Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Columbus

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Columbus Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 437 266 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio

Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio serves homeowners, landlords, and renters in Delaware, Ohio, and throughout the Columbus area. Its policies protect homeowners in the event that their home or the belongings they keep inside it are lost or damaged as a result of fire, natural disaster, vandalism, or theft. The company is accredited by the Better Business Bureau and offers a variety of other insurance products including health, life, auto, business, and specialty policies.

831 N Houk Rd
Delaware, OH 43015


Bazemore Insurance Group

Bazemore Insurance Group is a family-owned and operated insurance brokerage based in Westerville, Ohio. Established by Jordan Bazemore in 2016, the agency specializes in providing home insurance to residents throughout the Columbus metro area. The agency has extensive experience writing policies for condo-owners, renters, landlords, and owners of commercial properties, financially protecting clients from loss and liability. Bazemore Insurance Group also offers auto, term life, and universal life insurance services.

5368 Central College Rd
Westerville, OH 43081


Dolbow Insurance

Dolbow Insurance is an independent agency located in Westerville, Ohio. It provides home insurance for clients throughout Ohio, La Grange, and Kentucky. Founded in 1993, it is partnered with many insurance carriers, providing it with a wide choice of policies for clients. Coverage can be for homes or apartments, homeowners and renters, and include additions beyond standard inclusions like structural damage and personal possessions. The agency can advise on the pros and cons of named-perils and all-risk policies.

212 S State St
Westerville, OH 43081


Dressel & Evans Agency, Inc.

Dressel & Evans Agency Inc. is an independent insurance agency based in Columbus, Ohio. A provider of home insurance solutions amongst a wider portfolio of services, the agency represents a list of carriers that offer flexible policies for homeowners and renters. It can also provide coverage for condos and mobile homes. Policies typically include protection in the event of structural damage, fire, and theft. They can be expanded to include personal liability and coverage for particularly expensive items like jewelry.

1527 Northwest Blvd
Columbus, OH 43212


Great Lakes Insurance

Founded in 1989, Great Lakes Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in Powell, Ohio, and serving the residents in and around the Columbus area. The company offers home insurance policies from multiple insurance carriers to bring its clients competitive rates. Great Lakes Insurance offers policies for different property sizes including single-family homes, condos, and rental units. It helps clients to determine their needed coverage by assessing their risk factors. The company also offers auto, life, and business insurance.

47 W Olentangy St
Powell, OH 43065


Holobaugh Insurance

Holobaugh Insurance in Troy, Ohio, is an independent insurance agency that provides home insurance in the Columbus metro area. Established in 2011, Holobaugh Insurance offers insurance products that concentrate on minimizing risk to homes due to fire, floods, liability, or other unforeseen events. The agency is available 24 hours a day via text or e-mail for consultations on its insurance products, which also include auto insurance, business insurance, and life insurance.

1516 W Main St
Troy, OH 45373


Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC

Keystone Insurance Agency LLC is an independent home insurance agency operating out of Columbus, Ohio, with 10 other offices across the state. The company maintains relationships with a variety of large insurance providers to offer its clients a range of options for their needs. It provides coverage for damage to the home in the case of a fire or natural disaster, liability, and stolen or damaged belongings. Keystone Insurance Agency LLC also sells business and auto insurance.

5640 Groveport Rd Ste 2
Groveport, OH 43125


Ray Insurance

Ray Insurance is a fourth generation family-owned independent insurance agency in business since 1923, and it offers home insurance services to clients in the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. This agency is versed in personal property protection for clients with high-value items, collectibles, antiques, and jewelry. It provides flood insurance services to clients in applicable zones. Clients can also purchase automobile and identity insurance from this firm, which offers umbrella coverage policies.

1580 Fishinger Rd
Columbus, OH 43221


The Guarantee Insurance Agency

The Guarantee Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency based in Springfield, Ohio, that serves residents in the Columbus metro area and surrounding counties. With more than 100 years of experience, the company provides insurance for homeowners and renters of condos, townhouses, and traditional houses. Policies include protection for liability and damage done to dwellings and personal property. Discounts are available for homeowners with multiple insurance policies, paper-free billing preferences, and alarm systems.

1130 Vester Ave
Springfield, OH 45503


The Insurance Circle Agency

The Insurance Circle Agency is located in Canal Winchester, Ohio, and has served the surrounding areas for over 30 years. The agency helps clients obtain home and condominium insurance policies that protect against liability, loss, and damages caused by natural disasters, and some policies cover flood and fire damage. The company is partnered with multiple top-rated insurance carriers, such as Progressive, Anthem BlueCross, and Ohio Mutual Insurance Group. The Insurance Circle Agency also provides auto, life, health, umbrella, and business insurance.

44 S High St
Canal Winchester, OH 43110


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area