Laurels
Best Wedding
Cake Bakers in
Columbus
2017

Why These Wedding Cake Bakers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored wedding cake bakers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best wedding cake bakers in Columbus, OH.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks20012718

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

A Taste of Cake

A Taste of Cake, located in Columbus since 1980, makes pieces of cake art for weddings and other special events throughout the area. Owner Twyla Grooms has been baking for more than 35 years, and she takes the time to learn about her clients' preferences and get a sense of their personality and style. In addition to wedding cakes, Ms. Grooms can make cakes for birthdays, bridal and baby showers, baptisms, anniversaries, graduations, galas, and holiday parties. Delivery is available upon request.

Columbus, OH(614) 891-1141

Website

Alice's Piece of Cake

As the owner, namesake, and principal Cake Artist of Alice's Piece of Cake, LLC, Alice Dreischarf makes sweet treats for a range of occasions, from weddings and anniversaries to birthdays, holidays, and galas. Ms. Dreischarf uses only fresh ingredients, and she personally designs and bakes all cakes at her commercial-grade kitchen in Powell. Notably, Alice's Piece of Cake, LLC has been listed in The Knot's "Best of Weddings" feature, and it earned one of WeddingWire's prestigious "Couples' Choice Awards" (although, at the time, they were called "Bride's Choice Awards").

Powell, OH(740) 917-9031

Website

Belle's Bread

Belle's Bread is a hybrid Japanese and French bakery in Columbus that sells bread, cakes, sandwiches, and hot menu items. All of the business's cakes are light, moist, and flavorful, attributes typical of Japanese cakes. In addition to its selection of premade cakes, Belle's Bread offers made-to-order birthday and wedding cakes in a broad variety of styles, sizes, and flavors. Gluten-free items are available upon request.

Columbus, OH(614) 451-7110

Website

Cakes 2 Envy, LLC

Cakes 2 Envy, LLC is a Columbus business that makes cakes, cupcakes, and desserts for weddings, baby showers, birthdays, and engagements. Sonya Drake, the company's founder and cake designer, grew up baking alongside her mother, crafting scrumptious pastries and desserts for holidays and family parties. Now she works with her own two daughters, professional cake decorators who share her love for baking.

Columbus, OH(614) 376-6991

Website

Cakes by Cecile

Cakes by Cecile, headquartered in Columbus, is the cake shop of seasoned baker Cecile Small. Since opening the business in 1999, Ms. Small has made cakes for weddings, anniversaries, and birthdays. Past customers gush about the cakes, not just for their culinary excellence, but also, their exquisite visual designs. In 2014, Cakes by Cecile was featured in Columbus Bride Magazine's feature, "10 of the Best Columbus Wedding Cake Bakers."

Columbus, OH(614) 885-5501

Website

Cakes Creatively by Crystal

At Cakes Creatively by Crystal, the business's owner and head baker, Crystal, makes and intricately decorates cakes for weddings and other special occasions in the Columbus Metro. Cakes Creatively by Crystal has received multiple "Couples' Choice Awards" from the website WeddingWire, and it was featured in The Knot's 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016 "Best of Weddings" feature. Interested customers should browse the shop's mouthwatering online portfolio for images of past work.

Reynoldsburg, OH(614) 783-4830

Website

Dublin Cake Cottage

Dublin Cake Cottage makes custom cakes, including wedding cakes, for Columbus Metro customers. Carol Kender and Sharon Mueller, mother and daughter, make high-quality cakes for weddings as well as other occasions, such as birthdays, anniversaries, and other events. Six years ago, Carol Kender purchased Dublin Cake Cottage from its previous owner, Ann Zanon. An enormous range of cake flavors and fillings is available.

Shawnee Hills, OH(614) 789-0804

Website

Fate Cakes

For its Columbus Metro clientele, Fate Cakes makes fresh desserts such as cupcakes, cakes, and cake pops. The business, which is open six days a week, provides easy online ordering for weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, graduations, and other big events in the Columbus Metro. Notably, the business specializes in making cakes and cupcakes for Ohio State University students and alumni. Buckeyes planning a tailgate or assembling a care package ought to consider ordering from Fate Cakes.

Columbus, OH(614) 219-9429

Website

J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes LLC

J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes LLC is a Columbus-based maker of custom wedding cakes and other baked goods. The staff uses fresh ingredients and does not operate a storefront. This means that they have the time to give each client individualized attention. J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes LLC complies with Ohio's bakery regulations, and it encourages customers to make orders well in advance, in case the team is overbooked.

Columbus, OH(614) 805-7070

Website

Jan Kish

Jan Kish is a renowned cake artist based in Worthington who makes wedding cakes and other desserts for clients in the Columbus Metro area and beyond. She is highly respected by members of the wedding industry, including Maria McBride-Mellinger, the Style Editor of Bride's Magazine. Ms. McBride-Mellinger has called Ms. Kish "a master sugar artist who has the imagination and the magical fingers to bring exquisitely sweet details to life."

Worthington, OH(614) 848-5855

Website

Kelly's Cakery LLC

Kelly's Cakery LLC, located in Hilliard, makes cakes and cupcakes for customers from all over the Columbus Metro area. It has received multiple "Couples' Choice Awards" from the website WeddingWire and was listed in The Knot's "Best of Weddings" feature in 2014, 2015, and 2016. The business's specialty is making faux tier cakes, incorporating Styrofoam, which cost about half as much as real cake tiers.

Hilliard, OH(614) 321-9866

Website

Lady Di Cakes

Lady Di Cakes has been operating in Columbus since 2004, making fresh cakes and desserts for weddings, corporate gatherings, holidays, and other events. At the head of the team is Veronica Wills, who founded the business after taking a cake design class with her mother. Ms. Wills takes a unique approach to cake design in that, above all, she focuses on listening to the client. Customers of Lady Di Cakes are also collaborators, helping to shape the final product.

Columbus, OH(614) 270-9939

Website

Nanak Bakery

Located in Westerville, Nanak Bakery makes cakes and other desserts for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, and showers in the Columbus area. For over 20 years, the team has produced high-quality pastries and specialty cakes. Staff members use real light cream, among other high-quality, fresh ingredients. Nanak Bakery makes cakes of any size, shape, and style, and they can accommodate a range of dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free and vegan.

Westerville, OH(614) 882-8080

Website

Resch's Bakery

Resch's Bakery, based in Columbus, creates custom desserts for customers in and around the city. In addition to selling fresh cupcakes, donuts, and other pastries directly at its brick-and-mortar store, Resch's Bakery creates custom wedding cakes for local ceremonies. The staff can create tiered cakes, using buttercream, Champagne cake, and other flavors, in an array of styles and colors. The business has been listed in The Knot's "Best of Weddings" list.

Columbus, OH(614) 237-7421

Website

Scrumptious Crumbs

Scrumptious Crumbs, in Columbus, is a wedding cake provider that makes everything fresh, never frozen. In 2016, Scrumptious Crumbs was featured in The Knot's "Best of Weddings," and it has earned a spot in The Knot's prestigious "Best of Weddings -- Hall of Fame." Options include layer cakes, specialty cakes, cupcakes, brownies, dessert bars and cake pops, and cake balls, among other delicious sweet treats.

Columbus, OH(614) 529-9223

Website

Short North Piece of Cake

Short North Piece of Cake, a bakery in Columbus, makes fresh cakes, cookies, and cupcakes for weddings and other special occasions. Customers can also pick up treats at the Short North Piece of Cake shop. Wedding cakes by the team are custom-designed according to the clients' wishes, using fresh ingredients, and delivered on the big day. For its past wedding cake art, Short North Piece of Cake has won multiple "Couples' Choice Awards," and it has been listed in The Knot's "Best of Weddings."

Columbus, OH(614) 421-0399

Website

The Cake Studio

The Cake Studio is a Powell-based bakery that makes cakes for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, baby showers, bridal showers, and other events in the area. Customers can view the business's website for a list of available flavors. These include red velvet, lemon-lemon, toasted almond, cookies & cream, "coffee lovers," and other scrumptious selections. Cakes vary according to the size, flavor, and design requested.

Powell, OH(740) 881-6400

Website

The Suisse Shop

The Suisse Shop opened in 1983 and has since sold countless numbers of European-style tortes, cheesecakes, cupcakes, cookies, tarts, and wedding cakes to Columbus Metro customers. Over the years, the team has crafted over 2,000 cakes for local weddings. In 2016, the Suisse Shop won honors in WeddingWire, as well as The Knot's "Best of Weddings" feature. It was named Central Ohio's "Best Wedding Cake Bakery 2016."

Columbus, OH(614) 846-5102

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: