hero image

Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Pittsburgh

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored homeowners insurance agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best homeowners insurance agencies in Pittsburgh, PA.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 186 116 11

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

cover image of Bill Flinn Agency  homeowners-insurance/1.jpg

Bill Flinn Agency

Bill Flinn Insurance Agency is located in Pittsburg, Pennsylvania. It's an independent brokerage that shops a wide range of insurance providers on behalf of its customers to find the best, most affordable coverage options for their needs. It works with carriers such as Erie Insurance and Hagerty to provide homeowners insurance policies that cover personal liability, loss of use, property damage, and personal property/contents of the home. Bill Flinn Insurance Agency also offers condo, renters, and landlord insurance.

2754 S Park Rd
Bethel Park, PA 15102


cover image of Casper Insurance Agency  homeowners-insurance/2.jpg

Casper Insurance Agency

Casper Insurance Agency offers home insurance in the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, area. Founded in 1950, it offers homeowners insurance to protect the homes and apartments of buyers and renters. The insurance policies replace personal property that is destroyed in a disaster and cover a lawsuit from someone injured in a policyholder's home. Casper Insurance provides both a named-perils and an all-risk policy to ensure that each customer has their own personal needs covered.

611 Mount Royal Blvd
Pittsburgh, PA 15223


cover image of Chambers Insurance Agency  homeowners-insurance/3.jpg

Chambers Insurance Agency

Chambers Insurance Agency, located in Washington, Pennsylvania, is an independent agency offering a full suite of home and personal insurance solutions since 1953. The agency's six licensed insurance advisors represent 14 different major insurance companies, giving customers a variety of options and prices to choose from. Chambers Insurance Agency offers homeowner policies that protect in case of burglary, fire, water damage, and storm and supplementary coverage for valuables inside the home, such as jewelry, collector cars, and wine collections.

33 N Main St
Washington, PA 15301


cover image of Element Risk Management  homeowners-insurance/4.jpg

Element Risk Management

Element Risk Management is a Pittsburgh-based independent insurance agency serving clients from offices throughout Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Virginia. Home insurance is included amongst its risk management solutions for personal and business clients, including coverage for condos, renters, second homes, and landlords. Its tailored policies gleaned from a wide range of carriers can include coverage for structural repairs, theft or damage to possessions, and liability if a visitor is injured. Optional coverage can include off-premises theft and medical expenses.

1910 Cochran Rd. Manor Oak One Suite 330
Pittsburgh, PA 15220


cover image of George A. Reed Agency, Inc.  homeowners-insurance/1.jpg

George A. Reed Agency, Inc.

In business for over 60 years, George A. Reed Agency Inc. is a family-owned and operated independent insurance agency offering home insurance services to clients in the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, metro area. The agency frequently works with companies such as Safeco and Progressive to offer clients policies protecting their home itself, their belongings, and their finances in case of lawsuits related to the premises. Auto and life insurance policies are also available.

340 Siebert Rd
Pittsburgh, PA 15237


cover image of LM Insurance Agency  homeowners-insurance/2.jpg

LM Insurance Agency

LM Insurance Agency is a locally owned and independent insurance agency that sells home insurance in the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, metro area. Founded in 2007, LM Insurance provides coverage for homes for damage or destruction of the main dwelling and personal possessions due to fire, vandalism, and other covered events, including specific options for farms and tenants. The agency also offers auto, life, and business policies through over a dozen reputable insurance carriers.

453 Davidson Rd Ste A5
Pittsburgh, PA 15239


cover image of McElhinny Insurance Agency  homeowners-insurance/3.jpg

McElhinny Insurance Agency

The McElhinny Insurance Agency is an independent, third-generation, family-run insurance company located in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Founded in 1960, coverage specialists work with American Collectors Insurance, Erie Insurance, Foremost Insurance Group, Hagerty, and Progressive, to help clients get home protection policies at competitive rates. The agency provides homeowners, condominium, and mobile and manufactured policies that cover only named risks and comprehensive, all-risk policies that cover all perils. Other types of coverage include rental property, valuable items, and personal umbrella insurance.

5624 Brownsville Rd
Pittsburgh, PA 15236


cover image of McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance  homeowners-insurance/4.jpg

McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance

McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance is an independent agency with over 30 years of experience assisting homeowners throughout the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, metro area. Agents work with a wide range of insurance carriers to find clients a policy that covers the replacement value of their home, personal assets, and medical expenses following injuries to the homeowner or guest while on the property. The company also provides coverage for condominiums, flood damage, renters, mobile homes, and landlords.

4175 Steubenville Pike
Pittsburgh, PA 15205


cover image of McMenamin Insurance Group  homeowners-insurance/1.jpg

McMenamin Insurance Group

McMenamin Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency based in the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, metro area. Home coverage specialists have access to multiple companies and a wide range of policy options to provide clients unbiased and objective advice, claims assistance, and advocacy. Coverage choices include home repairs or replacement costs, and replacing the items inside the house, medical expenses for guests injured on the property, loss of use to pay for living expenses during repairs.

100 Wilhaven Rd Ste 200
McMurray, PA 15317


cover image of Ron Dunn Agency  homeowners-insurance/2.jpg

Ron Dunn Agency

Located in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, the Ron Dunn Agency has provided independent personal and business insurance services since 1981. It can find and tailor home insurance policies from its extensive list of carriers that provide suitable coverage for its client's homes and properties at a price within their budget. The agency prides itself on educating its customers so they understand the benefits and limitations of their policies. It can also offer home insurance discounts.

124 Ingram Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15205


cover image of The Polesky Insurance Agency  homeowners-insurance/3.jpg

The Polesky Insurance Agency

Located in Moon Township, Pennsylvania, The Polesky Insurance Agency is an independent agency serving personal and business clients in the Pittsburgh area. Founded in 1954, it provides tailored home insurance policies that are designed to fit the needs and budget of its clients. The agency represents many insurance carriers, which provides it with the flexibility to find the right coverage for homeowners. It also offers renters insurance and tailored solutions for condominiums.

1150 Thorn Run Rd Ste 106
Moon Township, PA 15108


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area