Expertise.com

2024

Last updated:

Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Columbus, OH

Our Recommended Top 20

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Columbus Local Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

447Reviewed

276Curated

20Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.

Providers

featured provider = Featured Provider

585 S Front St #300, Columbus, OH 43215
WebsiteLicense: 1342537

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.8 (1245)
Facebook
4.7 (29)

Why choose this provider?

Matic, a digital insurance marketplace, has been serving Columbus and nearby areas since 2014. Through the support of an agency of advisors, it offers a range of products, including car insurance policies covering liability, collisions, personal injury protection, and roadside assistance. The company also provides insurance for homes, floods, earthquakes, extra liabilities, and pets. Matic compares quotes from a network of over 40 insurance carriers to help customers find the policy that suits their budgets.

  • Multiple Carriers

20 S. Third Street Suite 210, Columbus, OH 43215
WebsiteLicense: 1063323

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (21)
Google
4.6 (16)
Yelp
1.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Sylvia A. Garret & Associates Agency, LLC, serves the locals of Columbus and the surrounding communities. It provides auto insurance that can be further modified with add-ons like protection against damage, car theft, or accidents that don't involve other vehicles. It also offers other personal insurance policies, such as home, rental property, individual life, high net worth, identity theft, and individual retirement. The independent agency has been serving families and businesses since 1967. Sylvia A. Garrett, the owner, supports local non-profits and organizations.

  • Bundling Option

333 N Limestone St, Springfield, OH 45503

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (16)
Facebook
5.0 (5)

Why choose this provider?

Link-Hellmuth Insurance has been providing insurance services to residents of Springfield, Ohio, for over 123 years. The company's agents help insurance shoppers find customized auto insurance policies for their cars. It provides a broad range of auto coverage, including collision, rental car accident, roadside rescue, full glass, and liabilities. Link-Hellmuth Insurance also offers homeowners, rental, life, boat, and business insurance. Moreover, apartment renters may insure their belongings and get comprehensive liability coverage.

1580 Fishinger Road, Columbus, OH 43221
WebsiteLicense: 1874455

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (28)
Google
4.2 (25)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Ray Insurance is a fourth-generation family-owned company catering to clients in Columbus and the nearby communities. It offers a wide selection of personal insurance products, including car or automobile, watercraft, motorcycles, homeowners, fine arts, and collectibles. It also serves individuals applying for life insurance policies. Ray Insurance has been in the industry since 1923. Its current president, Joe Ray IV, handles professional liability and business insurance plans. Joe is a member of the Rotary Club of Upper Arlington.

  • Motorcyle & ATV

1180. W. Broad St., Columbus, OH 43222
WebsiteLicense: 13345

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.7 (130)
Facebook
4.9 (78)

Why choose this provider?

Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio provides car insurance coverages to clients in Columbus and its nearby areas. The family-owned and family-operated company has been in the industry for over 26 years. Its agents offer liability and full coverage auto insurance to protect vehicles from accidents, theft, and damage. They also provide an SR22 bond, which helps clients reinstate their licenses after being suspended. Other coverages offered include renters' and homeowners', commercial vehicle, and motorcycle insurance.

  • Motorcyle & ATV

6050 Tain Dr, Dublin, OH 43017

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.9 (35)
Facebook
4.6 (29)

Why choose this provider?

The full-service independent insurance agency Haughn & Associates has been insuring drivers in the Dublin, Ohio, metro area since its founding in 1986. Through coverages such as liability and comprehensive, the company ensures clients are protected for at-fault accidents and for losses not involving collisions such as fire and theft. Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, and Travelers are among Haughn & Associates's numerous partners. The Agency also offers life, disability, and commercial insurance.

2000 Henderson Rd Ste 400, Columbus, OH 43220
WebsiteLicense: 957548

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.8 (34)
Facebook
5.0 (3)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Town & Village Insurance Service, Inc., is an independently owned and locally operated agency that serves Columbus. Its agents offer personalized car insurance policies with liability, no-fault, collision, and comprehensive coverage options to protect clients' finances. They also craft classic car insurance that covers agreed value, mileage, and roadside assistance. Business owners may opt for commercial auto protection plans with coverages for bodily injury liability, property damage while operating a company car, and medical payments or Personal Injury Protection.

  • Bundling Option

2970 McKinley Ave., Columbus, OH 43204
WebsiteLicense: 947373

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.2 (6)
Facebook
5.0 (5)

Why choose this provider?

Heyward Group LLC is an independent insurance agency serving clients in Columbus and the neighboring communities. It offers car insurance policies that provide coverage for medical expenses on bodily injuries and property damage liabilities. Owner Bryan Heyward opened an American Family Insurance franchise in 2006, becoming one of the agency's top agents nationwide with over 2,500 clients and $2 million of written insurance premiums. He later founded his agency in 2013, which offers coverage options from more than 150 insurance carriers.

  • Multiple Carriers

986 Morse Road, Columbus, OH 43229
WebsiteLicense: 17418423

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.7 (170)
Facebook
4.7 (27)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Solid Insurance is a family-owned business that caters to residential and commercial property owners in Columbus and the neighboring communities. It offers auto insurance programs that include coverages for financial liability for causing injuries to other people and damaging their personal belongings and losses as a result of fire, theft, and non-collision accidents. The company also provides life, home, business, and renters' insurance policies. It partners with several insurance carriers, such as Founders, Progressive, State Auto, Travelers, Foremost, and Encompass.

  • Multiple Carriers

1527 Northwest Blvd, Columbus, OH 43212
WebsiteLicense: 11014

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.7 (20)

Why choose this provider?

Dressel & Evans Agency, Inc., serves individuals and families in Columbus and the surrounding areas. It provides insurance coverage for a range of vehicles, from automobiles and motorcycles to trucks and watercraft. The agency also offers whole and term life insurance. It extends its coverage options to commercial clients who need policies for general liability, workers' compensation, and properties. It partners with multiple insurance carriers, including Auto-Owners Insurance, Ohio Mutual Insurance Group, and Motorists Mutual Insurance Company.

  • Bundling Option

39 S Liberty St, Delaware, OH 43015

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.8 (78)
Facebook
5.0 (7)

Why choose this provider?

Trimble Insurance Agency has been providing auto insurance in Delaware, Ohio, and the surrounding areas of Columbus, since the 1940s. The company offers comprehensive policies that include collision, uninsured driver, roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, medical payments, and personal injury protection. Trimble Insurance Agency insures cars and motorcycles as well as specialty vehicles, such as antiques, hot-rods, and custom built cars. The company also provides policies that include agreed-value coverage and spare-part insurance on collectible vehicles.

777 Goodale Blvd. Suite 200, Columbus, OH 43212
WebsiteLicense: 8001322

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
4.9 (18)
Google
3.3 (14)
Yelp
3.0 (2)

Why choose this provider?

GAD Insurance is an independent agency that has been serving clients in Columbus and the surrounding areas since 1928. It assists individuals in obtaining car insurance policies that protect them against various risks, including accidents, theft, and vandalism. The agency has established working relationships with more than 29 insurance companies, allowing its agents to review policies that suit the unique needs and financial situations of clients. The locally owned and operated agency is licensed to offer insurance services in 50 states.

  • Multiple Carriers

891 S James Rd, Columbus, OH 43227
WebsiteLicense: 2410

Expertise.com Rating

Why choose this provider?

Soller Insurance Agency, Inc., has been working with clients in Columbus since 1955. Its auto insurance provides financial protection to owners for vehicle damage and injuries resulting from road accidents. The policy also provides compensation for vandalism and theft. In addition, the firm has insurance products for health, homes, and farms, as well as commercial plans that cover vehicle fleets and professional liability suits. Soller Insurance Agency is a member of the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisers.

  • Multiple Carriers

470 Olde Worthington Rd, Suite 200, Westerville, OH 43082
WebsiteLicense: 1219667

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.8 (110)
Facebook
5.0 (6)

Why choose this provider?

Issam Insurance Agency is an independent brokerage catering to individuals and families in and around Columbus. It offers various risk management solutions, such as coverage for automobiles. Local car insurance includes comprehensive, personal injury protection, collision, and uninsured coverage. It also includes policies that cover bodily injuries to others and property damage. The brokerage also provides coverage for homeowners, businesses, and commercial trucks. Issam Insurance Agency employs staff who can speak English, French, and Arabic.

  • Bundling Option

111 South Main Street, Columbus, OH 43318
WebsiteLicense: 4585

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (41)
Facebook
5.0 (32)

Why choose this provider?

Comer Insurance Agency, Inc., is a locally owned and operated independent insurance company founded in 1924. Serving the people of Columbus and all of Ohio, its experienced agents can help private vehicle owners secure an insurance plan that will suit their needs and requirements. The company connects clients to various insurance companies that will give them and their vehicles coverages for liability, medical payments, and towing and labor. Comer Insurance Agency also offers life, homeowners', and business insurance.

  • Bundling Option
  • Motorcyle & ATV

221 S Hamilton Road, Columbus, OH 43213
WebsiteLicense: 811

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.9 (68)
Facebook
5.0 (11)

Why choose this provider?

Isner Insurance Assoc. Inc. is an independent agency that serves individuals and families in Columbus. This company provides auto insurance coverage for standard use and collector cars. It also covers other types of vehicles and properties including motorcycles, boats, and jet skis. Its agents work on multiple personal and commercial line insurance products through its partner carriers like Safeco, Travelers, Hartford, and Foremost. Principal agent Tom Isner, who became the company president in 1980, has decades of experience in handling insurance policies for small businesses.

  • Multiple Carriers

301 S Hamilton Rd,, Columbus, OH 43213
WebsiteLicense: 2312

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.1 (8)
Yelp
3.0 (2)

Why choose this provider?

Murray & Sons Insurance Agency is an independently-owned company that serves the Columbus metro. It offers vehicle insurance options, with coverages ranging from two-wheeled to twelve-wheeled vehicles, such as motorcycles, cars, trucks, boat and watercraft, motorsport and ATV, and RV and motorhome. Clients with classic cars are also accommodated by its agents. The agency provides insurance policy options for properties like homes, renters, and condos. It also handles business insurance, such as workers' compensation and surety bonds, as well as health and life insurance policies.

  • Multiple Carriers

991 Schrock Road, Columbus, OH 43229
WebsiteLicense: 666993

Expertise.com Rating

Why choose this provider?

Beau Burton is a State Farm insurance agent that serves individuals and families in Columbus and nearby areas. He offers auto insurance policies for new drivers, business travelers, and collectors, covering collisions, rentals, and rideshares. He provides a variety of risk management solutions for renters, homeowners, and pets. His agency also has life and health insurance options. Beau has been in the industry since 2015. He is a State Farm Senior Vice President candidate and a repeat Ambassador Travel qualifier.

  • Multiple Carriers

1620 E Broad St 103, Columbus, OH 43203
WebsiteLicense: 1007606

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.9 (36)
Facebook
4.9 (18)

Why choose this provider?

Sokol Eisenberg Insurance offers its products and services to clients in Columbus and its neighboring locations. Since 1925, its staff has been helping individuals and families protect their assets and properties, including homes and automobiles, from the risk of damage, loss, or theft. It also offers personal umbrella insurance that provides coverage against collisions, injuries, and resulting property damage. In addition, the firm provides complimentary reviews that help educate clients on their available options and identify possible risks based on audit findings.

  • Bundling Option

1275 Demorest Road, Columbus, OH 43204
WebsiteLicense: 28259

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.6 (30)
Facebook
5.0 (9)

Why choose this provider?

Matson Insurance Agency has been in operation since 1958. It has helped 3,500 individuals, families, and businesses in the Columbus area. It assists clients in finding a suitable auto insurance policy from different carriers, such as Grange, Auto-Owners, Progressive, and Burns & Wilcox. These plans provide car owners financial protection when they sustain bodily injuries and their vehicles get damaged following an accident. The company also delivers insurance for motorcycles, commercial vehicles, snowmobiles, ATVs, boats, and RVs.

  • Multiple Carriers

Compare our Top Local Car Insurance Agencies

NameExpertise RatingAddressPromotionsLearn more
Matic
585 S Front St #300, Columbus, OH 43215
Sylvia A. Garrett & Associates Agency, LLC
20 S. Third Street Suite 210, Columbus, OH 43215
Link-Hellmuth Insurance
333 N Limestone St, Springfield, OH 45503
Ray Insurance
1580 Fishinger Road, Columbus, OH 43221
Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio
1180. W. Broad St., Columbus, OH 43222
Haughn & Associates
6050 Tain Dr, Dublin, OH 43017
Town & Village Insurance Service, Inc.
2000 Henderson Rd Ste 400, Columbus, OH 43220
Heyward Group LLC
2970 McKinley Ave., Columbus, OH 43204
Solid Insurance
986 Morse Road, Columbus, OH 43229
Dressel & Evans Agency, Inc.
1527 Northwest Blvd, Columbus, OH 43212
Trimble Insurance Agency
39 S Liberty St, Delaware, OH 43015
GAD Insurance
777 Goodale Blvd. Suite 200, Columbus, OH 43212
Soller Insurance Agency, Inc.
891 S James Rd, Columbus, OH 43227
Issam Insurance Agency
470 Olde Worthington Rd, Suite 200, Westerville, OH 43082
Comer Insurance Agency, Inc.
111 South Main Street, Columbus, OH 43318
Isner Insurance Assoc. Inc.
221 S Hamilton Road, Columbus, OH 43213
Murray & Sons Insurance Agency
301 S Hamilton Rd,, Columbus, OH 43213
Beau Burton
991 Schrock Road, Columbus, OH 43229
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance
1620 E Broad St 103, Columbus, OH 43203
Matson Insurance Agency
1275 Demorest Road, Columbus, OH 43204

FAQs

  • Introduction

    A way to stay protected while on the road, car insurance offers a financial safety net should accidents occur, regardless of who's at fault. The right car insurance agency can be very valuable, providing a way to purchase an ideal level of auto insurance coverage for personal circumstances. Agencies can help customers select the most beneficial coverage options while saving money on their insurance plan. With help from a qualified agency, it's possible to feel safe and secure behind the wheel.

  • What are the minimum coverage requirements for car insurance policies in Columbus?

    Ohio has minimum requirements for bodily injury and property damage liability coverage. You must have bodily injury coverage of $50,000 per car accident and $25,000 per individual involved. Meanwhile, you must have $25,000 in property damage liability coverage for each accident. You can always choose to have more coverage than the minimum required for your Columbus car insurance policy.

  • What is the benefit of adding MedPay coverage to your car insurance policy in Columbus?

    If you have MedPay coverage, your accident-related medical expenses will be reimbursed regardless of who caused the car accident. This coverage extends to your passengers and family members at the time of the accident. It should be noted that MedPay has coverage limits and does not function like health insurance.

  • What additional coverage options for car insurance are available in Columbus?

    Aside from the required bodily injury and property damage coverage, your Columbus car insurance can include a variety of additional safeguards. Collision and extended glass coverage will cover the cost of repairing or replacing your damaged vehicle. MedPay and uninsured motorist coverage can cover your medical expenses and lost wages, especially if the at-fault driver does not have insurance. Meanwhile, comprehensive coverage pays for non-car-related damages, such as hailstorm dents or hitting a deer.

  • What happens if you drive without car insurance in Columbus?

    If Columbus police catch you driving without insurance, the Ohio BMV will issue you a Notice of Suspension. You must respond to this notice and show proof of insurance. If you cannot provide proof, your driving privileges will be suspended for up to two years, your car will be towed at your expense, and your license plate and car registration will be suspended. Following the suspension, you will be required to pay reinstatement fees of up to $650.

  • If you get in a car accident in Columbus, whose insurance policy covers your car rental expenses while your automobile is being repaired?

    You may make a liability claim against the at-fault driver's insurance company. Their insurance company should cover your rental car expenses while your car is being repaired. Please keep in mind that your rental expenses will only be covered for the reasonable time it takes to repair your vehicle. You can also file a claim against your own Columbus car insurance policy if it includes rental reimbursement coverage.

  • What is car insurance?

    Car insurance is a form of insurance that can cover damages to cars, drivers, passengers, and other property when an accident occurs. If another car crashes into a driver, or if a driver causes an accident, car insurance will pay most or all of the cost of repairs.