hero image

Best Property
Managers in

Why These Property Managers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored property managers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best property managers in Sarasota, FL.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 25 20 13

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of Great Jones  property-management/1.jpg

Great Jones FEATURED Expertise

Great Jones is a renowned property management agency in Sarasota that provides a seamless, full-service experience for owners and residents and helps owners maximize their return from residential real estate investment. Property owners receive an exhaustive list of services including property marketing, resident placement, property inspections, monthly and annual financial reporting, rent collection, evictions, maintenance, and legal compliance. Great Jones also purchases, renovates, manages, and sells residential real estate properties.

442 W Kennedy Boulevard Suite 280
Tampa, FL 33606


cover image of Ascendia Property Management  property-management/2.jpg

Ascendia Property Management

Ascendia Property Management is a property management firm in Sarasota, Florida. Ascendia Property Management serves the areas of Sarasota, Manatee, the Islands, Downtown Sarasota, Palmer Ranch, Golden Gate Pointe, Venice Island, Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, St. Armands, Siesta Key, Lido Key, and Longboat Key. Their services include marketing services, accounting services, online capabilities, tenant management services, homewatch services, and maintenance and housekeeping services. Ascendia Property Management delivers exceptional rental properties and offers 24/7 support as well as a reliable, locally based management team. This property management agency provides 5-star customer service. Ascendia Property Management won the 2015 Traveler’s Choice award by Trip Advisor.

Siesta Key, FL 34242


cover image of Florida West Coast Property Management  property-management/3.jpg

Florida West Coast Property Management

Based in Bradenton, Florida, Florida West Coast Property Management has been offering a full line of high-quality property management services to property owners, real estate investors, and tenants in the southwest part of Florida for over 33 years. Owners of condominium units, single-family houses, and townhomes can rest assured that professional, experienced real estate agents handle their properties’ day-to-day operations. The services they offer include property marketing and advertising, property tour for prospective tenants, complete tenant screening process, tenant deposit collection, execution of lease agreements, and routine property inspections. In addition, licensed and insured vendors attend to tenants' maintenance requests promptly. Florida West Coast Property Management is a highly rated company across various online review platforms including Yelp, Facebook, and Google Local.

Bradenton, FL 34202


cover image of Gulf Coast Property Management  property-management/4.jpg

Gulf Coast Property Management

Gulf Coast Property Management is a respected real estate solutions provider in Lakewood Ranch and the rest of the Sarasota metro. The firm has been part of the Sunshine State’s vibrant industry for more than 10 years, and it is a member of the National Association of Residential Property Managers, Vacation Rental Managers Association, and other reputable organizations. The company is a homegrown trade that knows the local market’s behavior and needs very well, and it devotes its professional resources to the delivery perfect owner-occupant matches. The team members have decades of cumulative experience and training, and they offer accessibility, responsiveness, and efficiency. Gulf Coast Property Management enjoys good reviews from past and present clients, as well as their referrals, and it offers service guarantees.

Lakewood Ranch, FL 34211


cover image of Home Rentals of Manatee  property-management/1.jpg

Home Rentals of Manatee

Home Rentals of Manatee specializes in high-quality property management services for the individual homeowner, investor, or landlord. Based in Bradenton, Florida, they provide twenty-four-hour of coverage in the areas of Bradenton, Ellenton, Lakewood Ranch, Palmetto, and Parrish. Services include screening for a prospective tenant, after-hour emergencies, annual property reviews, and rent collections. Past clients have appreciated their professionalism and effective management. The broker and co-owner, Barbara Mayo, has over twenty-five years of experience and received a Master Property Manager designation in 2009 through the National Association of Residential Property Managers. Home Rentals of Manatee manages both residential and vacation properties with competitive fees. Management fees may be tax deductible.

Bradenton, FL 34208


cover image of Kajuka Properties  property-management/2.jpg

Kajuka Properties

Kajuka Properties offers flexible and affordable property management services to real estate professionals, second homeowners, or property investors in Bradenton, Florida and the surrounding areas. Their company comprises a team of professional property managers who possess the education, experience, and expertise in the full cycle of real estate investments. In addition to handling the day-to-day operations of their clients’ respective properties, they offer other services that are guaranteed to be profitable to property owners. These services are home watching, eviction protection, rigorous tenant screening, and access to a secured system that shows upcoming and late payments and maintenance work orders. Kajuka Properties is an accredited business with the Better Business Bureau and a proud member of the National Association of Residential Property Managers.

Bradenton, FL 34210


cover image of Lindsay Leasing LLC  property-management/3.jpg

Lindsay Leasing LLC

Lindsay Leasing LLC is a property management company operating out of Sarasota, Florida, that serves clients all around the metro area. Residential clients are the primary focus of its services, which include screening of tenants and rent collection, as well as maintenance services involving the safety and security of properties. It also advises owners on advantageous business practices such as ideal rental rates and marketing approaches in order to help keep properties profitable and viable.

5020 Clark Rd #211
Sarasota, FL 34233


cover image of Newby Management  property-management/4.jpg

Newby Management

Since 1975, Newby Management has provided Ellenton, FL, and communities throughout Florida with full-service property management. Martin Newby, the founder and company namesake, emphasizes a philosophy of honesty, integrity, and ethical behavior in all that Newby Management handles. The team of associates oversees more than thirty manufactured home and RV communities throughout the state while offering an extensive range of services, including maintenance, rule enforcement, and 24-hour crisis management. Newby Management also collects rent, handles budgets, operates human resources, and specializes in website design and social media marketing. Additionally, they offer a chaplaincy program for communities, where they visit the sick and housebound, assist with weddings or funerals, or establish church services. For a complete list of services and pricing, Newby Management responds quickly to phone or email inquiries.

Ellenton, FL 34222


cover image of Oakleaf Property Management  property-management/1.jpg

Oakleaf Property Management

Oakleaf Property Management has over 15 years of experience helping owners and renters maximize their profits or find properties which suit their lifestyles and budgets. The company understands that property management can be difficult, and strives to provide a fully qualified and detail oriented service to all customers to help them. Their employees help customers in Bradenton, Sarasota, St. Petersburg, and many nearby towns. Potential tenants can contact the company to search for properties in the area, while owners can trust Oakleaf Property Management with services like tenant evaluations, general building maintenance, and lease negotiations. The company specializes in aggressive marketing strategies which help customers get their properties visible on the market using classified ads, fliers, and over 40 different websites.

Bradenton, FL 34208


cover image of Rent Sarasota  property-management/2.jpg

Rent Sarasota

Rent Sarasota offers professional property management to investors with properties throughout the Central Gulf Coast. The company focuses on filling vacancies fast and finding and keeping quality tenants via rigorous screenings and attentive managers, and services include a convenient tenant portal for rent pay and maintenance requests, 24/7 emergency contacts, routine upkeep, rent collection, monthly expense and maintenance reporting, and move-in and move-out inspections. The group handles all marketing, showings, and lease docs properly prepared by an attorney and utilizes the high-tech AppFolio Property Manager for optimal leasing results. Rent Sarasota works with both long-term and short-term/vacation rentals in Sarasota, Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, Osprey and Venice, and clients as well as real estate agents highly recommend the team.

Sarasota, FL 34237


cover image of Ryntal Property Management  property-management/3.jpg

Ryntal Property Management

Ryntal Property Management is a Sarasota property management company. Clients appreciate the highly experienced team and management services including cleaning, renting, tenant placement, maintenance, inspections, evictions, accounting, and home watch. The group can also advise on home improvements to increase value and helps individuals find investment properties as well. The group is known for cost-effective and efficient solutions, strategic marketing, a 24/7 online system and owner portal, and solid long-term relationships with its clients. Tenants also have multiple online resources and can submit maintenance requests directly via the site. Ryntal Property Management is affiliated with the NARPM, holds an A rating with the BBB under The Ryntal Group, LLC, and is a member of the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee.

Sarasota, FL 34243


cover image of Sarasota Management & Leasing  property-management/4.jpg

Sarasota Management & Leasing

For over twenty years, Sarasota Management and Leasing has offered property owners assistance in the oversight and administration of homes and condominiums throughout Sarasota and Bradenton, FL. Their associates specialize in performing market analyses for clients to accurately price a property and heavily market it to prospective tenants. Sarasota Management and Leasing also screen tenants for credit and criminal histories, performs move-in and move-out inspections, draws up detailed leases, collects rent, and offers maintenance and repair services. They also provide an optional eviction protection program that covers court and legal fees if a problem tenant should ever arise. Detailed brochures are available for prospective clients, and they provide references from previous customers upon request.

Sarasota, FL 34240


cover image of Sunshine Managed Investments Network  property-management/1.jpg

Sunshine Managed Investments Network

Sunshine Managed Investments Network is a real estate solutions provider in Sarasota that caters to several neighborhoods in the Tampa Bay Area. The establishment is a fast-growing network of realtors, property managers, and brokerages, and it boasts a marketing system that focuses more on “residential leasing rather than sales or buyer leads.” The company attracts high-quality tenants and has the resources to sift through thousands of applications, and it always helps the owners make sound choices. The team also sees to the well-being and safety of the occupants, and it has a 24/7 assistance unit that promptly addresses maintenance issues. Sunshine Managed Investments Network gives a complimentary quote, and it aims for nationwide coverage in a few years. The focus areas include low turnover and proper maintenance.

Sarasota, FL 34231


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area