Laurels
Best Jewelers
in Columbus
2017

Why These Jewelers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored jewelers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best jewelers in Columbus, OH.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks18311719

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Alexanders Jewelers

Alexanders Jewelers is a full-service jewelry store specializing in custom engagement and wedding rings for customers in Central Ohio. The jewelry collection includes designs by Andrea Candela, Simon G. Fana, Claude Thibaudeau, and more. Alexanders Jewelers also repairs watches, sells diamonds, and buys gold. Past customers praise Alexanders Jewelers for its knowledgeable staff and excellent customer service.

Grove City, OH(614) 233-6666

Website

Argo & Lehne Jewelers

Argo & Lehne Jewelers is a third-generation jewelry store that has served the Columbus Metro area since 1924. The store specializes in vintage and one-of-a-kind pieces. Services include appraisals of fine jewelry, custom designs, engraving, repairs, and restoration of heirlooms. The gemologist appraiser on staff is trained by the Gemological Institute of America and certified by the American Gem Society. Customers highly recommend Argo & Lehne Jewelers for jewelry expertise, fair prices, and attentive staff.

Columbus, OH(614) 457-6261

Website

Baker’s Village Garden Center and Gift Shoppe

Baker’s Village Garden Center and Gift Shoppe began in 1980 as a small family store in Northwest Columbus. The store has since expanded to offer plants, floral design, ornaments, and gifts. Baker’s Village also carries the popular Ginger Snaps jewelry line.

Powell, OH(614) 889-9407

Website

Beechwold Custom Jewelry

Beechwold Custom Jewelry custom designs bridal jewelry for customers in the greater Columbus area. Founded in 2005, the store offers engagement rings and wedding bands with the customer’s choice of gemstones and precious metals. The store uses diamonds that are certified and conflict-free. Past customers praise the store owner’s artistry, knowledgeable expertise, and trustworthy service.

Columbus, OH(614) 268-0012

Website

Buckeye Gold Company

Buckeye Gold Company buys gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, and coins in Dublin and several Central Ohio locations. The store makes offers on a wide variety of items, including solid gold jewelry or watches, dental gold, sterling silver jewelry or flatware, U.S. war nickels, solid platinum jewelry or wire, quality diamonds ½ carat or larger, and collectible paper currency. All items are sorted, tested, and valued in front of customers. Walk-ins are welcome.

Dublin, OH(614) 793-4653

Website

Carioti Jewelers

Carioti Jewelers has served the Columbus Metro area since 1991. The jewelry store offers custom designs, repairs, and appraisals by a GIA Graduate Gemologist. The store’s inventory features designer pieces such as Gabriel & Co., Benchmark, Imperial, Seiko, and Citizen. Carioti Jewelers also supports many non-profit organizations, including Make a Wish Foundation, Safari Club International, and Opera Columbus.

Columbus, OH(614) 221-8588

Website

CDI Diamonds & Jewelry

CDI Diamonds & Jewelry works within any budget for customers in the Columbus Metro area. CDI offers certified loose diamonds, designer engagement rings, custom designs, repairs, and appraisals. The jewelry store has over 30 years of experience meeting the needs of retailers and now offers its expertise to the public. The entire staff, including a graduate gemologist, is trained by the Gemological Institute of America. CDI is a member of Jewelers of America and The Dublin Chamber of Commerce.

Columbus, OH(614) 401-6677

Website

Denig Jewelers

Denig Jewelers is a three-generation family business, serving the greater Dublin area since 1947. The store employs a gemologist and sales associate who are certified by the American Gem Society. Denig Jewelers features designer collections such as Triton, William Henry, and Rembrandt Charms. The full-service jewelry store repairs heirloom pieces, custom designs jewelry, and offers appraisals. Customers can also have their jewelry cleaned and inspected for free at any time.

Worthington, OH(614) 885-6164

Website

Edward Warren Jewelers

Edward Warren Jewelers has been based in the Columbus area since 1987. The store’s collection comprises jewelry, engagement rings, wedding bands, timepieces, custom designs, and diamonds. Customers enjoy several free services, including jewelry cleaning, inspection, insurance appraisal, rhodium plating reapplication, and quality guarantee.

Pickerington, OH(614) 755-9229

Website

Grandview Mercantile

Grandview Mercantile features 45 antique dealers of Central Ohio in a 6,000-square-feet marketplace. Since 1997, the marketplace has offered vintage furniture, original art, estate jewelry, fine china, and unique decorative pieces. Hundreds of new items arrive every week at its historic location in the Short North Arts District.

Columbus, OH(614) 421-7000

Website

Jeff Johnson & Co.

Jeff Johnson & Co. specializes in engagement rings, special occasion gifts, jewelry repairs, and reinventions for the greater Columbus area. The jewelry store features vintage pieces along with designers such as Thistle & Bee, Mastoloni, and Whitehouse Brothers. All repairs are performed in-house by experienced goldsmiths.

Columbus, OH(614) 459-8890

Website

Leo Alfred Jewelers

Leo Alfred Jewelers is a family-owned jewelry store that has operated in the Dublin community for over 30 years. The Leo Alfred Jewelry collection specializes in one-of-a-kind bracelets, rings, earrings, and necklaces. The full-service store employs goldsmiths and Certified Gemologist Appraisers able to repair as well as custom design jewelry.

Dublin, OH(614) 889-5888

Website

ONE SIX FIVE

ONE SIX FIVE specializes in modern jewelry for everyday wear. The Columbus store’s jewelry collection is designed and handmade by Kaleigh Shrigley and Claire Lowe. The store also includes a curated selection of apothecary, ceramics, paper, and other goods made in the USA. ONE SIX FIVE has been featured in Cosmopolitan, InStyle, and Refinery29.

Columbus, OH(740) 816-4877

Website

Posin Diamonds and Fine Jewelry

Posin Diamonds and Fine Jewelry is a jewelry store based in Columbus and serving the surrounding area. The store features engagement rings, watches, special gifts, and repairs. Customers recommend Posin Diamonds and Fine Jewelry for its beautiful jewelry selection, helpful staff, and fair prices.

Columbus, OH(614) 457-2400

Website

Powell Jewelers

Powell Jewelers has over 30 years of experience providing jewelry from local artisans and designer brands to customers in the Columbus Metro area. The showroom features an extensive bridal selection. The store also offers jewelry repairs, appraisals, diamonds, and custom designs. Powell Jewelers is a member of Jewelers of America, Mid-America Jewelers Association, and The Greater Powell Area Chamber of Commerce.

Powell, OH(614) 764-4764

Website

Sawchuk Jewelers

Sawchuk Jewelers is a jewelry store based in Hilliard and serving customers throughout the Columbus area. The store specializes in engagement rings and offers fine jewelry repairs, restorations, and appraisals. Sawchuk Jewelers also buys gold, silver, and loose diamonds. Past customers highly recommend the store for its affordable prices, friendly staff, and high-quality jewelry.

Hilliard, OH(614) 219-1385

Website

The Johnson Family Diamond Cellar

The Johnson Family Diamond Cellar is a jewelry store based in Columbus and serving customers throughout the surrounding area. It is part of the Diamond Cellar Holdings family of jewelry stores, with locations in Ohio, Oklahoma, and Texas. Diamond Cellar offers the finest jewelry, diamonds, and watches hand-selected from throughout the world. All sales associates are certified by the Gemological Institute of America, and many are Graduate Gemologists.

Columbus, OH(614) 961-4114

Website

Worthington Jewelers

Worthington Jewelers has created one-of-a-kind pieces in Central Ohio since 2000. The store repairs, appraises, and buys jewelry as well. Customers receive free jewelry cleanings and inspections. Worthington Jewelers is a member of the Ohio Jewelers Association, Jewelers of America, and the International Gem Society.

Worthington, OH(614) 430-8800

Website

Y Sadiq Diamond

Y Sadiq Diamond designs and sells fine jewelry for the Dublin Metro area. Founder Yusuf Sadiq has over 25 years of experience in jewelry and gemstones. The jewelry store also repairs and appraises customers’ pieces. Past customers recommend Y Sadiq Diamond for its beautiful selection of jewelry, knowledgeable gemologist, and personal service.

Worthington, OH(614) 441-4403

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: