Laurels
Best Property
Managers in
Fort Myers
2018

Why These Property Managers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored property managers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best property managers in Fort Myers, FL.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks24189

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Absolute Equity Realty Group

Located in Fort Myers, Florida, Absolute Equity Realty Group is a real estate service contractor that services all of Southwest Florida. The staff at Absolute Equity specialize in relocations, investment properties, second homes, short sales, and general property management services. Their property management services include, but are not limited to, 24/7 availability for tenants and owners via an online service portal, property advertising, extensive tenant screening, routine inspections, monitored rent payments and late-payments, tenant move-out and walk-through, and cleaning and maintenance services. The partnering owners are Katrina and Mark Allison. Both business owners offer their expertise based on years of qualifying experience; Katrina has been a licensed agent for over 20 years, and Mark is a certified property appraiser.

Fort Myers, FL(239) 454-9300

Website

All County Medallion Property Management

All County Medallion Property Management, located in Fort Myers, Florida, is a professional property management company that serves clients in the surrounding metropolitan area. The company offers a free over-the-phone quote on its services to prospective clients. Such services include marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, negotiation of leases, maintenance, around-the-clock emergency availability, and more. All County Medallion Property Management has more than twenty years of experience in the industry and specializes in single-family homes, townhouses, apartment buildings, and condominiums. Previous clients praise the company for the convenience of its online portal as well as its professional, positive atmosphere.

Fort Myers, FL(239) 204-4171

Website

Alliance Realty Group

Alliance Realty Group, managed by Broker/Principal Debra B. Jennings, is a southwest Florida real estate group that has sold over a billion dollars in real estate and helped over 4000 families find their new home in the areas of Ft. Myers, Cape Coral, Lehigh Acres, Bonita Springs, Estero, and Naples since 2006. Alliance Realty Group has over 100 real estate agents and gives clients access to a website with a built-in feature for searching available properties. Having earned the Best in Client Satisfaction Award from Gulfshore Life Magazine for nearly ten years in a row, Alliance Realty Group offers a full service guide to real estate in southwest Florida in order to best assist its clients. David Jennings, Realtor/Principal, also offers customers services and information on how to build a home on any property and is available to discuss build layouts and designs with most of the areas best builders.

Fort Myers, FL(239) 274-6637

Website

Anchor Property Management

Anchor Property Management is a Fort Myers business that has more than 62 years of combined experience. The business has been serving Lee County for more than 30 years. Property management services include in-house maintenance, tenant selection, tenant initial property inspections, tenant pre and post inspections, quarterly, semi-annual, and annual inspections, access to online reporting, monthly statements, year-end reporting, monthly market rent verification, following up with late rent payers, the choice of paper check or direct deposits, and repairs. Anchor Property Management offers owners’ interviews and provides low fees. The business is experienced in buying, renovating, selling, and renting multi-family, single family, duplexes, and condos.

Fort Myers, FL(239) 994-4678

Website

Cape Shore Property Management

Cape Shore Property Management has been a premier provider of high quality, customized solutions for more than 20 years. The full-service real estate management firm specializes in taking the hassle out of property leasing and management to provide owners with peace of mind. The Cape Coral-area business delivers ethical, trustworthy services that maximize real estate property investment while minimizing vacancies. Cape Shore Property Management makes client satisfaction a top priority by staying abreast of the latest news, laws, and developments in the local real estate market. Property owners can rely on the experts to perform an array of services including superior tenant screening, maintenance, repairs, rent collection, and more. The dedicated team of experts employs cutting-edge technology and the most up to date tools available to supply safe, clean housing for tenants while meeting all property owner needs.

Cape Coral, FL(239) 549-6611

Website

My Realty Story

My Realty Story has an excellent reputation for providing impeccable service and attention to detail that exceeds client expectations. The Cape Coral-area, property management experts specialize in eliminating the headaches of investment real estate ownership while managing properties with maximum efficiency. The full-service firm excels at matching buyers, sellers, landlords, and tenants together to meet a range of needs, goals, and budgets. My Realty Story employs a team of talented, driven professionals with more than 20 years of experience in leadership, operations, customer service, and market knowledge. Owners enjoy peace of mind knowing that investment properties are well-cared for and the firm has the expertise to prevent problems before they arise. The luxury marketing specialists go above and beyond to protect owner investments and increase profitability.

Cape Coral, FL(239) 800-3054

Website

Property Management of SW Florida

Property Management of SW Florida is a full-service property management firm that is located in Fort Myers, Florida. The service areas covered include SW Florida, Fort Myers, Fort Myers, Beach, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, and Naples. This firm makes the tenant process as easy and user-friendly as possible on its website. From the online application, maintenance issues, to online payments, the firm makes sure that the tenants get the best of what they need. Property Management of SW Florida is accredited with the CFRM, A Larson Educational Services Property Management Designation. It is a proud member of the Florida Community Association Professionals, holds the Realtor accreditation, and is also accredited by the Equal Housing Opportunity agency.

Fort Myers, FL(239) 245-7203

Website

Sunshine Rentals & Property Management Inc.

Since 2011, Sunshine Rentals and Property Management Inc. has been specializing in property management of single-family homes, condominiums, and townhomes for homeowners and investors in Lee County, FL. With occupancy rates of managed properties ranging from 92% to 100%, Sunshine Rentals and Property Management Inc. offers services that include marketing and advertising properties, coordinating repairs and maintenance, showing properties, preparing leases with attorneys, and collecting funds. Additionally, Sunshine Rentals and Property Management Inc. provides financial services that include monthly income and expense statements, year-end statements, and income tax documents. They utilize property-management and accounting software AppFolio Property manager that allows for secure communication between owners, tenants, and vendors and access to a variety of property information.

Cape Coral, FL(239) 541-5570

Website

Uptown Property Services

Ashley Simonelli is the Property Manager for Uptown Property Services in Fort Myers. With more than 10 years of property management experience, she serves primarily as a liaison between the tenants, vendors, and property owners, making sure the property operates efficiently and provides a maximized return for the owner. The company’s services include detailed and thorough tenant screening, rent collection and tenant relations, comprehensive and regular property inspections, free 24/7 availability for emergency calls, and no setup fees or upcharges. They charge no markup on services charged by vendors and concentrate on minimizing tenant turnover and maximizing rents. Properties are maintained at a level that maximizes their return on investment. The company undertakes all bill payment, bookkeeping, and financial reporting on behalf of their clients. Reviews remark on the speed with which the company lets out properties and resolves issues.

Fort Myers, FL(239) 691-0810

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area