace Welch & Willingham

Wallace, Welch & Willingham is an insurance agency located in Saint Petersburg, Florida. Since 1925, it has provided insurance products to fit the needs of both individuals and businesses, including auto, homeowners, boat, and life insurance as well as employee benefits coverage. It represents a wide range of top-rated insurance companies that the company's insurance agents can select from to provide a personalized insurance program that will fit clients' needs.

Click to Call

300 1st Ave S # 5
St Petersburg, FL 33701

Website

(727) 522-7777 Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area