Best Car Insurance Agencies in Jacksonville

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Jacksonville Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 472 289 15

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

All Florida Insurance Options, Inc.

All Florida Insurance Options Inc. prides itself on its ability to obtain the lowest rates for its customers. The company's qualified agents assess drivers' needs to recommend an auto insurance policy that meets state requirements and includes suitable additional coverage. All Florida Insurance Options Inc. offers policies to young and experienced drivers and insures vehicles of all sizes including RVs and motorcycles. Its partners include Universal, Security First, and Foremost.

3450 Dunn Ave Ste 106
Jacksonville, FL 32218


Auto Insurance World

Auto Insurance World, whose motto is "We want to save you money on insurance," represents over 40 auto insurance companies and has insured Florida drivers since 1979 through its 23 offices in the state. The company offers instant SR-22/FR-44 service and provides coverage over the phone when needed, including to clients with tickets and accidents on their records. Auto Insurance World also covers motorcycles, boats, RVs, and mobile homes, and it offers identity theft protection insurance.

1907 Blanding Blvd
Jacksonville, FL 32210


Donovan & Abercrombie

Founded in 1910, Donovan & Abercrombie is an independent insurance agency with over 45 years of experience assisting drivers in the Jacksonville, Florida, metro area. The company represents several insurance carriers to offer clients a wide range of options, including collision, comprehensive, medical payments, roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, protection for custom parts and equipment, and loan or lease payoff coverage. Donovan & Abercrombie also insure antique and collector cars, motorcycles, and recreational vehicles.

9880 San Jose Blvd # 3
Jacksonville, FL 32257


George Koury & Associates

Since 1975, George Koury & Associates, an auto insurance agency based in Jacksonville, Florida, has assisted clients with getting the right auto insurance coverage to fit their needs and budget. Policies help cover finances in the event of an accident or if the vehicle is damaged or stolen, along with personal liability coverage. The agency also offers health, life, home, and group insurance policies for businesses, such as business liability and workers' compensation.

4221 Baymeadows Rd Ste 5
Jacksonville, FL 32217


Insuramerica of Florida, Inc.

Insuramerica of Florida Inc. is an independent insurance agency with more than three decades of experience building customized auto policies for drivers in the Jacksonville metro area. The agency works with a variety of A.M. Best's most highly rated insurers to provide policies for cars, trucks, and motorcycles with robust coverage options such as liability, comprehensive, and personal injury protection. Insuramerica of Florida Inc. also offers commercial and life insurance.

4348 Southpoint Blvd Ste 200
Jacksonville, FL 32216


Insurance Place of Orange Park

Insurance Place of Orange Park in Orange Park, Florida, helps local drivers, including those in Jacksonville, Fleming Island, and Clay County, explore their auto insurance options. Doing business since 1989, this independent insurance agency maintains a wealth of relationships with leading insurance carriers that lets it easily obtain comparative quotes and coverage options to personalize an auto insurance policy that works for each individual client's needs. It also sells other personal insurance lines, including watercraft, motorcycle, and recreational vehicle policies.

999 Blanding Blvd
Orange Park, FL 32065


Lassiter-Ware Insurance

Founded in 1912, Lassiter-Ware Insurance is an insurance agency in Jacksonville, Florida, with four other offices throughout the state and a business approach of serving customers first. Lassiter-Ware focuses on finding the right automobile coverage for individuals, families, and businesses. With over 30 insurance carriers to choose from, Lassiter-Ware Insurance offers individualized plans for new to the most experienced drivers. In addition to automobile coverage, Lassiter-Ware offers coverage for ATVs, motorcycles, and watercraft.

8659 Baypine Rd Ste 100
Jacksonville, FL 32256


Mike Bell Insurance Agency

Founded in 1992, the Mike Bell Insurance Agency is an independently owned and operated insurance company based in Jacksonville, Florida. Auto coverage specialists seek quotes from multiple carriers to find the right amount of coverage to fit drivers' needs and budgets. The company also covers small, motorized vehicles, such as cars, motorcycles, RVs, ATVs, boats, personal watercraft, and golf carts, and provides insurance for homes, floods, and liability for small businesses.

1819 3rd St N
Jacksonville, FL 32250


Sihle Insurance

Founded in 1974, Sihle Insurance is a local, family-owned and professionally managed insurance agency in Jacksonville, Florida. The firm works with insurance companies such as Nationwide and Progressive to provide clients with personalized auto insurance. With nine additional offices across the state, Sihle's team of agents specializes in aspects of coverage involving vehicle repairs and replacement auto parts. The company offers car rental reimbursement and roadside assistance. Discounts are available for students.

1000 Riverside Ave Ste 500
Jacksonville, FL 32204


Sonic Insurance

Sonic Insurance serves clients throughout Florida from offices in Ponte Vedra Beach and Key Largo. The company issues personal auto and motorcycle policies as well as commercial vehicle policies, considering variables such as the age of the driver, driving history, and type of car to determine the most suitable policy for each client. Sonic Insurance is a Trusted Choice company offering a Pledge of Performance to provide outstanding service on home and commercial insurance.

822 A1A N Ste 310
Ponte Vedra Beach, FL 32082


The Della Porta Group, Inc.

Established in 1968 in Jacksonville, Florida, The Della Porta Group Inc. is an independent agency specializing in auto insurance. It defines its goal as to provide clear and concise explanations of policies so its clients can make the best decisions. The agency represents many carriers, allowing it to search from a wide range of auto insurance policies. Coverage will typically include damage to or theft of the car, liability to others hurt in an accident, and medical costs for injuries.

7807 Baymeadows Rd E Ste 301
Jacksonville, FL 32256


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: