Best Property
Managers in

Why These Property Managers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored property managers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best property managers in Indianapolis, IN.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks21113420

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

A Step Ahead Management

A Step Ahead Management is a locally owned and operated property management firm in Carmel, IN. The company specializes in the leasing and management of single-family homes. The staff has more than 20 years of combined experience and knows the ins and outs of the neighborhoods of Indianapolis and the surrounding area. The leasing team gets homes rented within 20 days of a vacancy on average, and tenants stay on average for three years with less than a 1 percent eviction rate. A Step Ahead Management works with local vendors to get maintenance work done quickly and cost-effectively, and before and after pictures are required before payment is authorized.

Carmel, IN(317) 912-1507


A.M. Real Estate Resources

A.M. Real Estate Resources is a property management firm in Carmel that connects tenants with rental property owners in Central Indiana. The company has more than 30 years of experience in the industry, and it is committed to protecting the clients' interest while minimizing the hassles. A.M. Real Estate Resources is a member of various professional associations, and its website features portals for owners and tenants.

Carmel, IN(317) 848-1588


Becovic Management Group

Becovic Management Group is a full-service property management company specializing in the management of multi-family apartment complexes. Founded in 1973, they develop residential and commercial properties throughout the Midwest that are distinguished by high-quality construction, innovative design, attractive landscaping, lavish amenities for residents, and unmatched property management and service. In 2016 alone, Becovic Property Management received the Gene B. Glick Spirit Of Giving Award, the Prodigy Award for Best Community Green Initiative Program, and the Prodigy Award for Community of the Year from the Indiana Apartment Association. Becovic Management Group is accredited by and holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.

Fishers, IN(317) 570-0400


Brick Lane Property Management

Brick Lane is a residential property management company in Indianapolis that helps homeowners realize the full potential of their real estate investments. The company focuses on properties in Central Indiana, and it deals with single-unit houses and multi-family complexes. Brick Lane has an in-house construction team that rehabilitates, repairs, and prepares the rental homes.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 759-0332


Edenbridge, Inc.

Edenbridge is a real estate service provider in Plainfield that handles all aspects of residential property management. The company has more than 20 years of experience in the industry, and its range of services includes real estate brokerage, estate planning, and guidance on compliance matters. Edenbridge is a member of professional associations like the National Association of Realtors and the Indiana Association of Realtors, and it supports the Equal Housing Opportunity campaign.

Plainfield, IN(317) 626-0722


ES Property Management

ES Property Management is a property manager in Indianapolis and Greenwood that handles rental and investment homes. The firm also deals with the buying and selling of real estate assets, and it serves local and international clients. ES Property Management is an equal housing provider, and this means that it does not discriminate against lawful persons on the basis of their national origin, gender, sexual orientation, religion, disability, age, or familial status.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 883-9790


Ethosity Property Management Group

Ethosity is a property management firm in Indianapolis that deals with rent collection, property marketing, tenant screening, property inspections, financial reporting, and maintenance. The company also handles eviction processes, and it provides legal guidance to owners to be sure that the investments are compliant with federal laws and state regulations. Ethosity is an equal housing provider, and its core values include honesty and professional integrity.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 514-2403


HARVEY Property Management Group LLC

Harvey is a property management company in Indianapolis that deals with real estate investments within the metro. The principal has more than 30 years of professional experience, and one of his firm's successes involves handling a client's portfolio of 48 foreclosed real estate assets that were purchased from a lender. Harvey was able to keep the tenants of 20 of these properties, and it brought in new ones for the 28 others, shortly after these were renovated.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 623-8500


Indiana Property Group

Indiana Property Group is a real estate services provider in Greenwood that engages in property management, real estate purchasing and selling, and property remodeling. The company serves the Greater Indiana area, and it has more than 20 years of experience in home rentals. Some of the company's services are screening and securing tenants, collecting current and delinquent rental payments, and 24/7 response on maintenance concerns. Indiana Property Group accepts tenant applications online, and it charges $35 for each submission.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 366-9352


Indiana Property Management Group, LLC

Indiana Property Management Group is a property management firm in Indianapolis that deals with the challenges of renting out apartments, condominiums, single-family homes, and other residential units. The company assists real estate investors in procedures like drafting contracts and conducting credit checks, and it helps tenants on matters like convenient payment systems and immediate response to maintenance requests.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 759-1086


James Management Group, LLC

James Management Group is a property management firm in Carmel that commits to decreasing their clients' stressful involvement in the investment process while increasing their profits. The company handles single-family residential units, as well as apartment complexes, and it also engages in property development. The website features the paper, “The 10 Things You Need To Know When Renting so You Don't Get Burned”, which can be downloaded for free.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 497-5655


Justus Property Management, Inc.

Justus is a property management company in Whitestown and Nappanee that opened in 1989. The firm handles more than 75 apartment communities and 2,000 units across the state, and its practice is in accordance with federal laws and state regulations. Justus' owner is a past president of the Institute of Real Estate Management's Northern Indiana Chapter 100, and he has also served as the state president of the Rural Rental Housing Association of Indiana for four terms.

Whitestown, IN(317) 834-4756


Polaris Property Management, LLC

Polaris is a property management company in Indianapolis that deals with the real estate market forces in the metro. The principal has 20 years of experience in the field, and he is a member of several professional organizations like the National Association of Realtors, Indiana Real Estate Investor Association, and Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors. Polaris handles property upkeep and rent collection, and it commits to resolving maintenance and repair issues swiftly and effectively.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 870-3249


Reid Properties LLC

Reid Properties is a property manager in Indianapolis. The company focuses on investor relations, and it assists clients in remodeling, renting, and maintaining their assets to maximize the return on investment. A property owner attests to the company's professionalism, writing, “The service I receive from Reid Properties is first class. From inventorying all of my contents, to repairs to sorting the tenants, contracts, and rent, and keeping on top of everything. Always personal visits and good people. Great experience.”

Indianapolis, IN(317) 241-3955


Swan Properties

Swan Properties is a real estate services provider in Fortville that manages properties in the Greater Indiana area. The company opened in 1994, and its focus communities include Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, McCordsville, Noblesville, and Zionsville. Swan Properties also assists clients with the sales of single-family or condominium homes, relocation to and from the metro, investment evaluation, and property development.

Fortville, IN(317) 747-7022


T&H Realty Services, Inc

T&H Realty Services is a property management company in Indianapolis that both protects and promotes its clients' real estate investments in the metro. The firm handles properties that command at least $1,000 in monthly rent, and its client base consists of local property owners. The firm's founders each have more than 15 years of professional experience, and they are themselves real estate investors. T&H Realty Services is a state-licensed real estate brokerage, and it has other locations around Indiana.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 255-7767


Triple E Property Management LLC

Triple E is a property management firm in Indianapolis that truly cares for clients' real estate investments. Some of the company's services are initial evaluation, active marketing, maintenance, inspections, and the preparation of accurate and timely financial statements. The company also deals with eviction cases, and its assistance extends to tenant debt collection. Triple E runs a referral and incubation program for realtors and other qualified parties.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 210-3636


True Property Management

True Property Management Group is a property manager in Indianapolis and neighboring communities like Brownsberg, Greenwood, and Broad Ripple. The company handles maintenance and repair work, and other matters that affect its clients' real estate assets. True Property Management Group also helps with buying and selling homes in the area.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 679-1551


Zidan Management Group, Inc.

Zidans is a property management company in Indianapolis that delivers its services under the credo, “We maximize long-term profitability for landlords while maintaining quality housing for our tenants. Guaranteed.” The company deals with all aspects of property management, and these include maintenance, inspection, and leasing. Zidans has a 24-hour service center that handles major emergencies and minor annoyances that affect the real estate assets it handles.

Indianapolis, IN(877) 794-3267



Zuluscape is a property management company in Indianapolis that deals with single-family residences in safe neighborhoods. The firm takes away the hassles of management from owners, and it helps them maximize their real estate investment. Zuluscape combines its team's professional experience with state-of-the-art software to enable a more efficient oversight on the properties. Tenants can submit their intention to rent via the online form, and the application fee is $40.

Indianapolis, IN(317) 663-8485


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: