Laurels
Best Wedding
Cake Bakers in
Milwaukee
2018

Why These Wedding Cake Bakers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored wedding cake bakers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best wedding cake bakers in Milwaukee, WI.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks16410518

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop is a family-owned bakery located in West Allis, Wisconsin. They were established in 1977 and continue to use family recipes that have been passed down through generations. They offer wedding cakes, birthday cakes, cupcakes, cookies, donuts, and other baked goods. They can customize the flavor of the cake, filling, and frosting, and can add personalized messages or accent colors. Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop was the 2014-2016 Wedding Wire Couples’ Choice Award winner.

West Allis, WI(414) 482-1288

Website

Baked Custom Desserts

Baked Custom Desserts specializes in a variety of beautiful cakes, cupcakes, pies, brownies, and other delicious desserts in the Milwaukee area. They promise to provide the perfect dessert for all special occasions. The bakery’s owner, Rachel Schmidbauer, opened the doors to her new kitchen inside Peter Sciortino’s in 2013. Customers can order the finest desserts online, or stop into their storefront, which is still located in Peter Sciortino’s.

Milwaukee, WI(414) 467-8848

Website

Bridal Cakes by Ann

Ann, a 3-time successful small business owner, opened Bridal Cakes by Ann in 1999 in Kenosha, Wisconsin. At Bridal Cakes by Ann customers will find simplicity, vibrant designs, modern elegance, and natural inspiration. She is known for her European-style cakes and pastries, her artistic vision, contemporary designs, and personable service. Ann and her cakes have been featured in the Chicago Tribune, the Journal Times, Fox News Milwaukee, and Milwaukee Sentinel. They have retail spaces both in Kenosha and Zion Illinois.

Kenosha, WI(262) 654-3054

Website

Brookfield Wedding Cakes

Brookfield Wedding Cakes has been serving southeast Wisconsin for over 35 years. They are family-owned and operated and are dedicated to serving the finest and freshest wedding cakes. Their cakes are always made to order and never frozen. They offer a wide variety of cake and filling flavors. They have been voted Best Cake Bakers in the Upper Midwest by The Knot, and have been featured in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.

Brookfield, WI(262) 781-2253

Website

Cake & Bake

Cake & Bake is a bakery located in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin. This bakery not only specializes in wedding cakes and deserts, but also provides various supplies for chocolate making, cake decorating, and cookie decorating. Cake & Bake uses fresh ingredients, homemade techniques and precision to make the perfect dessert for any special occasion. Their website offers many baking tips, instructions, recipes, and they provide baking equipment rentals. Classes and workshops are offered as well.

Menomonee Falls, WI(262) 502-1219

Website

Cakes by Erin Salerno

Cakes by Erin Salerno is a home-grown bakery located in Brookfield, Wisconsin. They specialize in extraordinary fondant and gum paste hand-molded figures. Her creations show a keen attention to detail and quality. Cakes by Erin Salerno is a state- and county-licensed kitchen, and she makes herself available by appointment. Erin Salerno started making a name for herself with her inventive designs at Iron Cupcake Milwaukee competitions. She has since worked in many other bakeries, such as Elizabeth’s Cakes, while she honed her skill and perfected her craft.

Brookfield, WI(414) 520-2219

Website

Delicately Delicious

Delicately Delicious is a home-town bakery located in Cedarburg, Wisconsin. They specialize in cakes, cupcakes, and other assorted desserts for any occasion. They make custom wedding cakes and cupcakes and can take orders online or by phone. They have a wide variety of cake and cupcake flavors, as well as various frostings and fillings. They offer an extensive list of dessert-themed cakes, such as hot chocolate, red velvet, and strawberry shortcake.

Cedarburg, WI(262) 377-7268

Website

Eat Cake!

Eat Cake! is located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Owner Debbie Pagel uses her expertise as a pastry chef and her experience in fine art to create beautifully-designed cakes for all occasions. Each cake is made-to-order with farm fresh ingredients. The bakery was established in 2003 and has already offered its services for thousands of events. They have a large portfolio of specialty cakes and continue to take custom orders to meet each customer’s unique request.

Milwaukee, WI(414) 344-3119

Website

Let Them Eat Cakes

Let Them Eat Cakes was opened in Hartland, Wisconsin by Ann Mandick. Ann learned her passion while working with her mother in the kitchen. For over 25 years Ann has been perfecting her baking and decorating skills while working with the likes of Rich’s and Wilton Foods. In her community, her business and reputation continue to grow as she is becoming the favorite purveyor of delicious cakes and cookies that are never ordinary.

North Lake, WI(262) 912-6395

Website

Miss Molly's Pastries

Miss Molly’s Pastries is an elegant pastry boutique located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The business was established in 2012. They specialize in custom wedding dessert cakes and displays. They use all natural ingredients and have vegan, nut-free, and gluten-free options as well. They have an extensive menu of cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other assorted desserts. The staff at Miss Molly’s Pastries are dedicated to quality, are prompt in their responses to inquiries, and offer setup services at events in which they have been booked.

Milwaukee, WI(414) 530-1065

Website

National Bakery & Deli

National Bakery & Deli was founded in 1925 and is located in Waukesha, Wisconsin. As of 2009, there have been three locations and it has been voted the #1 bakery in Milwaukee. Their wedding cakes are available in square and round tiers, and they also offer wedding cupcakes and cookies. The bakery has seasonal specials as well as a vast selection of items that are available all year. They offer their services for birthdays, weddings, graduations, and other special occasions, and their retail locations provide a dine-in or carry-out option.

Milwaukee, WI(414) 672-1620

Website

Rick's Bakery

At Rick’s Bakery in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, customers can get a quality cake for any occasion. They have over 25 years of experience in the wedding industry, as well as over 36 years of baking experience. Rick’s Bakery also prides themselves on their impeccable customer service. Some services provided at Rick’s Bakery include floral decorations, such as bouquets, corsages, boutonnieres, table centerpieces, and wedding cake flowers. Floral pieces can be hand made from either fresh flowers, silk flowers or a combination of both.

Milwaukee, WI(414) 578-0827

Website

Simma's Ovens Bakery, Inc.

What began as a small cheesecake and pastry shop over three decades ago has now become an award-winning bakery. Simma’s Bakery is located in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin and is nationally known for superior quality and products. They specialize in elegant cheesecakes and wedding cakes and offer a wide variety of cake and frosting flavors. Simma’s Bakery was voted Best of Weddings in Wisconsin by The Knot in 2014 and has been featured in Milwaukee Magazine.

Wauwatosa, WI(414) 257-0998

Website

Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe

Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe is family-owned and operated. They are located in Waukesha, Wisconsin and specialize in hand-crafted wedding cakes, cupcakes, doughnuts, and pastries. They are known for their patent-pending “Cheez Torte, ” and they can take custom cake orders. The owners of Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe have over 30 years of culinary and pastry experience and are following the trend to 3D and extreme specialty cakes. They service southeastern Wisconsin and northern Illinois and also have an online store. They were the 2016 Wedding Wire Couples’ Choice Award winner, the 2016 pick for Best of Weddings by The Knot, and have an A+ rating with the BBB.

Waukesha, WI(262) 446-2253

Website

Sweet Tooth

Sweet Tooth is located in Elm Grove, Wisconsin. It is owned and operated by sisters Pam and Brianna. They are happy to be following in the footsteps of their grandmother and great-grandmother, who opened their bakery almost 60 years ago. Pam and Brianna acquired their recipes, passion, and love for baking from them, and recipes have been passed down through generations. They believe in fresh, homemade treats including cakes, cookies, chocolates, and more.

Elm Grove, WI(262) 789-0500

Website

Terraza's Cakes & Pastries

Terraza’s Cakes & Pastries is a family-owned bakery in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. They are committed to making the experience they give their customers just as memorable as the occasions they are celebrating. The staff takes pride in a long tradition of satisfaction and excellence in their customer service and their themed cakes. Themed cakes can range from sports cakes and fashion cakes to music-inspired cakes and adult-themed cakes.

Milwaukee, WI(414) 988-2097

Website

The Cake Lady

The Cake Lady is a gourmet cake bakery located in St. Francis, Wisconsin. In 2012, The Cake Lady won The Knot Award for Best of Weddings. Karen Smith, owner and cake decorator, has trained under the James Beard Award-winning chef Sanford D’Amato at the International Wilton School of Cake Design. The Cake Lady brings the finest ingredients to the plate such as Swiss buttercreams, fresh fruits, and a wide assortment of chocolates.

Saint Francis, WI(414) 294-4220

Website

The Rochester Deli, Inc.

The Rochester Deli is located in Historic Downtown Waukesha, Wisconsin. They are known as Home of the Best Reuben, and use only the finest quality ingredients. They specialize in corned beef and pastrami dishes. They are a full-service caterer and also provide wedding cakes, tortes, and pies. Their staff of dedicated bakers specialize in Genoise, which is a light but rich sponge cake. The Rochester Deli offers delivery and online ordering services.

Waukesha, WI(262) 522-9613

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: