Best Jewelers
in Madison

Why These Jewelers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Madison Jewelers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 67 47 17

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

B's Jewelers

B’s Jewelers is a family-owned, full-service store in Sun Prairie that has been in business since 2005. The store sells pre-used Rolex watches, bridal jewelry, diamonds, and custom jewelry created with computer-aided design. B’s Jewelers also provides jewelry insurance, watch and jewelry repair, and engravings for every kind of material and occasion.

Sun Prairie, WI 53590


Bergey Jewelry

Bergey Jewelry is a small-town, family-owned, full-service jewelry store. The store’s inventory carries all kinds of jewelry and watches for men and women, from wedding rings to necklaces to cufflinks. The store also repairs all sorts of jewelry and watches, and its staff is certified by the Gemological Institute of America. The store has two locations in Mt. Horeb and Oregon and has an online catalog on its website.

Mount Horeb, WI 53572


Chalmers Jewelers

Chalmers Jewelers is a full-service Middleton store that has served the community for nearly two decades. The store has an extensive inventory of wedding jewelry, fashion jewelry, watches, and other accessories, and allows clients to create custom pieces with computer-aided design. Chalmers Jewelers aims to stand behind every piece it sells. The store offers a full-service warranty and appraisal for the lifetime of the piece and guarantees all repairs for one year.

Middleton, WI 53562


Condon Jewelers

Condon Jewelers has served the Madison area since 1959, and the store carries a full inventory of bridal jewelry, fashion jewelry, watches, Swarovski ornaments, and Packers-themed memorabilia. The store offers limited warranties for its watches and lifetime warranties for its diamonds and its Leslie line of gold and silver jewelry. Condon Jewelers also offers free appraisals on high-value items and allows one free resizing for every customer who buys a ring.

Countryside Jewelry

Countryside Jewelry in Lake Mills is a member of the Independent Jewelers Association. The store’s inventory carries bridal jewelry, engagement rings, and diamond and gemstone jewelry. Countryside Jewelry's on-site goldsmithing shop handles simple repairs and creates custom jewelry. The store also engraves plaques, trophies, and awards for both schools and businesses.

Lake Mills, WI 53115


Custom Creations

Custom Creations is a jewelry store that specializes in rings. Not only does the store offer distinctive and sculptured designs for men and women, but it also sells military-themed rings, with a whole line commemorating the Marine Corps. The store sells its pieces online and at its shop in Monona.

Monona, WI 53716


Diny's Jewelers

Diny’s Jewelers is a family-owned jewelry store in Middleton that specializes in jewelry repairs, restyling, and custom designs. The store’s owners are both certified by the Gemological Institute of America and have run the business since 1983. The store has over a dozen collections of bridal and fashion jewelry and offers free estimates on custom-designing services.

Middleton, WI 53562


Gruno’s Diamonds

Gruno’s Diamonds is a full-service, family-owned store in Madison that offers a complete inventory of wedding jewelry, diamonds, engagement rings, fashion jewelry, and top-quality watches. The store, which has been in business since 1953, is an official Rolex jeweler and carries many other nationally recognized brands, like Alex & Ani and Crown. Gruno’s Diamonds takes pride in selling only the best pieces, and also offers jewelry and watch repair services.

Jill Schienle

Jill Schienle is a metalworker and jeweler in Madison who creates and sells original designs. She creates unique earrings and necklaces in shades of black, white, and gray, and aims to make the largest statement using the smallest number of parts. She sells her jewelry online and at many different art shows, craft fairs, and festivals throughout the country.

Madison, WI 53705


Lee Dorn Jewelers

Lee Dorn Jewelers is a Madison jewelry store with over 30 years of experience. The store takes pride in offering unique and custom-designed jewelry, and they also sell Orbis brand jewelry and a distinctive collection of wedding bands. Services offered are jewelry repairs, restorations, appraisals, and cleaning. The store also assists customers in creating custom designs. Many satisfied customers have complimented the owner of Lee Dorn Jewelers for his creativity, customer service, and vision.

Middleton Jewelers

Middleton Jewelers is a store in the Madison area that customers have praised for its personalized service and high-quality work. The company's expert goldsmiths and gem setters offer full-service jewelry repairs, and several professional appraisers in the store also buy gold. Middleton Jewelers has an extensive catalog of both unique jewelry and pieces from favorite brands, and the company also helps customers design their pieces.

Middleton, WI 53562


Paula Sparks Studio

Paula Sparks Studio is a jewelry shop that sells original pieces created with cloisonne enamel. The proprietor has been creating jewelry for nearly 25 years, and she aims to create bold, colorful pieces. In addition to selling enamel jewelry, she also sells hand-stamped silver charms, pendants and earrings made with semi-precious stones, and statement rings. Customers can purchase her pieces at her Madison shop or online at Etsy.

Madison, WI 53705


The Artery

The Artery is a Madison art store that sells all kinds of pieces from local artists. The store offers a convenient online catalog, allowing artists to reach a wider audience. The Artery has many types of artwork for sale, including jewelry, paintings, drawings, and ceramics. The store also provides a place for local artists to advertise their services and promote events.

The Diamond Boutique

The Diamond Boutique is a jewelry store in McFarland that specializes in custom jewelry designs. The store also offers all kinds of on-site jewelry repairs and allows clients to place rush orders to get their jewelry fixed. The Diamond Boutique has served the area for around three decades, and it also carries many unique rings and pendants.

McFarland, WI 53558


The Voyagers

The Voyagers Jewelry Design is a group of jewelry designers and makers that have been in business since 1973. The store is housed in a historic house in Cambridge and is staffed by several goldsmiths, artists, and designers. The store’s aim is to make creating a custom jewelry piece as personal and easy as possible, with no appointments needed and with free designs, estimates, and consultations. The Voyagers also repair jewelry, restring beads and pearls, and appraise jewelry for insurance and estate sales.

Cambridge, WI 53523


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: