Best Jewelers
in Toledo

Why These Jewelers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored jewelers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best jewelers in Toledo, OH.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks825619

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Alan Miller Jewelers

Alan Miller Jewelers offers one-stop shopping for every jewelry need in Oregon. The store exclusively features The Marry Me Diamond and carries collections by designers such as Pandora, Kameleon, Caribbean Blue, and the Everlon Diamond Knot Collection. Alan Miller Jewelers is also Northwest Ohio’s Pandora Gold Level Dealer. Customers reported “best selection of unique pieces,” “nice to work with someone we trust,” and “excellent service and craftsmanship.”

Oregon, OH(419) 693-4311


Barrow's Jewelers

Barrow’s Jewelers is a family-owned and operated full-service jewelry store in Toledo. The store offers custom designed jewelry, diamonds, jewelry and watch repairs, and appraisals by experienced designers Gabe, Greg, and Lisa Barrow. The staff also includes a Master Jeweler with 36 years of experience in jewelry manufacturing and the restoration of damaged heirlooms. Service is available for many watch brands including Invicta, Guess, Tommy Hilfiger, Rolex, Movado, and Omega.

Toledo, OH(419) 385-6114



Broer-Freeman has 130 years of history in Toledo as a full-service jewelry store offering custom design pieces and quality brand names such as Reed & Barton, A. Jaffe, Gottlieb & Sons, Mastoloni, and B.A. Ballou. The store also offers repair services for jewelry, chipped crystal glassware, and antiques. Other services include appraisals and estate collection valuations. Broer-Freeman specializes in watch repairs for many brands including Rolex, Piaget, Tiffany, and Cartier with a one year warranty on all repair work.

Toledo, OH(419) 536-5272


Butler Fine Jewelers

Butler Fine Jewelers is a family-owned business in Holland featuring the original jewelry designs of the award-winning, owner and founder, Ramon Butler. The full-service store also offers ring sizing, stone setting, and jewelry and watch repairs. Butler Fine Jewelers is a member of Jewelers of America and the Mid-America Jewelers Association.

Holland, OH(419) 866-7055


C Sterling Jewelers

C Sterling Jewelers is a family-owned jewelry showroom in Perrysburg offering unique, personalized jewelry and quality items by name brand designers. The store offers bridal jewelry by designers such as Benchmark, Tacori, and Imagine Bridal. Watches are available from many brand names including Michele, TW Steel, and Watch Finder. C Sterling Jewelers carries a selection of loose diamonds and has over 30 years of experience to guide clients in finding the perfect stone.

Perrysburg, OH(419) 897-9131


Carroll/Ochs Jewelers

Carroll/Ochs Jewelers is a full-service, family-owned business in Monroe offering custom and brand name jewelry from designers such as Candela Jewelry, Chrysalis, HL, Hot Diamonds, and Imperial Pearl. Engagement rings are available from Ashi Diamonds, Gabriel NY, Camelot Bridal and more. The company is a sponsor of the Grafton Hall Bridal Expo and the American Red Cross Annual Golf Outing and contributes to the Monroe Knights of Columbus, the Monroe County Chamber of Commerce, and others.

Monroe, MI(734) 243-9500


David Kay Jewelers

David Kay Jewelers provides custom design jewelry and repairs with over three decades of experience in the industry. All jewelry repairs are handled on location. The Temperance store also carries gold, silver, and platinum delivered in coins and bars with no sales tax in Michigan saving Toledo customers Ohio’s sales tax. The experienced staff also buys gold, gold coins, gold bars, unwanted jewelry, and silver products.

Temperance, MI(734) 847-6700


Eli Antypas Jewelers

Eli Antypas Jewelers is a full-service jewelry store offering custom designs by Eli, jewelry and watch repair, appraisals, engraving, and the purchase of diamonds and precious metals. The store also carries brand names such as Kelim Jewelry Design, Versus by Versace, Uno de 50, and much more. The certified and experienced staff handle all services in a state-of-the-art workshop on site. The owner and founder, Eli Antypas, has more than 25 years of experience in Toledo.

Toledo, OH(419) 842-0022


Estate Jewelers of Toledo

Estate Jewelers of Toledo is a family-owned business with over 40 years of jewelry and diamond brokerage experience. The company is interested in buying gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, estate jewelry, and high-end watches. The master jewelers are highly trained in the custom design of jewelry for engagements, weddings, graduations, or other special occasions. Estate Jewelers also offers repairs for jewelry and watches in-house and all work comes with a free warranty.

Toledo, OH(419) 885-9100


Harold Jaffe Jewelers

Harold Jaffe Jewelers is a family-owned, full-service jewelry store offering fine watches and fine jewelry in Toledo. The experienced staff sell and service fine watches from Ball, Carl F. Bucherer, Frederique Constant, Lego, Luminox, and more. Jewelry designs are available from brand names such as Adel Chefridi, Danhov, Erez, and Euro Fashion. Harold Jaffe Jewelers is a proud member of the American Gem Society, the BBB, and Jewelers of America.

Toledo, OH(419) 472-4480


J Foster Jewelers

J Foster Jewelers has two jewelry showrooms in Toledo and Maumee with an extensive selection of bridal and engagement jewelry from quality brands such as Benchmark, Lovebright, Bridal Bells, I.B. Goodman, Kattan Diamonds, and much more. The store is an authorized dealer for every brand and every item on display is carefully hand-selected by the experienced staff to ensure quality. J Foster Jewelers offers a free lifetime warranty on every item sold in the store.

Toledo, OH(419) 473-3300


Jeffrey Mann Fine Jewelers

Jeffrey Mann Fine Jewelers is a family-owned business in Toledo carrying a large selection of bridal jewelry, custom jewelry, and diamonds. The full-service jewelry shop also offers items made by recognized jewelry designers and brands such as Forevermark to Simon G, Lagos, Michele Watches, Ernst Benz Timepieces, and more. Many services are available such as jewelry repairs, remounting and restyling, cleaning and inspections, and appraisals. Jeffry Mann Jewelers carries an exclusive line from Forevermark called The Corrine Collection in honor of his wife.

Toledo, OH(419) 882-6994


Jensen Jewelers

Jensen Jewelers has the Toledo area’s largest goldsmith studio with onsite designers and state-of-the-art technology to service every jewelry need. Jensen’s manufactures many styles of jewelry in gold and platinum and offers a selection of loose diamonds and colored stones. Customers reported “out of this world,” “best jeweler in town,” and “customer service is not a thing of the past with this company.”

Toledo, OH(419) 471-1000


Jewelry B. Jacob

Jewelry B. Jacob offers custom designed jewelry featuring unique, precious stones such as Azurmalachite, Maw-Sit-Sit, Rutilated Quartz, Tsavorite Garnets, Padparadscha Sapphires, and Lapis Lazuli. The showroom in Toledo is the workshop and design studio of B. Jacob Mowery, a GIA certified, Graduate Jeweler and Gemologist. The store also offers jewelry repairs on site.

Toledo, OH(419) 509-1491


Leo Marks Jewelers

Leo Marks Jewelers is a full-service jewelry store in Toledo offering fine jewelry both custom designed and brand names for every occasion. The store carries brands such as Amavida, Gabriel & Co. New York, Verragio, and Hearts On Fire. The staff handles custom designs and jewelry modifications in-house. Leo Marks also buys jewelry and allows clients to borrow money using their jewelry as collateral.

Toledo, OH(419) 531-1223


McGivern Jewelers, Inc.

McGivern Jewelers, Inc. is a family-owned direct diamond merchant and designer of custom fine jewelry founded in 1980. The Perrysburg staff includes a diamond importer, two full-time gemologists, and other experienced jewelry manufacturers. The store offers an extensive line of beautiful gold or platinum jewelry and specializes in GIA certified diamonds. McGivern Jewelers clients reported “excellent experience and product," “great customer service,” and “delivered as promised.”

Perrysburg, OH(419) 874-5509


Milkins Jewelers

Milkins Jewelers is a full-service jewelry store in Monroe serving customers in Toledo and beyond since 1905. The experienced staff includes a Certified Gemologist Appraiser working in an accredited gem laboratory and custom jewelry designer Burdett Milkins. The extensive list of brand designers includes Frank Reubel Jewelry, Bam Collection, Viszu Jewelry, The Gems of the Great Lakes, and Tyflied-Fishing Jewelry. Bridal collections include Hidalgo Stackable Rings, Peter Storm, Etienne Perret, and many more.

Monroe, MI(734) 242-1023


Northwood Jewelers

Northwood Jewelers is a full-service jewelry store offering every kind of jewelry from diamonds to birthstones and more. The family-owned store offers an extensive selection of Landstrom’s Black Hills Gold, Melodies in Motion clocks designed by Seiko, and Bering’s line of men’s and women’s watches. Northwood Jewelers provides a lifetime service of complimentary inspection and cleaning on purchases, insurance advice, and other services.

Northwood, OH(419) 691-6352


Paul Antypas Jeweler

Paul Antypas Jeweler is a family-owned business in Toledo offering custom designed jewelry, wedding and engagement rings, watches, and loose diamonds. The owner, Paul Antypas, is a master goldsmith and jeweler with over three decades of experience in jewelry craftsmanship. He also offers on-site repairs within 24 hours or the repair is free.

Toledo, OH(419) 725-1313


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: