hero image

Best Property
Managers in

Why These Property Managers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Madison Property Managers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 65 43 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Anchor Property Management

Headed by founder and president Ronald V. Beaton, Anchor Property Management is a firm in Madison, Wisconsin, that has been serving clients and tenants in the surrounding metropolitan area for over 34 years. The property management firm oversees residential, commercial, and condominium properties and provides a range of managerial services to its clients. Theses comprehensive services include accounting and administration plans as well as a 24/7 maintenance response system. The company also provides bids for projects that need subcontractors, working to provide its clients with the best possible prices for necessary services. Anchor Property Management is praised by previous clients for its efficient and honest business practices as well as the ability of the firm to increase the value of its properties through sound management practices.

Broihahn Management and Consulting

The full-service property management firm Broihahn Management and Consulting, located in Madison, Wisconsin, offers fourteen rental properties throughout Dane and Rock Counties. The firm, led by owner Sue Broihahn, serves nearly 1,000 apartment homes and condominiums in the local metropolitan area and has established a solid reputation for the quality of its management and consulting services. In addition to these services, the firm offers its clients emergency on-call services, maintenance and repairs, secret shoppers, cleaning, painting, and shampooing. At Broihahn Management and Consulting, the staff has over a century of combined property management experience. The firm is an Equal Housing Opportunity provider and manages locations that have affordable housing options designed specifically for seniors 62 years and older.

Madison, WI 53713


Caribou Property Management

Started by property owners in the greater Madison, Wisconsin with the intent of creating the perfect property management firm, Caribou Property Management is a Residential Property Management Company headquartered in Middleton, Wisconsin. The firm provides its clients with an access point for all rental property ledgers and income/expense statements in addition to leasing and maintenance services. The firm specializes in single-family homes, duplexes, condominiums, apartment complexes, and both Home and Condominium Owners Associations. Caribou's wide range of client services includes the handling of advertisements for rental properties, flexible maintenance and repair services, an accounting staff for year-end tax forms, and the provision of a tenant portal for ease of use. In addition, the firm does not charge the normal 7% of monthly rent fee until tenants are found for properties.

Middleton, WI 53562


CCL Management

Located in Middleton, Wisconsin, and serving the wider Dane County and Madison metropolitan areas, CCL Management is a leasing and property management firm that has been serving clients for over 28 years. The firm received new owners in 2008 and has been going through a period of steady growth ever since. CCL Management has both rental and for-sale properties and has a number of pet-friendly locations. In addition, all properties are required to be professionally cleaned before tenant move-in. The firm provides clients with a range of services, including the management of monthly disbursements and end-of-year tax paperwork. At CCL, the Maintenance Director is a licensed general contractor and the firm's General Manager has over two decades of experience in risk assessment gleaned from the lending and mortgage industry.

Middleton, WI 53562


Grindstone Management

Grindstone Management is a locally owned and operated property management company founded in 2010 in Madison, Wisconsin. It specializes in apartment properties in Madison's downtown neighborhoods. The company also offers parking areas and handles snow and ice removal.

25 W Main St
Madison, WI 53703


Kane Property Management

Kane Property Management in Madison, Wisconsin, is a property management firm that specializes in residential homes, condominium associations, and commercial venues in the greater Madison metropolitan area. The company serves clients in a host of communities within a 25-mile radius of Madison, Wisconsin, including Black Earth, Sun Prairie, Albany, Dane, and more. Kane Property Management provides its clients with a range of services that includes maintenance programs, groundskeeping, inspections, monthly reconciliation of operating and reserve bank accounts, maintaining of condominium rules and bylaws, and others. The firm also coordinates repairs for a host of problems like HVAC, landscaping, drywall, paint, snow removal, and other services. Previous clients praise the firm for its work ethic, dedication to client satisfaction, and overall quality of its groundskeeping, maintenance, and general management services.

Palisade Property

Voted one of the top property managements firms in Madison, Wisconsin, Palisade Property is a local, family-owned firm with properties that include downtown apartments, east-side neighborhood apartments, and west-Madison office spaces. Additionally, Palisade Property offers rental property locations in Platteville, Wisconsin as well as surrounding towns in Dane County. The central headquarters of Palisade Property is located conveniently near both the Wisconsin State Capitol and the Madison Children's Museum, and representatives are available around the clock for the maintenance and comfort needs of their clients and tenants. In addition to waterfront properties, the firm also lists several locations near the UW-Madison campus for prospective clients needing housing during the school year.

Prime Urban Properties

Specializing in upscale apartments and commercial venues in urban Madison, Wisconsin, Prime Urban Properties is a property management firm that seeks to provide tenants in the greater Madison metropolitan area with high-end locations. The firm owns all of its properties outright, including retail locations in Valencia Place, University Row, Kennedy Place, Livingston Place, Forward Plaza, and more. In addition, the firm has several apartment locations in Madison and Middleton, Wisconsin, including Bel Mora, Asana, Kennedy Place, City Gables, University Row, and others. Prime Urban Properties allows tenants to pay rent online, offers a $200 rent deduction for friend referrals, and around-the-clock emergency maintenance services in addition to its usual maintenance programs. Previous clients raise the company for its professional and consistent management style as well as its quick responses to clients' needs.

REI Property Management

Located in Madison, Wisconsin, and serving the greater Madison metropolitan area, REI Property Management is a property management firm with available rental locations across Southeaster Wisconsin. The firm's goal is to increase the profitability of its clients' properties by providing customized management plans to suit each client's needs. This means that REI employs staff to manage properties for hands-off clients as well as working with clients who desire to be more involved with the day-to-day dealings. REI was founded by a property owner after four consecutive bad experiences with other property management firms in a bid to create a better solution for property owners like himself. Thus, REI is run by people with experience owning and operating properties and the firm is able to understand clients' issues from the inside-out.

Madison, WI 53716


Roseland Real Estate and Property Management

With over twenty years in the business and marketing sectors and an around-the-clock on-site staff for clients' needs, Roseland Real Estate and Property Management in Madison, Wisconsin is a firm that manages and operates some of the most desirable locations in the greater metropolitan area. The firm manages a range of properties, including condominiums, townhouses, and both single family and multi-family homes. In addition, Roseland also oversees commercial properties and land lots. The firm implements customized solutions to the needs of tenants and owners, with specialized training, unique systems, and a variety of management techniques. Clients of Roseland Real Estate and Property Management praise the firm for its ability to rescue properties from poor management situations and improve the financial outlook of its properties through disciplined, efficient management practices.

Madison, WI 53713


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: