Expertise.com

2024

Last updated:

Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Broken Arrow, OK

Our Recommended Top 15

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Broken Arrow Local Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

75Reviewed

51Curated

15Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.

Providers

featured provider = Featured Provider

709 West Washington Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
WebsiteLicense: 14003

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.6 (48)
Facebook
5.0 (8)

Why choose this provider?

Harmon Insurance is an insurance agency located in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma that provides insurance products and services to residents of the metro and nearby counties. It offers various options for personal and business insurance needs and has extensive experience writing auto insurance policies for its clients. State-required auto insurance in Oklahoma is 8% higher than the national average due to unpredictable weather—which is why Harmon Insurance is committed to finding and adjusting the right policy to sufficiently address each client's unique needs.

  • Bundling Option

2604 West Kenosha Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
WebsiteLicense: 3000293428

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (21)
Facebook
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Greater Tulsa Insurance caters to the Broken Arrow metro. It offers car insurance policies with different types of coverage. The independent agency also carries personal insurance like home and renters and business insurance such as business owner package and cannabis dispensary insurance. It is a family-owned independent agency by wife and husband, Kelley and James Brown. While both have a passion for helping families, they each use their distinctive skillsets and backgrounds to help all their clients succeed.

  • Multiple Carriers
  • Bundling Option

6145 East 21st Street, Tulsa, OK 74114
WebsiteLicense: 100105022

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.5 (82)
Facebook
4.8 (12)

Why choose this provider?

All American Insurance Agency is an independent insurance firm in Tulsa that extends its services to the people of Broken Arrow. With over 35 years in business, it employs agents to represent various financially sound carriers that can provide a wide range of protection plans, including car insurance. The company’s agents are bilingual and can communicate with clients in Spanish if preferred. In addition to standard auto insurance, All American Insurance Agency also offers coverage for motorcycles, RVs, and boats.

  • Boats
  • Motorcyle & ATV

500 South Elm Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
WebsiteLicense: 100136923

Expertise.com Rating

Why choose this provider?

Chris Mathurin is an insurance agent for State Farm, operating from and serving clients in Broken Arrow. He provides auto insurance plans to help clients pay for any unplanned repairs or replacements. Chris meets with interested customers via phone or in-person to answer questions about their policies. He reviews existing coverages to find any oversights or risks. His options can cover any weather damage, collisions, medical liabilities, and roadside service. Previous clients praise Chris for being informative and patient.

1300 South Main Street, Tulsa, OK 74119
WebsiteLicense: 100165885

Expertise.com Rating

Why choose this provider?

Serving Broken Arrow and the rest of Tulsa, Gallagher delivers a wide array of insurance, risk management, and consulting services worldwide. Founded by Arthur Gallagher in 1927 as an insurance agency, it expanded to provide driven solutions for brands and businesses. Offering all aspects of insurance services, the company provides coverage for claims, cyber, property, worker's compensation, and small businesses. Recognized by Forbes Magazine in 2018 as one of the world's best employers, Gallagher was the only insurance company on the list.

  • Motorcyle & ATV

11 South Sheridan Road, Tulsa, OK 74112
WebsiteLicense: 100100453

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (983)
Facebook
5.0 (7)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Best Insurance is a team of licensed agents offering risk management solutions to its clients in Broken Arrow for over 50 years. It offers car insurance options with lower and longer payment terms. It also helps second chance clients who have had the unfortunate experience of an accident. Some of its partner insurance companies are Progressive, Harbour Insurance, Traders Insurance, CCA, and General Insurance. Clients can purchase a policy in person or over the phone.

  • RV & Motorhome
  • Boats
  • Motorcyle & ATV

319 South Main Street, Sapulpa, OK 74066
WebsiteLicense: 10009111

Expertise.com Rating

Why choose this provider?

As an independent agency, Main Street Insurance Agency, LLC provides several policy options for clients by screening multiple carriers. Serving Tulsa and the surrounding areas, the company provides personal insurance including auto, homeowners', individual life, and health insurance. In addition to cars, the agency also offers coverage for motorcycles and watercraft equipment such as boats. Rideshare companies and businesses can also avail of the agency's commercial auto insurance to cover business-owned vehicles.

