Best Car Insurance Agencies in Columbus

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Columbus Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 441 270 14

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Read more about our selection process

Comer Insurance Agency, Inc.

  • Motorcyle & ATV
  • Bundling Option

Comer Insurance Agency, Inc., is a locally owned and operated independent insurance company founded in 1924. Serving the people of Columbus and all of Ohio, its experienced agents can help private vehicle owners secure an insurance plan that will suit their needs and requirements. The company connects clients to various insurance companies that will give them and their vehicles coverages for liability, medical payments, and towing and labor. Comer Insurance Agency also offers life, homeowners', and business insurance.

111 South Main Street
Columbus, OH 43318


Danduran & Associates Insurance Agency, Inc.

Danduran & Associates Insurance Agency Inc. arranges auto insurance policies in the metro area around its location in Columbus, Ohio. Founded in 1975, carriers it represents include Ohio Casualty and Auto-Owners Insurance. The agency's policies are formed around the needs of its customers and can include coverage enhancements like accident forgiveness, rental reimbursement, and pet coverage. Customers can request a quote online from its website. The agency also sells insurance to homeowners and businesses.

1827 Obrien Rd
Columbus, OH 43228


Dostal & Kirk, Inc.

Dostal & Kirk Inc. is a Powell-based independent insurance agency serving Columbus, Ohio. An auto insurance specialist, it also has offices in Bucyrus, Galion, and Marion, providing its clients with flexible insurance solutions for their vehicles. Established in 2009, the agency represents many insurance providers, including Ohio Mutual and Transamerica. It works with its clients to form a policy around their needs, be it for a single vehicle, multiple vehicles, or many drivers for one vehicle.

9783 Fairway Dr Ste A
Powell, OH 43065


Hummel and Plum Insurance Agency

Since 1904, Hummel and Plum Insurance Agency has been providing personalized insurance solutions to residents of the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. While keeping in mind clients' budgets and concerns, agents create auto policies that cover liability, property damage, and personal injury protection. Comprehensive coverage is available for drivers looking to protect their vehicles against losses due to fire, theft, and hit-and-run collisions. Hummel and Plum Insurance Agency also offers life and commercial insurance.

116 W Franklin St
Circleville, OH 43113


Link-Hellmuth Insurance

Link-Hellmuth Insurance has been providing insurance services to residents of Springfield, Ohio, for over 123 years. The company's agents help insurance shoppers find customized auto insurance policies for their cars. It provides a broad range of auto coverage, including collision, rental car accident, roadside rescue, full glass, and liabilities. Link-Hellmuth Insurance also offers homeowners, rental, life, boat, and business insurance. Moreover, apartment renters may insure their belongings and get comprehensive liability coverage.

333 N Limestone St
Springfield, OH 45503


Moffatt Insurance Agency

The Moffatt Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company located in the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. Coverage specialists work with select carriers, such as Progressive and Grange Insurance, to help drivers get the right policy for a fair rate. Options include liability for property damage and bodily injuries and medical coverage with additional choices for collision and comprehensive plans that pay for all repairs and the replacement value of the vehicle for valid claims.

229 S Market St
Troy, OH 45373


Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agency, Inc.

Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agency Inc. is an independent insurance agency founded in 1932 that sells auto insurance and serves the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. Its auto insurance policies include comprehensive, liability, and collision coverage options, and the agency offers high-risk auto insurance for current customers. TFW Agency offers additional insurance products that include property and casualty insurance, loss control services, life and health insurance, self-insured programs, and bonding for professionals and businesses.

1500 Lake Shore Dr Ste 400
Columbus, OH 43204


Trimble Insurance Agency

Trimble Insurance Agency has been providing auto insurance in Delaware, Ohio, and the surrounding areas of Columbus, since the 1940s. The company offers comprehensive policies that include collision, uninsured driver, roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, medical payments, and personal injury protection. Trimble Insurance Agency insures cars and motorcycles as well as specialty vehicles, such as antiques, hot-rods, and custom built cars. The company also provides policies that include agreed-value coverage and spare-part insurance on collectible vehicles.

39 S Liberty St
Delaware, OH 43015


Wichert Insurance

Wichert Insurance is an independent agency serving clients throughout the Columbus, Ohio, metro area. It considers itself a community-based agency and it actively engages in loss control methods to help clients prevent accidents and subsequent claims. Its agents insure a variety of automobiles including classic cars, off-road vehicles, RVs, and watercrafts. Commercial auto services are available to businesses who want to managed hired/non-owned liability for employed drivers, as well as employees who utilize their own vehicles for work purposes.

400 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster, OH 43130


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: