Get Listed
Close
Get Listed
 
Laurels

Best Renter's Insurance Companies in Appleton
2022

We scored 36 Renter's Insurance Companies in Appleton, WI and Picked the Top 10

Here are the Picks:

Calder Insurance Agency LLC

GIS of Appleton - Daryl Brown

Head Insurance Agency, LLC

Ken Heiner

Matt Holtebeck

Maurer Insurance Agency

Monday & Associates Insurance

Ryan Renard

Thiel Insurance Group LLC

Total Insurance

Why These Renter's Insurance Companies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Appleton Renter's Insurance Companies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 36 25 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Read more about our selection process

Calder Insurance Agency LLC

  • Multiple Carriers

Established in 1980, Calder Insurance Agency LLC is a family-owned and family-operated business serving customers in the Appleton area. It aims to help clients protect themselves and their most valuable assets by providing comprehensive insurance policies. These policies include renters', home, auto, motorcycle, and life insurance. The company also serves the insurance needs of businesses in the metro, offering plans that cover theft and fire. Its agents tailor each policy to fit the customers' needs and budgets.

Click to Call

611 N. Lynndale Dr., Ste. 165
Appleton, WI 54914

Website

(920) 735-9191 Website

Reputation:A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

2 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

GIS of Appleton - Daryl Brown

  • Home And Auto Insurance

GIS of Appleton - Daryl Brown is an agency providing coverage options, including renters' insurance. This policy covers the personal belongings of tenants that have been damaged or stolen. It also takes into account situations like additional living expenses if the policyholder was forced to leave their home due to a disaster, as well as personal liability if other people were hurt in their home. The agency partners with multiple insurance carriers to provide a variety of personal and business lines products.

Click to Call

3019 W. Spencer Street
Appleton, WI 54914

Website

(920) 284-2043 Website

Reputation:A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

1 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Head Insurance Agency, LLC

  • Multiple Policy Types
  • Multiple Carriers

Head Insurance Agency, LLC, has been providing insurance coverage options to individuals, families, and renters in the Appleton metro since 1947. It offers renters' insurance that protects them and their assets against intrusion, fire, and other accidents. The policy covers the repair and replacement of lost items. Focused on establishing long-lasting relationships with clients, the agency matches them with the best carriers that offer policies that cover their needs. It also offers homeowners, life, health, business, and auto insurance.

Click to Call

W579 Castle Drive
Sherwood, WI 54169

Website

(920) 989-1473 Website

Reputation:A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

4.7 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

15 (Better)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Price: $500

Ken Heiner

  • Home And Auto Insurance
  • Multiple Policy Types

Based in Appleton, Ken Heiner is a State Farm insurance agent who serves clients throughout the metro. He provides renters' insurance policies and advises tenants on further protection options, such as personal property and liability coverage. Heiner offers other personal insurance products, including auto, life, pet, and health plans. He has experience helping small business owners avoid severe financial loss through builders' risk and workers' compensation insurance. The agent has been with State Farm for over 45 years.

Click to Call

3110 N Ballard Road
Appleton, WI 54911

Website

(920) 734-3141 Website

Reputation:A+

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

125 (Best)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Matt Holtebeck

  • Multiple Policy Types

Based in Appleton, Matt Holtebeck is a second-generation State Farm insurance agent and has been with the provider since 2008. Holtebeck offers a wide range of insurance products, including renters' insurance, which covers tenants' personal belongings from various mishaps, including theft, vandalism, weather impacts, water damage, and fire. In addition, he also offers other products, such as home, auto, life, health, pet, and business insurance policies. Holtebeck extends his services to clients who need help with mutual funds and annuities.

Click to Call

2711 N Mason Street
Appleton, WI 54914

Website

(920) 739-3003 Website

Reputation:A+

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

4.9 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

79 (Best)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Maurer Insurance Agency

  • Multiple Carriers

Established in 2008, Maurer Insurance Agency provides financial investment services to individuals and families in the Appleton metro. It creates customized renters' insurance policies and helps clients secure claims for damaged belongings and medical expenses due to perils like theft and natural disasters. The independent company also offers home, life, and auto insurance. Its agents work with over 20 carriers, including Liberty Mutual, Progressive, and Kemper. Founder Scott Maurer brings 18 years of insurance industry experience.

Click to Call

2835 W College Avenue
Appleton, WI 54914

Website

(920) 560-5800 Website

Reputation:A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

3 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Monday & Associates Insurance

  • Home And Auto Insurance
  • Business Insurance
  • Commercial

Monday & Associates Insurance is an independent agency that serves clients in Appleton. Established in 1984, it offers advice and options regarding personal, business, life, and health insurance plans. Its renters' insurance covers both tenants and the rental properties, providing financial protection from property damage, theft, and any liability issues. Its home insurance offerings include coverages for homeowners, condominiums, and motor homes and RVs. Monday & Associates Insurance also offers policies for autos, motorcycles, boats, snowmobiles, and collector cars.

Click to Call

2500 North Richmond Street
Appleton, WI 54911

Website

(920) 731-2018 Website

Reputation:A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

3 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Ryan Renard

  • Home And Auto Insurance

Ryan Renard is an insurance agent who works with State Farm and serves clients in the Appleton area. He provides a range of renter's, life, and health insurance policies to help individuals protect themselves and their families from unexpected events in the future. He also offers risk protection packages for cars and businesses. Renard provides sufficient information to his clients to make informed decisions that can benefit them in the future. He and his family have been in business for over four decades.

Click to Call

2405 S Oneida Street
Appleton, WI 54915

Website

(920) 734-8331 Website

Reputation:A+

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

4.6 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

34 (Best)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A+

Price: $500

Thiel Insurance Group LLC

  • Multiple Policy Types

Thiel Insurance Group LLC caters to clients in Appleton and the surrounding neighborhoods. It helps customers find renters' insurance that fits their budgets, lifestyles, and coverage preferences. The company also offers insurance for home and condo owners. It answers inquiries from clients, guides them through the process of securing the policy, and assists in the claims process. The company is owned and operated by husband-and-wife duo Boyd and Stacey Thiel. Boyd has been a member of the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors since 1988.

Click to Call

620 N Richmond St
Appleton, WI 54911

Website

(920) 739-6241 Website

Reputation:A+

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

3 (Best)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

310 (Best)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A+

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: A

Total Insurance

  • Multiple Policy Types

Total Insurance is an agency that caters to the needs of individuals and business owners in Appleton. Since 2009, the firm has served as an independent agency, offering multiple lines of insurance. Among its offerings are coverage plans for renters. The renters' insurance pays for and replaces the policyholders' tangible assets that have been destroyed in covered losses such as fire incidents. This also serves as policyholders' primary defense against lawsuits brought by people injured on their properties.

Click to Call

2100 S Kensington Dr.
Appleton, WI 54915

Website

(920) 731-3200 Website

Reputation:A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

3.8 / 5 (Good)

Total Reviews:

10 (Better)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Professionalism: A

More Info

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.

Responsiveness: A+

Friendliness: A+

Helpfulness: A+

Detail: --

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area

Search for Renter's Insurance Companies near you