Best Car Insurance Agencies in Pittsburgh

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Pittsburgh Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 186 116 11

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Crawford Insurance

Founded in 1951, Crawford Insurance is a local independent insurance company serving the greater Pittsburgh, Pennslvania, area. Crawford Insurance provides clients with a range of quality auto insurance products to suit their vehicle types and personal automobile insurance requirements. Discounts are available to clients whose vehicles contain airbags, anti-lock brakes, and additional safety or security systems. Crawford Insurance is also able to assist clients with their business and household insurance requirements.

11743 Frankstown Rd
Pittsburgh, PA 15235


Cusumano Insurance Agency

Founded in 1958, Cusumano Insurance Agency Inc. is an auto insurance provider based in Pittsburgh, serving the Western Pennsylvania area. Its tailored auto policies come from regional insurance carriers, factoring in no-fault states, additional medical bills, and collisions with uninsured drivers. It also sells specialty auto insurance for off-road vehicles, RVs, and classic cars. The agency's other individual policies include home, life, and wedding. It also sells business policies, including commercial property, and workers' compensation.

178 Clairton Blvd
Pittsburgh, PA 15236


Dinnin & Parkins Associates

Dinnin & Parkins Associates was established in 1994 to provide independent insurance services in the Pittsburgh metro area. Located in Oakmont, Pennsylvania, the agency includes auto insurance in its list of specialisms. It discusses specifics with each client then searches for the right policy from the insurance carriers it represents. Policies can then be tailored to the client's needs and budget. This can include coverage if personal property is damaged and medical payments to meet recuperation expenses.

300 Allegheny River Blvd
Oakmont, PA 15139


Hurley Insurance Brokers

Hurley Insurance Brokers has covered drivers in the Pittsburgh metro area for more than a decade. As an independent agency, it works with different carriers to find the best terms. Policies can include a variety of coverages such as liability, uninsured motorist, and property damage. Clients can add comprehensive coverage to protect their cars, trucks, and motorcycles against fires and hit-and-runs. Hurley Insurance Brokers also provides specialty insurance catering to the unique concerns of high net-worth clients.

3508 5th Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15213


Insurance Consultants of Pittsburgh

Established in 1987, Insurance Consultants of Pittsburgh offers automobile insurance to clients in western and central Pennsylvania. Founders, George Delistienne and Stephen Gallagher, created the firm based on the principle of doing what is best for clients. With a multitude of insurance carriers to choose from, Insurance Consultants of Pittsburgh develops tailored solutions to meet clients' automobile needs. Insurance Consultants of Pittsburgh also sells home, health, business, umbrella, and group insurance.

300 Mount Lebanon Blvd Ste 205A
Pittsburgh, PA 15234


OHL Insurance and Financial Services, Inc

OHL Insurance and Financial Services Inc. is an independent insurance agency affiliated with over 40 insurance companies, including Liberty Mutual, Progressive, and Nationwide. Located in Manor, Pennsylvania, with another office in Leechburg, it provides service to the Pittsburgh metro and throughout the state. It offers several coverage options in its auto insurance policy, including collision, comprehensive, liability, medical payment, and personal injury protection. Clients can also add reimbursement coverage for expenses such as towing, car rentals, and roadside assistance.

57 Race St
Manor, PA 15665


Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency

Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency assists clients with finding auto insurance policies and serves the entire Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, metro area. This agency is an independent company offering rates without bias for any specific provider and consults clients on liability and comprehensive coverage areas. It also informs clients on minimum legal requirements and helps them to explore additional coverage areas suitable for their specific needs. Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency also provides home and life insurance services.

200 Wallace Rd Ste 100
Wexford, PA 15090


Single Source Benefits Insurance Enrollment Center

Single Source Benefits Insurance Enrollment Center is an independent insurance agency based in and serving the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, area with a full suite of coverage options including auto insurance. The company's agents work with each client to provide policies with customized levels of liability, collision, and underinsured motorist insurance. Optional services such as roadside assistance, towing, and rental reimbursement help reduce downtime to keep clients on the road and minimize the financial impact when accidents and vehicle damage occur.

1220 Mayview Rd
Pittsburgh, PA 15241


Wagner Agency, Inc.

Wagner Agency Inc. is an independent insurance agency that has more than seven decades of experience insuring residents of the Pittsburgh metro area. The agency offers auto insurance policies designed to address clients' concerns with coverages such as liability, property damage, and uninsured motorist. Drivers can recoup their losses from damages due to fire and vandalism with comprehensive coverage. Wagner Agency Inc. can insure all types of cars and trucks through its wide range of carriers, including Progressive and Safeco.

5020 Centre Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15213


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: