hero image

Best Jewelers in

Why These Jewelers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored jewelers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best jewelers in Indianapolis, IN.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 191 121 17

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of Aronstam Fine Jewelers  jewelers/1.jpg

Aronstam Fine Jewelers

Aronstam Fine Jewellers has 45 years of experience creating unique, custom jewelry. It allows people to express themselves through their jewelry, solidify their memories, or celebrate their love stories. Aaronstam has a small gallery where it displays beautiful jewelry in antique, baroque, modern, ethnic, and other styles. The store also buys gold, sterling silver, and platinum.

cover image of Distinctive Diamonds  jewelers/2.jpg

Distinctive Diamonds

Distinctive Diamonds is a premier provider of engagement rings, wedding bands, and fashion jewelry, with locations in Indianapolis and St. Louis. It is one of the leading bridal jewelers in Indianapolis, where it boasts a 5,500 square foot showroom. Distinctive Diamonds has a reputation for quality and beauty, as well as for excellent customer service.

Indianapolis, IN 46240


cover image of J.C. Spire Jewelers  jewelers/3.jpg

J.C. Spire Jewelers

J.C. Spire Jewelers is a full-service store that specializes in fine diamonds, estate jewelry, and beautiful engagement rings. It also offers custom designed, hand drawn and hand carved jewelry -- all done on-site. All manner of repairs and engraving are performed here. The store is family owned and has served Indianapolis for three generations. In fact, the staff at J.C. Spire has more than a century of combined experience -- including training from the Gemological Institute Of America, and certification from the American Gem Society.

Indianapolis, IN 46240


cover image of JEM Jewellers  jewelers/4.jpg

JEM Jewellers

JEM Jewellers is a Carmel, Indiana boutique that has a reputation for offering beautiful and timeless jewelry. It specializes in bridal and engagement items, watches, bracelets, gifts, and custom-designed jewelry. It also offers engraving, appraisals, cleaning, and watch repair. The staff at JEM Jewellers have worked together for more than 30 years, and their customers speak highly of the knowledge and skill that they bring to the job.

cover image of JL Hupp Jewelers  jewelers/1.jpg

JL Hupp Jewelers

JL Hupp Jewelers is a reputable jewelry store in Fishers, Indiana that offers rings, earrings, watches, and custom jewelry designs. It boasts an impressive collection of estate and antique jewelry, and it offers to repair watches, clocks, and other items. JL Hupp also does appraisals, and it buys gold and other precious metals.

Fishers, IN 46037


cover image of Khamis Fine Jewelers  jewelers/2.jpg

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Khamis Fine Jewelers is a member of the Indiana Jewelers Association and an accredited member of the International Society of Appraisers. It exchanges gold, sterling silver, platinum, coins, estate jewelry and previously owned watches. The store also offers pearl and bead restringing, custom design and restoration, jewelry and watch repair, engraving, appraisals, and a host of other services. The jewelers at Khamis Fine Jewelers have more than 30 years of experience. They are located on Fall Creek Road in Indianapolis.

Indianapolis, IN 46256


cover image of Kirles Jewellers  jewelers/3.jpg

Kirles Jewellers

Kirles Jewellers is a family-owned and operated shop that has served Indianapolis for more than 60 years. It specializes in engagement rings, designer gifts, watches, custom designs, repairs, appraisals, and more. Its two full-time jewelers have been with the store for more than 25 years, and Kirles has a reputation for providing friendly and down-to-earth customer service.

Indianapolis, IN 46260


cover image of Lewis Jewellers  jewelers/4.jpg

Lewis Jewellers

Lewis Jewellers has served Indianapolis since 1982. The family business specializes in jewelry repair, gold casting, custom design, watch repair, appraisals, and special orders. The jewelers at the store have been certified by the Gemological Institute of America, and they have a combined experience of more than 50 years.

Indianapolis, IN 46229


cover image of M. Grosser Jewelry Design  jewelers/1.jpg

M. Grosser Jewelry Design

M. Grosser Jewelry Design provides custom designs, redesigns, and restorations, as well as appraisals for jewelry, diamonds, colored gemstones, gold, silver, platinum, watches, and coins. Mark Grosser is an award-winning designer; he has more than 30 years of professional experience, and he is Indiana's first Certified Master Jeweler.

cover image of McGee & Company  jewelers/2.jpg

McGee & Company

McGee & Company is a family-owned jeweler that deals in diamond engagement rings, wedding bands, and anniversary rings for men and women. It has served Indianapolis for more than a quarter of a century, and it boasts an award-winning custom designer who helps clients to create personalized pieces. The store also stocks a selection of watches from prestigious names. McGee & Company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau, and it is a member Jewelers of America and the Indiana Jewelers Association.

Greenwood, IN 46142


cover image of Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange  jewelers/3.jpg

Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange

Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange is a locally-owned company with more than 25 years of industry experience. It offers customers excellent rates of exchange for unwanted jewelry, gold, platinum, coins, and silver items, and it has built an impressive collection of necklaces, earrings, rings, pendants, loose diamonds, watches, and other jewelry. Midwest has a reputation for honest and helpful customer service, and customers are impressed by the knowledge and expertise of the staff. Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange has two offices; one in Indianapolis, and one in Greenwood.

Indianapolis, IN 46240


cover image of Nancy Lee Designs  jewelers/4.jpg

Nancy Lee Designs

Nancy Lee Designs, in Indianapolis, specializes in custom jewelry design and artistic copper works. Nancy is a past president of the Indianapolis Downtown Artists and Dealers Association, and she has a passion for creating handmade jewelry, sculptures, and patina paintings. Nancy Lee Designs is a member of the Society of North American Goldsmiths.

Indianapolis, IN 46202


cover image of Nelson Jewelers  jewelers/1.jpg

Nelson Jewelers

Nelson Jewelers has provided Indianapolis and Henricks County with high-quality jewelry for more almost 60 years. It specializes in engagement and wedding rings; custom design jewelry; diamond rings, earrings, and pendants; and jewelry repairs. Nelson Jewellers is a family-owned store, and second generation jeweler Jeff Nelson is a Certified Gemologist and a Certified Gemologist Appraiser.

Brownsburg, IN 46112


cover image of Pierce Jewelers  jewelers/2.jpg

Pierce Jewelers

Pierce Jewelers is a full-service store located on East Carmek Drive, Indianapolis. It offers an impressive selection of colored gemstones, as well as original handcrafted jewelry. Pierce also restores, repairs, and remounts bridal and family jewelry. The store is a member of the American Gem Society, which has offered protection for consumers for more than 80 years.

Carmel, IN 46032


cover image of Reis-Nichols  jewelers/3.jpg


Reis-Nichols, in Indianapolis, has thousands of mountings and hundreds of diamonds -- the largest selection in the city. Customers speak very highly of the thoughtful and attentive service that they receive at Reis-Nichols, as well as of the beauty of the jewelry. The store holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, with whom it is accredited.

Indianapolis, IN 46240


cover image of Robert Goodman Jewelers  jewelers/4.jpg

Robert Goodman Jewelers

Robert Goodman Jewelers, in Zionsville, Indiana, is a third-generation family jeweler that has a reputation for stocking stunning jewelry. Customers are impressed not only by the unique and eye-catching products but also by the dedicated staff. Robert Goodman offers custom designs, restoration, watch and jewelry repair, appraisals, loose diamonds, engraving, and cleaning and inspection.

Zionsville, IN 46077


cover image of Smith's Jewelers  jewelers/1.jpg

Smith's Jewelers

Smith's Jewelers specializes in custom designed jewelry, bridal and engagement rings, diamonds, and watches. It also offers jewelry and watch repair, engravable gifts, jewelry care, and appraisals. Various financing and layaway options are available to customers, and the store offers full refund and exchange policies. Smith's Jewelers is located in Noblesville, Indiana.

Noblesville, IN 46060


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: