Best Tire Shops
in Indianapolis

Why These Tire Shops?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored tire shops on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best tire shops in Indianapolis, IN.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks1841126

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

A's Legitimate Used Tires

A's Legitimate Used Tires, home of the $15 used tire, is located in Indianapolis, Indiana. They aim to serve customers looking for amazing deals and service for their vehicles. The shop is owned and operated by Jeremy O'Day, and his entire staff is service-oriented and extremely knowledgeable. A's Legitimate Used Tires is concerned about the safety of customers above all else, and they offer free tire inspections to check and adjust air pressure to ensure it meets OEM standards. They pride themselves on being able to carry most major tire brands, including Firestone, Bridgestone, Goodyear, Cooper, Pirelli, Michelin, Dunlop, BF Goodrich, and more. Services offered by A's Legitimate Used Tires include single through complete set standard tread, single through complete set high tread, Tire Pressure Monitoring System sensors, tire balancing, rotations, and tire mounts and dismounts. They also offer an in-store warranty, which covers unpredictable tire malfunctions such as rim leaks, belt separations, and valve stem leaks. A's Legitimate Used Tires can be reached by phone, email, in-store, or through social media, and they are open seven days per week.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 507-8583


All Star Tire & Auto Service

All Star Tire & Auto Service is a family-owned auto, tire, and truck maintenance and repair facility that has been serving the Indianapolis area since 1940. They specialize in both the sales and service of high performance tires for Asian and European imports, as well as domestic automotive applications. They use only the most efficient, state-of-the-art technologies and equipment, and are an Affiliated Dealer of the Bridgestone-Firestone Company. All Star Tire & Auto Service also offers tire storage for those who have no place to keep out-of-season summer or winter tires. Other services offered by All Star Tire & Auto Service include battery sales and service, oil changes, alignments, tire balancing and repair, engine tune-ups and service, engine diagnostics, engine replacement, complete brake work, heating and air conditioning service, exhaust systems, transmission replacement, TPMS service, filter replacement, axle repair, differential service, and much more. All Star Tire & Auto Service has also made strides in taking several green initiatives such as recycling waste oil, filters, engine coolant, tires, and used automotive parts. Prospective customers are given the option to apply for financing through Bridgestone and Firestone by way of an online credit application process or in-store. All Star Tire & Auto Service comes highly recommended on Angie's List, and has maintained an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 269-0500


AutoTire Car Care Centers, Inc.

Auto Tire Car Care Centers, Inc., located in Indianapolis, Indiana, has a devout mission to create an unparalleled and unmatched customer service experience. They are committed to providing exceptional products and services, pristine facilities, the best team of employees, high-quality parts, and competitive prices. Auto Tire Car Care Centers was first established in 1981 by Kevin Vaught with the core values to exceed all customer expectations, to always offer only the highest quality products at the best prices, and to stand behind products and services at any cost. The shop is still operated by the Vaught family, and they are dedicated to working as hard as necessary in order to guarantee complete customer satisfaction. Services offered by Auto Tire Car Care Centers include alignments, batteries, brakes, emission analysis, engine analysis, fuel system cleaning, heating and air conditioning service, maintenance packages, mufflers and radiators, starters, timing belts, tire repair, transmission service, tune-ups, wheel balancing exhaust systems, and more. Auto Tire Car Care Centers use only brand name parts like AC Delco, Motorcraft, Champion, Anco, Raybestos, Wagner, and Monroe. Additional services offered include a free reminder card program which automatically alerts customers to upcoming vehicle maintenance suggestions, free computerized work history logs, free manufacturer's maintenance schedules, and free used car inspections.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 881-1101


Circle City Hubcaps & Wheels

Circle City Hubcaps & Wheels is Indianapolis, Indiana's premier wheel repair specialist. They specialize in straightening, repairing, refinishing, re-polishing, painting, and fixing damaged wheels. With over 20 years of experience in the industry, they have the knowledge and capacity needed to complete even the toughest of jobs. Each service offered is personalized and catered to each customer's individual needs, and they carry most major brands and sizes of wheels and tires. Circle City Hubcaps & Wheels is proud to be a source of durability, quality, and reliability, and they offer in-store financing options to qualified applicants. Circle City Hubcaps & Wheels offers wheel repair, tire sales, and wheelskins. Wheelskins are a polymer product that gives vehicles a sharp appearance for many years, and are highly resistant to salt, chemicals, cold, heat, and impacts. Past satisfied customers have appreciated the quick and efficient service, and have said Circle City Hubcaps & Wheels offers the best prices in the area. Circle City Hubcaps & Wheels is open Monday through Saturday, and can be reached in-store, by email, by phone, or by fax.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 890-1450


Elite New and Used Tires & Auto Service

Elite New and Used Tires & Auto Service is a newly formed tire shop located in Indianapolis, Indiana. In addition to new and used tires sales, as their name suggests, they also offer a complete selection of automotive services. Safety and value are primary goals, so they offer only premium tires at the most affordable and competitive prices. Other services offered by Elite New and Used Tires & Auto Service include tire rotating and balancing, complete brake services, windshield repair and replacement, windshield wiper replacement, alignments, and oil changes. Elite New and Used Tires & Auto Service strives to be a one-stop-shop for all vehicle repair and replacement needs, and they are passionate about keeping customers in the area rather than needing to refer them to other providers outside of Indianapolis. The business was first formed in April of 2016, and they continue to pride themselves on their "no part mark-up" policy and the ability to offer financing options to qualified applicants. Customers have raved about this new business, and appreciate the fast, efficient, and competent team of technicians. Elite New and Used Tires & Auto Service is open Monday through Sunday, and can be contacted by phone, social media, and in-store.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 389-7944


Real Man's Tire Co.

Real Man's Tire Co. is a full-service, family-owned tire shop that is located in Indianapolis, Indiana. They offer used tires, new tires, used wheels, and new, custom wheels from 13" to 32". Since 1970, they have been building professional relationships across the country, which now allows them to find any part at the best price. The highly experienced staff are capable of choosing the safest and most cost-effective product for vehicles, and they specialize in brakes, shocks, struts, tires, wheels, and general suspension. Real Man's Tire Co. offers a wide variety of services including custom wheel sales and service, new and used name brand tires, computerized balancing, TPMS reset and replacement, tire inspection, fleet services, professional tire installation, and mechanical repairs. They also carry a wide selection of passenger tires, painted wheels, wheel and tire packages, and chrome wheel and tire packages. Real Man's Tire Co. carries only the best tires from well-known brands like Durun, Milestar, Goodyear, Uniroyal, Michelin, Cooper, Nexen, Delinte, and more. All prices advertised by Real Man's Tire Co. include professional mounting, TPMS, locks, balancing, and installation; no hidden fees or surprise charges like some competitors use when trying to compensate for offering unbelievable specials. Real Man's Tire Co. can be reached by phone, email, online, or in-store, and can be found on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, LinkedIn, and Google+.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 542-8473


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: