Expertise.com

Best Life Insurance Companies in Erie

Laurels
Laurels

We did the research for you!

Learn more
  • checkboxLicensing
  • checkboxUser Reviews
  • checkboxMystery Shopping Calls

Life Insurance Companies FAQs

Learn more
Black Insurance Group logo

Black Insurance Group

121 East 2nd Street, Erie, PA 16507
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Whole Life Insurance
  • Term Life Insurance

Serving for almost 60 years, Black Insurance Group is an independent insurance firm dedicated to providing a straightforward insurance experience for residential and commercial clients in Erie. It offers two options for life insurance services, term life and permanent, to support the policyholder's beneficiaries' financial security. Founded by Samuel P. Black II, the firm also provides insurance for homes, renters, auto, motorcycle, and flood. Black Insurance Group received an Erie Legacy Award in September 2017.

Visit Website
Bort Insurance Services logo

Bort Insurance Services

1460 West 38th Street, Erie, PA 16508
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Bort Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency that serves clients in Erie. It offers life insurance policies from several providers that include Erie Insurance, Progressive, and Universal Property. The agency also helps clients in obtaining insurance products for homes, automobiles, general liability, and commercial property. The owner, Dennis Bort, is a U.S. Army veteran, and has been a licensed insurance agent since 1988. Under his leadership, the agency has won the Quality Agent of the Year award in 2012.

Visit Website
Burns & Burns Insurance logo

Burns & Burns Insurance

3123 West 12th Street, Erie, PA 16505
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Burns & Burns Insurance is a family-owned and operated agency that serves individuals in Erie and its surrounding areas. Its life and health insurances have options for child life, disability, vision, and dental inclusions. Other personal services that it provides include home, auto, wedding, and pet insurances. It is a member of Trusted Choice and IAABA. Its team has over 915 years of combined experience in the field. The multi-generational agency has been assisting clients for over 80 years.

Visit Website
C.H. Reams & Associates, Inc logo

C.H. Reams & Associates, Inc

401 Cranberry Street, Erie, PA 16507
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

C.H. Reams & Associates, Inc. is an Erie-based company helping clients with life insurance policies. The agency is spearheaded by company president Tom Reams, specializing in life insurance, mainly in employee benefits and individual insurance plans. Its insurance policy services include life insurance, group insurance, health insurance, dental insurance, and vision insurance. Moreover, the agency also aids its clients in COBRA, FSA, HRA administration, Medicare products, and group consolidated billing. C.H. Reams & Associates works with companies and aims to serve as their human resources teams' extension.

Visit Website
Crotty Insurance logo

Crotty Insurance

3132 Sterrettania Road, Erie, PA 16506
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Crotty Insurance is an independent insurance agency catering to clients in the Erie area. It provides a wide range of personal insurance products, including life, health, and disability as well as umbrella liability coverage. It offers coverage for personal properties, including auto, motorcycles, watercraft, and RV insurance as well as insurance for homeowners, condo owners, landlords, and renters. Crotty Insurance specializes in providing trucking insurance. Coverage for business and commercial liabilities as well as financial planning assistance are also available.

Visit Website
Domino Insurance Agency Inc. logo

Domino Insurance Agency Inc.

3209 Greengarden Boulevard, Erie, PA 16508
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Domino Insurance Agency Inc. has been providing life insurance since 1979. An Erie-based independent insurance agency, the company partners with multiple providers to help individuals shop for the right insurance product. The agents offer individual and group insurance plans to customers with term or whole life insurance needs. They also provide auto, home, and business insurance. Its founder, James T. Domino, received the President's Award for Excellence from the Peerless Insurance Company, Ohio Casualty Insurance Company, and Liberty Mutual.

Visit Website
Drushel & Kolakowski Insurance logo

Drushel & Kolakowski Insurance

1730 West 26th Street, Erie, PA 16508
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Drushel & Kolakowski Insurance is an independent insurance agency that caters to individuals and businesses in the Erie metro. Its product line includes term, universal, and whole life insurance plans, which can cover burial expenses, medical bills, mortgage, and outstanding debts. It also provides auto, commercial umbrella, Medicare Supplement, professional liability, and workers' compensation insurance policies. Grundy Insurance and Progressive are some of the insurance carriers it represents. George P. Drushel, the firm's principal agent, has been working in the insurance industry for 31 years.

Visit Website
Great Lakes Insurance Services Group, LLC logo

Great Lakes Insurance Services Group, LLC

3205 Peach Street, Erie, PA 16508
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Founded in 1969, Great Lakes Insurance Services Group, LLC, offers life insurance policies that can be used for children's education, retirement fund, and mortgage payoff. It caters to clients in and around Erie. It also offers insurance plans for individuals, namely boat and yacht insurance, jewelry and valuable items insurance, car insurance, and homeowners' insurance. For business owners, it provides property and auto insurance, umbrella insurance, inland marine insurance, and transportation insurance, as well as surety bonds and professional liability.

Visit Website
Hart, McConahy & Martz Insurance logo

Hart, McConahy & Martz Insurance

2562 West 12th Street, Erie, PA 16505
Visit Website
  • Health Insurance

Hart, McConahy & Martz Insurance is an independent agency that has been operating in Erie since 1872. It offers term, whole, and universal life insurance options for individuals and their families. A needs calculator is available on the website to help clients determine the type of insurance program they need. The agency also offers health, recreational vehicle, and farm insurance. One of its agents, R. Carl Martz, has been in the industry since 1974. He supervises the commercial property and casualty department.

Visit Website
Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance logo

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance

332 Holland Street, Erie, PA 16507
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance is an Erie-based insurance agency that has been serving families and businesses throughout Pennsylvania since 1955. This agency offers various options for life, home, auto, and business insurance plans in partnership with some of the major carriers like Erie Insurance, Progressive, and AIC. For life insurance, the available products suitable for individuals are term life, whole life, universal life, and final expense insurance policies. Business owners and executives may obtain another type of life insurance called individual disability income protection.

Visit Website
Historic Square Agency logo

Historic Square Agency

3731 West 26th Street, Erie, PA 16506
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Historic Square Agency is a full-service insurance agency that serves families, businesses, and possessions throughout Erie County. With access to a line of reputable carriers, such as Erie Insurance, Progressive, and Travelers, the agency offers full-range insurance solutions for personal and commercial needs. Among these solutions is life insurance, which includes various policies like term life, whole life, and universal life. In cases like serious accidents or chronic illnesses, solutions like long-term disability insurance and long-term care insurance are also provided by Historic Square Agency.

Visit Website
Jeremy Borrero logo

Jeremy Borrero

952 West 38th Street, Erie, PA 16508
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Jeremy Borrero is an insurance agent and CEO of the State Farm Insurance office in Erie. He has been serving the area and its surrounding communities since 2010, assisting clients in their life insurance needs. He offers term life, whole life, and universal life insurance. He also helps clients who want changes in their policies or beneficiaries. Jeremy has a degree in financial services. He owns C & K Legacy Enterprises, LLC, and is a member of Erie community outreach groups.

Visit Website
Jessica Burick Insurance Agency logo

Jessica Burick Insurance Agency

4603 Wattsburg Road, Erie, PA 16504
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Jessica Burick Insurance Agency has been serving Erie with personalized life insurance coverage since 1987. The full-service company provides term, universal, whole life, variable universal, and simplified issue insurance. Its owner, Jessica Burick, has over three decades of industry experience. Burick is licensed to serve in Ohio and New York. Her staff joins her in providing other insurance products, such as home, auto, RV, and business insurance. Together, they represent carriers, such as American Modern, Nationwide, Progressive, and Travelers.

Visit Website
Lafaro Agency logo

Lafaro Agency

4627 Peach Street, Erie, PA 16509
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Lafaro Agency is an insurance company that serves clients throughout Erie and the surrounding communities. This full-service insurance agency provides an extensive array of insurance products for individuals as well as businesses. Its team of agents offers term life and permanent life insurance, guiding clients in choosing the kind of coverage suited to their needs and financial goals. Robert J. Lafaro, the company owner, established the business in 1969. Today, the agency serves clients across multiple states, including New York, Virginia, and California.

Visit Website
Lighthouse Insurance logo

Lighthouse Insurance

3715 Zimmerman Road, Erie, PA 16510
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance
  • Group Plans

Lighthouse Insurance carries comprehensive personal and commercial solutions in and around Erie. Its insurance products include group life, home, motorcycle, and pet insurance from multiple carriers, including Nationwide and Dairyland. Agents from this company also offer annuities and coverage for cyber liability, directors, and officers. Lighthouse Insurance has been in business since 1962, under the name Carter-Reagan Insurance Agency. The company changed its name upon its incorporation in 2003. An accounting graduate, Ken Norfolk, its owner, began his insurance career in 1988.

Visit Website
Loesel-Schaaf Insurance Agency, Inc. logo

Loesel-Schaaf Insurance Agency, Inc.

3537 West 12th Street, Erie, PA 16505
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Loesel-Schaaf Insurance Agency, Inc., has been providing services to Erie and the nearby areas since 1927. It specializes in various life insurance products to help clients protect the future of their families. These products include key man, retirement planning, and international travel insurance. It also offers disability insurance that benefits the policyholders and their families if they become unable to work due to critical illnesses or injuries. Its vice president, Eric J. Consiglio, has been in the industry for over 20 years.

Visit Website
Mark Bruns Agency logo

Mark Bruns Agency

4420 Peach Street, Erie, PA 16509
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Mark Bruns Agency in Erie offers clients a varied selection of life insurance policies, ranging from individual and group life insurance to long-term care and mortgage protection insurance. Its insurance agents can also collaborate with clients to review and update their existing policies to accommodate the client's current circumstances. Principal agent and president Mark E. Bruns has been working for the agency for over two decades. He specializes in life, farm, and commercial insurance. Moreover, he holds AFIS and CLCS designations.

Visit Website
Mike Hess logo

Mike Hess

183 Main Street East, Girard, PA 16417
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Mike Hess is a State Farm insurance agent based in Girard who also provides life insurance services covering term life, whole life, and universal life policies in Erie. The coverage periods of the plans he offers range from a limited time period to a lifetime. He and his team help their clients choose which product fits their needs, offering services like the Triangle of Protection, which consists of life, disability income, and homeowners' insurance. They also handle auto, property, pet, health, and business insurance.

Visit Website
Murray Insurance logo

Murray Insurance

10 North Park Row, Erie, PA 16501
Visit Website
  • Whole Life Insurance
  • Term Life Insurance

Murray Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Erie that carries diverse insurance products. Its personal insurance solutions cover child and individual life, home, and auto insurance coverages. The insurance professionals walk clients through available life insurance options, such as term, universal, and whole life insurance plans, and help them determine which types suit their needs. Established in 1968, Murray Insurance also offers general liability, builders' risk, and inland marine insurance. In addition, it partners with Progressive and Erie Insurance.

Visit Website
Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC logo

Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC

2340 West Grandview Boulevard, Erie, PA 16506
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC, has been serving individuals, families, and businesses in Erie since 1972. It offers term and permanent life insurance policies that protect beneficiaries financially in the event of an untimely death. The agency also covers insurance products for commercial vehicles, contractors, and workers' compensation. The agency started as the James B. Orth Insurance Agency, which was established by Jim Orth in November 1972. James partnered with Marybeth Baran in July 1991. Marybeth became the sole owner of the agency in 2012.

Visit Website
R.H. Rutkowski Insurance Inc. logo

R.H. Rutkowski Insurance Inc.

2900 Copperleaf Drive, Erie, PA 16509
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

R.H. Rutkowski Insurance Inc. is an independent insurance agency that helps clients across the Erie area. Founded in 1968, the company provides life insurance products, including universal life, term life, and whole life insurance. They also help clients with final expense insurance. Besides these, the company also has an array of personal insurance products, including auto, homeowners, renters', and earthquake insurance. Moreover, R.H. Rutkowski Insurance helps commercial clients with business insurance. Owners Patricia Figurski and Harry Figurski have a combined 62 years of insurance experience.

Visit Website
Runstedler Life & Retirement LLC logo

Runstedler Life & Retirement LLC

1611 Peach Street, Erie, PA 16501
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Runstedler Life & Retirement LLC is a family-owned business based in Erie that specializes in life insurance. It provides term, universal, and whole life policies, as well as single premium and indexed universal life insurance. It also offers final expense, mortgage protection, and buy-sell agreement funding. Moreover, this independent broker assists clients with retirement planning and securing long-term care, disability, and health insurance. It has access to more than 30 companies, including Mutual of Omaha and National Life Group.

Visit Website
Sitter Insurance logo

Sitter Insurance

4267 West Ridge Road, Erie, PA 16506
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Sitter Insurance is an independent agency providing services to Erie. It caters to clients who want to secure their families' finances by offering individual life insurance products. These include term life that gives financial benefits depending on the clients' agreements. It also offers whole and universal life for clients wanting to get a lifetime or permanent benefits. Its owner, Tony Cusati, has over 12 years of experience in the insurance and finance industry and is an executive board member of the Asbury Woods Partnership.

Visit Website
Vicary Insurance Agency LLC logo

Vicary Insurance Agency LLC

1652 West 8th Street, Erie, PA 16505
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance
  • Health Insurance

Vicary Insurance Agency, LLC, offers individual and business insurance solutions to clients in Erie. The business has been serving the community since 1990, representing various insurance carriers, including United Concordia, MetLife, Aetna, and Highmark. It specializes in offering life insurance coverage, such as term and permanent life, both designed to help clients protect their most valuable assets and financial future. Its CEO, Richard Vicary, Jr., carries various designations in the field, such as a Life Underwriter Training Council Fellow.

Visit Website
Villarreal Life Insurance of Erie logo

Villarreal Life Insurance of Erie

1403 West 35th Street, Erie, PA 16508
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Villarreal Life Insurance of Erie caters to the insurance needs of individuals and families in the Erie metro. It specializes in term life insurance, procuring tailored plans and finding the right policies that cover its clients' unique needs. The company simplifies the process of obtaining insurance coverage and helps its clients mitigate risks. Its clients commend the company for accelerating the insurance process, eliminating nonessential steps involved in claims processing, and reducing monthly insurance premiums.

Visit Website
Wagner Giblin Insurance logo

Wagner Giblin Insurance

3928 Avonia Road, Fairview, PA 16415
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Wagner Giblin Insurance provides life insurance products to Erie. It helps individuals protect their loved ones from financial burden by offering whole life, term life, universal life insurance plans. It also assists clients who are seeking medical, business, auto, and property insurance products. The agency has partnered with Eastern Alliance, Liberty Mutual Insurance, Nationwide, and Penn National Insurance. Its president, Thomas J. Giblin, is a certified insurance counselor and a former president of the Whitehall Village Civic Association.

Visit Website
Werle & Rushe Insurance Agency LLC logo

Werle & Rushe Insurance Agency LLC

4055 West Lake Road, Erie, PA 16505
Visit Website
  • Life Insurance

Werle & Rushe Insurance Agency, LLC, is an independent insurance company that serves individuals, families, and businesses located in the Erie metro. It has been offering a variety of life insurance packages, including term life and whole life insurance policies, since 1997. The Werle & Rushe team represents several insurance companies, like Millville Mutual, Progressive, and Erie Insurance as its primary carrier. In addition, the company's founders, Don Werle and John Rushe, are also experienced insurance brokers.

Visit Website
Back to Providers

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Who should buy supplemental health insurance?

A: Supplemental health insurance is a product that helps cover the cost of services that your primary health insurance policy doesn't. One popular option is secondary insurance that helps cover some of the costs associated with high deductibles. Medicare supplemental insurance is also popular. Medicare doesn't cover everything, and older adults on a limited income can face large prescription or medical bills after Medicare pays. Supplemental insurance helps reduce those patient costs.

Q: Can I buy health insurance anytime?

A: To buy health insurance in the marketplace, you must purchase it within open or special enrollment periods. But you can purchase short-term coverage to bridge the gap between now and the next open enrollment period. These plans are meant to be used for less than a year. You can purchase them online or via insurance agents, but they may not be ACA-compliant.

Q: Can I buy health insurance that is not Obamacare?

A: When people say "Obamacare insurance," they typically mean insurance within the health insurance marketplace. You can get health insurance outside of the marketplace by going through your employer, choosing COBRA coverage if you leave your job, or buying a short-term health insurance policy through an insurance agent. ACA-compliant plans meet all the benefits and coverage requirements of the Affordable Care Act. But you may be able to find supplemental or short-term coverage that simply provides peace of mind for major medical expenses.

Read All FAQS

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Search for Life Insurance Companies near you