  • RV & Motorhome
  • Boats

22 West 2nd Street, Sand Springs, OK 74063
WebsiteLicense: 72261

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (56)
Google
4.9 (26)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Steve Lane is a State Farm insurance agent who covers clients in and around Broken Arrow. He provides insurance plans for automobile owners to prepare for any accidents or collisions on the road. He talks with clients to help them find a fitting plan, including those that cover weather damages. Steve is a second-generation agent and is also on the board of the Sand Springs Chamber of Commerce. Aside from auto insurance, Steve also offers business and health insurance plans.

  • Multiple Carriers

2720 North Hemlock Court, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
WebsiteLicense: 100102216

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (10)
Facebook
5.0 (3)

Why choose this provider?

The Arrow Group is an independent insurance agency that provides personal and commercial auto coverage to clients in Broken Arrow. From required to optional products, it offers policies with liability protection, security against collision and non-collision damages or losses, and additional coverage for medical expenses, roadside assistance, and uninsured motorist protection. Among its providers are Progressive, Travelers, State Auto, and Liberty Mutual. In business since the 1970s, The Arrow Group takes on an "out-of-the-box" approach to challenge insurance conventions.

  • Multiple Carriers
  • RV & Motorhome
  • Boats

121 East Main Street, Jenks, OK 74037

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
4.7 (48)
Google
4.7 (27)

Why choose this provider?

Tedford Insurance - Jenks is an insurance firm established in 1978. Its founders, George and Kay Tedford, had one goal, which was to offer sound insurance coverage to the local community. Their staff of two has since grown to 56 associates. The company's professional agents help vehicle owners in Broken Arrow secure an auto insurance plan that suits their needs and preferences. The company’s auto insurance packages include options for liability, collision, injury protection, comprehensive, medical coverage, and uninsured and underinsured motorists.

  • Multiple Carriers

9717 East 42nd Street, Tulsa, OK 74146
WebsiteLicense: 100101312

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (24)
Facebook
5.0 (6)

Why choose this provider?

Bracken Insurance Agency offers personal and business insurance solutions in Broken Arrow through its carrier network. The independent insurance provider has coverages for automobiles, recreational vehicles, motorcycles, boats and watercraft, and mobile homes. Its insurance advisors educate and help car owners obtain adequate protection from damage arising from collisions, liabilities, and uninsured motorists. Bracken Insurance Agency also carries bonds and contractors' insurance. President and owner Robert Bracken II began his insurance career in 1998, a year after obtaining his finance degree.

  • Multiple Carriers

4724 South Union Avenue, Tulsa, OK 74107
WebsiteLicense: 100104069

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (21)
Facebook
5.0 (4)

Why choose this provider?

Charles G. Harris Insurance Agency is a Tulsa-based business that specializes in risk management solutions. Serving Broken Arrow, the company assists clients in a number of areas, including auto insurance. Its team of agents creates car protection plans that may include a combination of any of the following: rental reimbursement, collision, medical payments, uninsured motorist, and bodily Injury and property damage liability coverage. Charles G. Harris Insurance Agency is a third-generation family-owned business that started operating in 1925.

  • RV & Motorhome
  • Boats
  • Motorcyle & ATV

4008 South Elm Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
WebsiteLicense: 10000091

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (5)
Google
5.0 (4)

Why choose this provider?

Flippo Insurance offers risk management solutions from its Broken Arrow location. Its team creates multiple types of protection plans such as auto insurance, which may include collision and comprehensive coverages. In addition, the company's agents can create car insurance plans with personal injury protection. They can also craft policies for customers that need commercial auto insurance. Flippo Insurance is owned and run by Roger Flippo, who has been in the insurance industry for over 25 years.

  • Boats
  • Motorcyle & ATV

5506 South Lewis Avenue, Tulsa, OK 74105
WebsiteLicense: 100101527

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

LandesBlosch is an insurance company servicing the needs of clients in the Tulsa and Broken Arrow areas. The company focuses on building relationships with its clients while providing auto insurance that meets their needs. It provides recommendations to helps its clients protect their assets. With this, its clients get auto insurance that is customized to include and exclude coverages whenever necessary. LandesBlosch also offers insurance coverage for motorcycles, boats, and classic cars.

  • Multiple Carriers

9238 South Sheridan Road, Tulsa, OK 74133
WebsiteLicense: 3000159482

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (19)
Facebook
5.0 (5)

Why choose this provider?

Arkoma Insurance is a car insurance agency that serves individuals and families in Broken Arrow. Its agents write policies that provide a variety of coverage for drivers and car owners. Some of the coverage types offered include collision, comprehensive, liability, and medical payments. They provide personalized service to ensure customers get the right auto coverages based on their needs and situations. To help clients know the available options, the company presents comparisons of insurance quotes.

  • Motorcyle & ATV

Compare our Top Local Car Insurance Agencies

NameExpertise RatingAddressPromotionsLearn more
Harmon Insurance
709 West Washington Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Greater Tulsa Insurance
2604 West Kenosha Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
All American Insurance Agency
6145 East 21st Street, Tulsa, OK 74114
Chris Mathurin
500 South Elm Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Gallagher - Tulsa Oklahoma
1300 South Main Street, Tulsa, OK 74119
Best Insurance
11 South Sheridan Road, Tulsa, OK 74112
mainstreetinsuranceok.com
319 South Main Street, Sapulpa, OK 74066
Steve Lane
22 West 2nd Street, Sand Springs, OK 74063
The Arrow Group
2720 North Hemlock Court, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Tedford Insurance - Jenks
121 East Main Street, Jenks, OK 74037
Bracken Insurance Agency
9717 East 42nd Street, Tulsa, OK 74146
Charles G. Harris Insurance Agency
4724 South Union Avenue, Tulsa, OK 74107
Flippo Insurance
4008 South Elm Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
landesblosch.com
5506 South Lewis Avenue, Tulsa, OK 74105
Arkoma Insurance
9238 South Sheridan Road, Tulsa, OK 74133

FAQs

  • Introduction

    A way to stay protected while on the road, car insurance offers a financial safety net should accidents occur, regardless of who's at fault. The right car insurance agency can be very valuable, providing a way to purchase an ideal level of auto insurance coverage for personal circumstances. Agencies can help customers select the most beneficial coverage options while saving money on their insurance plan. With help from a qualified agency, it's possible to feel safe and secure behind the wheel.

  • How do auto insurance rates in Broken Arrow compare to state and national averages?

    In Broken Arrow, drivers spend roughly $759 annually for minimum coverage and approximately $2,646 for full coverage. This is notably more expensive by 32% compared to Oklahoma's mean of $2,493 and 19% above the U.S. average of $2,216. Monthly, the rates stand at about $63 for basic coverage and $221 for comprehensive insurance.

  • If your car insurance in Broken Arrow is non-renewed and you are struggling to find a new insurer, what steps can you take?

    When faced with policy cancellations or non-renewals on car insurance in Broken Arrow, securing a new policy can be challenging due to stringent underwriting guidelines. Initially, an individual should approach multiple insurers to seek coverage. However, if these efforts don't bear fruit, consider reaching out to the Oklahoma Assigned Risk Auto Plan. Contact them at (866) 667-2827 or fax at (405) 842-1361.

  • If you plan to move to Broken Arrow, can you transfer your auto insurance before your existing policy expires?

    Yes. You can change your car insurance provider whenever you wish before your policy expires, especially for those pondering relocation to Broken Arrow or if it's been a while since you last reviewed local rates. Allocating a short period to investigate online insurance comparison websites might lead to unexpected savings. Remember, staying updated can be financially beneficial.

  • If you have a vehicle registered in another state, can you insure it in Broken Arrow?

    No. You can't insure a car in Broken Arrow if it is registered in another state. In Oklahoma, you should possess insurance corresponding to where your vehicle is registered. You have a 30-day window to register your vehicle in your home state. Insurance providers adhere to the principle of aligning insurance with the vehicle's registration state due to distinct state regulations.

  • Is Oklahoma's state-mandated minimum coverage adequate if you're involved in a major accident in Broken Arrow?

    It might not be enough. While the state-prescribed minimum coverage legally permits you to drive in Broken Arrow, it might prove insufficient in major accidents. Oklahoma's basic liability insurance might suffice for minor damages, but in cases of severe injuries or legal proceedings, it could fall short. Speak with your insurance representative about appropriate liability limit modifications to protect yourself from potentially significant costs.

  • What is car insurance?

    Car insurance is a form of insurance that can cover damages to cars, drivers, passengers, and other property when an accident occurs. If another car crashes into a driver, or if a driver causes an accident, car insurance will pay most or all of the cost of repairs.