Best Jewelers
in Rochester

Why These Jewelers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored jewelers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best jewelers in Rochester, NY.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks654720

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

ASJewelz: Gold Filled Jewelry

ASJewelz: Gold Filled Jewelry is a jewelry store in Rochester, New York. They supply necklaces, name plates, earrings, bracelets, rings, collection pieces, and more. ASJewelz: Gold Filled Jewelry provides discount coupons, and they offer a free chain with the order of 18" gold plated chain. ASJewelz: Gold Filled Jewelry also offers jewelry at marked-down prices.

Rochester, NY(585) 441-8170


Burke and Bannayan Jewelers, Inc.

Burke and Bannayan Jewelers, Inc. is a jewelry designer in Rochester, New York, established in 1985. They specialize in wedding bands, bridal jewelry, jewelry repair, and custom design. If a customer is planning on attending a wedding or special occasion, they can come in and get their rings cleaned and polished, to make them look brand new. Burke and Bannayan Jewelers, Inc. is a Better Business Bureau accredited business with an A+ rating.

Rochester, NY(585) 723-1010


Charisma Jewelers

Charisma Jewelers is a jeweler in Greece, New York. They offer the finest selection of diamond engagement rings, fine jewelry, and loose diamonds. Charisma Jewelers also supplies wedding jewelry and designer brand jewelries. They sell jewelry from around $250 and up. Charisma Jewelers is a family-owned jewelry store offering a beautiful selection, excellent service, a knowledgeable staff, and custom jewelry design.

Rochester, NY(585) 227-7700


Emerson & Oliver

Emerson & Oliver is a gift shop in Rochester, New York. After 25 years of friendship and spending nearly a decade apart living in different countries, Laura Bascomb-Werth & Mary Presutti created their lifestyle brand, Emerson & Oliver, specializing in providing jewelry, home needs, and arts and crafts. The jewelry they supply includes bracelets, Dia, Dia charms, earrings, necklaces, and rings. Each piece of jewelry is designed or handmade by Emerson & Oliver.

Rochester, NY(585) 461-8347


Forsythe Jewelers

Forsythe Jewelers is a jewelry store in Pittsford, New York, established in 1927. The jewelry they offer includes diamond rings, fashion diamond rings, Jewelry Rings, Diamond Earrings, Diamond Necklaces, Necklaces, Diamond Pendants, and more. Their services include custom design/counter sketch, jewelry brokering, two certified gemologists in-house, free jewelry cleaning, and lectures. Forsythe Jewelers is a member of the American Gem Society.

Pittsford, NY(877) 436-5954


Get Personal Designer Jewelry

Get Personal Designer Jewelry is a jewelry designer in Rochester, New York. They sell pendants, sliders, earrings, and bracelets. Get Personal Designer Jewelry offers an exciting line of fashionable jewelry designs, and are renowned for their creative use of genuine Swarovski Austrian crystals in both gold and platinum finish settings. Get Personal Designer Jewelry, the "jewelry that makes a statement."

Rochester, NY(585) 426-9079


Gold 4 Cash

Gold 4 Cash is a pawn shop in Rochester, New York. They specialize in purchasing gold, silver, coins, estate jewelry, watches, sports memorabilia, and electronics, as well as all diamonds from the best, most flawless D color to O+ colored, broken stones in poor condition. Their inventory includes a wide variety of quality products such as gold, silver, coins, watches, sports memorabilia, electronics, high-end china, and crystal. Their certified professionals have a keen attention to detail.

Rochester, NY(585) 415-1514


Heritage Fine Jewelers

Heritage Fine Jewelers is a jeweler in Rochester, New York, established in 1969. They carry different collections of designer jewelry, as well as supplying engagement rings, pendants, bracelets, Heritage II watches, rings, wholesale loose diamonds, and earrings. Heritage Fine Jewelers is associated with GIA, and are an IJO Master Jeweler.

Rochester, NY(585) 225-7280


J. William Jewelers

J. William Jewelers Lab is a jeweler in Spencerport, New York. John W. McGrath, the owner of J. William Jewelers, has 30 years of experience in the jewelry industry. The products they offer include fine gold, brilliant diamonds, engagement rings, gemstones, wedding bands, sterling silver, quality watches, and charms and chain. All of their jewelry repairs and appraisals are performed on premise, and they also offer complimentary jewelry cleaning and inspection. J. William Jewelers was the recipient of the Spencerport Chamber of Commerce Business of the Year award for 2007.

Spencerport, NY(585) 349-8300


Jerry's Jewelers

Jerry's Jewelers is a jewelry store in Rochester, New York, family owned since 1962. Jerry's Jewelers has been providing diamonds, designs, and quality repairs for generations. The fashion jewelry they offer includes rings, earrings, necklaces, bracelets, and pendants. Jerry's Jewelers has earned a sterling reputation throughout the years by offering high-quality jewelry, professional repairs, and honest value.

Rochester, NY(585) 544-2090


Jewelry Clinic

Jewelry Clinic is a jewelry repair company in Rochester, New York, established in 1984. Their services include jewelry repair, watch repair and reconstruction, and restoration. They also offer custom creations and a full choice of metals. Jewelry Clinic is proud to be downtown Rochester's only full-service jewelry store.

Rochester, NY(585) 232-5920


Jewelry Lab

Jewelry Lab is a jeweler in Rochester, New York. Their products and services include a beautiful selection of jewelry pieces, repair and restoration, and polishing and cleaning. Their jewelry brokers have the perfect gifts for mother’s day, birthdays, graduations and more. Jewelry Lab provides their customers with a professional and trusted jewelry brokers’ service.

Rochester, NY(585) 227-8940


JF Jones Jewelers Inc.

JF Jones Jewelers Inc. is a jeweler in Rochester, New York, serving customers since 1928. JF Jones Jewelers Inc. specializes in custom jewelry, jewelry collections, and all-inclusive engagement rings. They are a Better Business Bureau accredited business with an A+ rating. Financing is available with no interest for 6 months.

Rochester, NY(585) 865-6604


Lee Gorfine Jewelers

Lee Gorfine Jewelers Lab is a jeweler in Rochester, New York. Their services include custom designing, engagement and wedding, buying of gold and silver, estate jewelry, repairs and cleaning, and appraisals. All work is done on their premises. Lee Gorfine Jewelers Lab provides excellent prices and reliable workmanship.

Rochester, NY(585) 256-1249


People's Pottery

People's Pottery is a boutique jewelry store in Rochester, New York. The collections they offer include Pandora, Mi Moneda, Ti Sento, Milano, Kiss & Dream Diamonds, Kiss & Dream Rings, TwirlyGirl Dresses®, and Lauren G. Adams. Their attentive service, customized offerings, and impressive lines mean that their customers will find the perfect gift for “her, him, and home” to present in perfect confidence.

Rochester, NY(585) 271-2740


Profetta Jewelers

Profetta Jewelers is a jewelry store in Rochester, New York, established in 1936 by Sam Profetta. The jewelry they offer includes bridal sets, engagement rings, diamond wedding bands, fashion rings, gemstone rings, earrings, pendants, and bracelets. Profetta Jewelers also provides Benchmark Wedding Bands and Jewels by Irina. Their goal is to continue to offer the same quality and service that they have been providing for the past 80 years.

Rochester, NY(585) 385-2150


Rainmaker Designs

Rainmaker Designs is a jewelry store in Shortsville, New York. It is the collaborative work of two artists, Antoinette Magaletta and Dan McClure. Antoinette is an enamellist and Dan works in both wood and metal. They are employed by ARTISANworks in Rochester, NY and exhibit their work locally in art shows. They are happy to create custom made jewelry and wall hangings.

Shortsville, NY(585) 764-4870


Richards & West Jewelers

Richards & West Jewelers is a jewelry designer in East Rochester, New York, established in 1982. The jewelry they offer includes engagement rings, wedding bands, bracelets, earrings, necklaces, and women's rings. With passion, dedication and a constant pursuit of excellence, they strive to enrich the lives of their customers with distinctive pieces of matchless beauty to be treasured for generations to come.

East Rochester, NY(585) 461-3022


Rochester Pawn & Gold

Rochester Pawn & Gold is a pawn shop in Rochester, New York. They accept pawns such as books, media items, diamonds, electronics, jewelry, laptops, watches, and tools. They buy/sell/loan/accept all types of precious metals and jewelry. From gold, silver, platinum and palladium, whether it is broken, damaged or unwanted, Rochester Pawn & Gold will pay their customers top dollar.

Rochester, NY(585) 319-3916


Stefan Otter Fine Art Jewelers

Stefan Otter Fine Art Jewelers is a jewelry store in Rochester, New York, creating jewelry with joy and passion since 1989. They are proud to feature their signature collection, shimmering stones, opulent opals, swirls and spirals, natural beauty, and fancy pearls. Stefan Otter Fine Art Jewelers pride themselves on offering custom designs and expert repairs and remodeling.

Rochester, NY(585) 641-0798


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: