Best Insurance Agencies in St. Petersburg

17 Best St. Petersburg Insurance Agencies

  • Our selection process
  • View our top picks

We scored 74 Insurance Agencies in St. Petersburg, FL and Picked the Top 17

Bennie Brinson Insurance Agency is a health insurance company near Saint Petersburg. Founded in 1998, the agency has been helping find competitive rates on needed insurance products for more than three decades. Its general lines include health insurance for families, individuals, and groups. It also sells whole life and term life insurance, Medicare advantage and prescription plans, and policies for home and auto. Insurance quotes are available via phone or online.

CLC Insurance Agency Inc. assists Saint Petersburg customers with evaluation of their insurance needs. This locally owned agency takes pride in helping its clients get the most competitive rates on life insurance, including both term life policies and whole life/universal life coverage. Other coverage types offered include auto, boating, classic car, flood, home, motorcycle, renters, and RV insurance. CLC Insurance Agency Inc. also sells commercial insurance, such as E&O insurance, farm and ranch, and landlord liability policies.

Clifton and Lewis Insurance Group serves the Saint Petersburg area, offering high-quality insurance products that meet the needs of its customers. Founded in 1996, this independent agency specializes in a range of personal and business insurance lines, including life insurance and health insurance. It leverages its 40-plus years of industry experience and relationships with dozens of top companies to help buyers get competitive rates on whole or term life insurance and fee-for-service and managed care health insurance.


Compass Health finds the right life and health insurance solutions for customers in Saint Petersburg. Founded in 2007, the agency is locally owned and operated and serves all of South Florida. Its agents are state licensed and most hold certification from Medicare to help customers with enrollment in Medicare plans. Its offerings include individual health insurance, including ACA and short-term coverage, as well as medical, hospital indemnity, and small group health insurance.


Crevello Financial Services is a trusted source in Saint Petersburg for insurance solutions for groups. This independent agency works with a network of partners, including some of the top insurance carriers in the country, to help its clients get the best coverage for competitive rates. Its group offerings include group life insurance, group health insurance, and group policies for vision, dental, and disability. Quotes are available online or via phone or email.

Healthcare Solutions Team is a health insurance company near Saint Petersburg dedicated to helping its clients find the most competitive rates for health and life insurance coverage. It sells individual, family, small business, and large group coverage with plans such as short-term, major medical, guaranteed issue, and fixed benefit available. Life insurance is available in term and whole or permanent policy configurations. Carriers in the agency's network include Humana One, National General, Aetna, ManhattanLife, and BlueCross BlueShield.


Impel Insurance works with clients throughout Saint Petersburg to help them find insurance coverage at rates that are competitive. It focuses primarily on auto and home insurance with other products available including life, health, and flood insurance. Both individual and group life insurance policies are available. The agency's team helps clients find the right level of health insurance for their needs from an impressive network of trusted national insurance carriers.

McMahan Insurance Solutions helps clients in and around Saint Petersburg with their insurance needs. An independently owned and operated agency, the business has years of experience helping clients find the right level of life insurance and other types of coverage for their needs. The agency's relationships with national carriers allows each customer to get a competitive rate on needed policies. Other insurance products include home and auto, flood, and general liability insurance.

Mutual Insurance Inc. is a life insurance company near Saint Petersburg. The agency's team is dedicated to helping customers find solutions customized to their specific needs when purchasing life insurance and other insurance products. The agency's permanent life insurance options include whole life, limited pay, endowment, and universal life coverage. In addition, it offers temporary life insurance and variable life. Its knowledgeable agents can help customers decide which is right for their particular objectives.

Quote Savage helps Saint Petersburg customers find competitive rates for needed insurance coverage. Founded in 2012, this Florida-based agency connects customers with its network of insurance carriers to find the best possible life insurance coverage. Its knowledgeable agents understand how to structure coverage to help clients protect their families and provide for them if the unforeseeable happens. In addition to life insurance policies, Quote Savage also sells auto insurance policies and home insurance coverage.

Sandal Insurance LLC is a life insurance agency near Saint Petersburg offering years of expertise to its clients in need of coverage. This locally owned independent insurance agency primarily offers personal lines of insurance, including life insurance in whole life or term life options. Additional policies available from Sandal Insurance LLC include home insurance, auto insurance, flood insurance, umbrella insurance, and short-term rental insurance. The company offers proactive annual insurance reviews to ensure customers' coverage levels are up to date.

Sonnenberg Insurance Services, part of SandStone Insurance Partners Affiliate Family, extends its expertise in the insurance industry to clients in Saint Petersburg. In business since 1972, the agency provides coverage for individuals, families, and businesses from a full and comprehensive line of individual health, group health, disability, life, and long-term care offerings. Additional policies are available for homeowners, automobile, accident, and umbrella insurance. The agency is also adept at helping clients with their Medicare Advantage, supplement, and prescription drug coverage.

The Bushko Insurance Group brings its insurance industry expertise to clients in the Saint Petersburg metro area and beyond. The company specializes in insurance products geared toward the senior population, including life insurance, long-term care insurance, disability insurance, and supplemental policies for Medicare, such as Advantage plans and prescription drug plans. Agency owner Heidi L. Bushko has been serving clients in the insurance industry since 2001. SilverScript, Humana, Coventry, Aetna, and United American are all carriers in the agency's network.

The Tom Hendry Insurance Agency is a trusted life insurance agency in Saint Petersburg. The agency is locally owned and operated, and it's dedicated to offering quality insurance products from top insurers to both individuals and businesses. Its life insurance team sells both whole life and term insurance policies. Some policy types offered include individual and group life, long-term care, mortgage protection, disability insurance, second-to-die, and key men insurance coverage.

Victoria Dore – Colonial Life is a life insurance company in Saint Petersburg that mainly serves employers and employees looking for group insurance. It sells life insurance products that enable employees to get the individual coverage needed for themselves and their families. In addition, the company offers flexible spending accounts, critical care insurance, dental insurance, and cancer insurance. Hospital indemnity, disability insurance, and 24/7 health care access are all available.

Weisner Insurance Network is a life insurance company near Saint Petersburg that has helped clients with their insurance needs for more than 20 years. This agency is independently owned and operated, and it connects customers with their choice of insurance carrier while enabling them to get competitive quotes from multiple insurers at once. In addition to life insurance coverage, Weisner Insurance Network offers car, boat, home, and other insurance products.

Wilkinson Insurance is a trusted source for insurance products throughout Saint Petersburg and the greater metro area. Its agents are well-versed in life insurance options and helping clients plan for the unexpected while reaching their financial objectives. The agency's personal insurance lines include coverage for short-term health needs, long-term care, disability insurance, and Medicare coverage such as Medicare Advantage, Part D, and prescription drug coverage. Commercial insurance, including key person protection, is also available.

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: