hero image
Laurels

Best Car Insurance Agencies in Madison
2020

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored car insurance agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best car insurance agencies in Madison, WI.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 139 86 8

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of Cuna Mutual Group  car-insurance/1.jpg

Cuna Mutual Group

Located in Madison, Wisconsin, the Cuna Mutual Group was founded in 1935 to provide insurance and protection for credit unions, a purpose it continues to uphold. Under the name TruStage, the company has designed a full range of policies and a program to help credit unions market insurance to its members. Auto insurance coverage comes from national carriers like Liberty Mutual Insurance and Esurance, and is designed to integrate with the credit union's core business. Other policies, based on the same quick and simple program, include home, life, and health insurance. The company also provides accidental death & dismemberment insurance.

5910 Mineral Point Rd
Madison, WI 53705

Website

cover image of Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency  car-insurance/2.jpg

Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency

Greene-Neisen Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agent and broker in Middleton that provides auto insurance. Serving the Madison, Wisconsin, metropolitan area since 1950, Greene-Niesen offers automobile insurance policies with competitive rates and coverage that take into account driving history, age, gender, the value of the vehicle, where the client lives, and other factors. It also covers users of snowmobiles, boats, motorcycles, all-terrain vehicles, and mobile homes. The company provides both personal and commercial insurance products that protect renters, condos, and homes. Green-Niesen Insurance Agency is licensed to sell insurance in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa.

6810 University Ave
Middleton, WI 53562

Website

cover image of Harms Insurance Group  car-insurance/3.jpg

Harms Insurance Group

Harms Insurance Group in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, is an independent insurance agency that sells auto insurance throughout the Madison metropolitan area. Founded in 1984, Harms Insurance offers both personal and business auto insurance and provides insurance for boats, motorcycles, and snowmobiles. The company also offers insurance that covers real estate, including for homes, rental properties, and condos. It also offers dental plans, health insurance, life insurance, Medicare supplement plans, and other insurance products. Harms Insurance Group works with Cincinnati Insurance, Progressive, Hastings Mutual, United Fire Group, QBE, and other insurance providers.

804 Liberty Blvd Ste 203
Sun Prairie, WI 53590

Website

cover image of Homewood Insurance  car-insurance/4.jpg

Homewood Insurance

Homewood Insurance is an insurance brokerage firm in Madison, Wisconsin, with another office in Sun Prairie. Founded in 1989, the firm has valuable experience from providing auto insurance solutions to thousands of residents and businesses in the southern part of the state. The company represents a group of the top state and national insurance providers with the most competitive rates. The agents carefully assess a client's insurance needs, research the best policies among their list of insurance carriers, and recommend the coverage that best suits the needs. Besides auto insurance, the agency also helps with home, motorcycle, and business coverage.

583 Donofrio Dr Ste 1012
Madison, WI 53719

Website

cover image of M3 Insurance Solutions, Inc.  car-insurance/1.jpg

M3 Insurance Solutions, Inc.

M3 Insurance Solutions Inc. is an auto insurance specialist based in the Madison, Wisconsin, metro area with over 51 years of experience working with drivers and insurance carriers. The agency offers white-glove service at offices throughout the state and helps clients get the best possible auto coverage to protect their assets and lifestyle. M3 Insurance Solutions Inc also provides insurance for collector cars, motorcycles, snowmobiles, boats, yachts, utility trailers, and other personal recreational vehicles. Clients can report claims, check on policies, and generate certificates of insurance through the company website.

828 John Nolen Dr
Madison, WI 53713

Website

cover image of Neckerman Insurance Services  car-insurance/2.jpg

Neckerman Insurance Services

Founded in 1914, Neckerman Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency located in Madison, Wisconsin. Personal account managers work with several reputable carriers to help drivers find the right amount of coverage at an affordable rate. Most states require drivers to have a minimum amount of liability insurance. Policy options include property, liability, medical, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. Other policies are available for recreational vehicles such as motorcycles, snowmobiles, scooters, boats, and ATVs. The company also offers homeowners, renters, flood, life, and several types of business insurance that cover commercial auto, property, and general liability.

6200 Mineral Point Rd
Madison, WI 53705

Website

cover image of Quamme Insurance Services, Inc.  car-insurance/3.jpg

Quamme Insurance Services, Inc.

Quamme Insurance Services Inc. is a family-owned and operated agency providing auto insurance services to clients within the Madison, Wisconsin, metro area. It has been in operation for over three decades and focuses on delivering customized insurance packages to customers. This agency provides the standard coverage categories mandated by law as well as specialized coverage for niche circumstances. Clients are granted assistance services including 24-hour assistance, towing, rental compensation, and access to discount and forgiveness programs. It also sells home insurance policies and frequently sells auto/home combination packages which usually offer clients discounted rates or special terms.

1130 Park Ave
Columbus, WI 53925

Website

cover image of Tricor Insurance  car-insurance/4.jpg

Tricor Insurance

Tricor Insurance in Madison, Wisconsin, is an independent insurance agency that sells personal and commercial auto insurance. Founded in 1945, Tricor provides auto insurance that covers liability for bodily injury, medical payments, and property damage. It also offers coverage for damage occurring from something other than a collision and from uninsured or under-insured motorists. The company additionally provides commercial insurance, including for craft brewers, the agricultural industry, government entities, schools, factories, the aviation industry, and other businesses. Tricor Insurance offers insurance and risk management services in Illinois, Wisconsin, and Minnesota through a network of over 200 agents.

2001 W Beltline Hwy Ste 201
Madison, WI 53713

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: