Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Rochester

2021

We scored 127 Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Rochester, NY and Picked the Top 10

Here are the Picks:

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Rochester Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Our Selection Criteria:

1. Availability

Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.
2. Qualifications

Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.
3. Reputation

A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.
4. Experience

Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.
5. Professionalism

Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Read more about our selection process

Last Updated: April 28, 2021

Multiple Policy Types
Flood
Condos

Bailey Place Insurance is a homeowners insurance agency in Rochester. It consults clients to find out their needs and offers them homeowners insurance policies that provide protection in case clients lose their homes or become victims of burglary or vandalism. Its policies can cover replacement costs of entire dwellings as well as any medical or living costs following disasters. Bailey Place Insurance provides clients with a full range of services for business insurance needs as well.

Click to Call

2280 East Avenue
Rochester, NY 14610

Website Facebook Instagram

Leave Feedback

(607) 218-6502 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Multiple Carriers

Crowley Insurance Agency sells homeowners insurance policies and operates as an independent agency. It connects clients with associated carriers to sell them policies that include coverage for dwellings, personal items, and additional properties. Loss of use and medical expense coverage is offered as well. Crowley Insurance Agency also advises clients on family and personal liability coverage to protect them against lawsuits if visitors are hurt on their grounds. Scheduled personal property coverage is available for jewelry and other valuable items.

Click to Call

Rochester, NY

Website Facebook Twitter Instagram

Leave Feedback

(315) 437-2983 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Personal Property Insurance
Flood
Fire

Eastern Shore Associates Insurance Agency sells homeowners insurance policies that cover dwelling damage, material replacement costs, and costs associated with living outside of damaged homes. Agents are available to explain policy options to clients and help them select from offered quotes. They also advise on personal liability coverage and can assess the likelihood of guest injury scenarios. Additional coverage options are available for high-value items, scenarios involving identity theft, and water back-up or sump-related issues.

Click to Call

3720 Main Street
Walworth, NY 14568

Website Facebook Twitter

Leave Feedback

(800) 836-3324 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Personal Property Insurance
Renter's Insurance

Haylor, Freyer, & Coon Inc. is a homeowners insurance agency near Rochester. It sells policies that offer comprehensive coverage to protect clients from financial losses and lawsuits associated with their properties, land, and personal belongings. Clients can cover their primary homes as well as additional structures, and additional living expenses can be covered to protect clients when they're displaced by disasters. Haylor, Freyer, & Coon Inc. also offers insurance products for cars as well as motorcycles.

Click to Call

1159 Pittsford-Victor Road
Pittsford, NY 14534

Website Facebook Twitter

Leave Feedback

(585) 385-6600 Website

Multiple Policy Types

Jim Corley, State Farm Insurance Agent, provides homeowners insurance services to clients in the Rochester metro area. This office and its founder have served clients since 2004 and help people to cover their property liabilities by selling them insurance plans that protect against losses caused by property damage or guest injuries. This particular office works with many newer homeowners and helps them to avoid a variety of insurance pitfalls. Auto insurance is available as well.

Click to Call

Rochester, NY

Website Facebook Twitter

Leave Feedback

(716) 322-1239 Website

Flood
Condos

Lawley is a homeowners insurance agency in Rochester offering several policy options to potential clients. Its agents act as consultants for clients and advise them on their insurance options while evaluating their unique needs. This agency sells homeowners insurance policies that cover repair and replacement costs for any structural or external damage caused to properties. Its policies can also shield clients from financial liability if they're sued for any guest injuries on their properties.

Click to Call

30 Union Street North
Rochester, NY 14607

Website Facebook Twitter

Leave Feedback

(585) 454-1600 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Personal Property Insurance

Salanger & Hayward Insurance sells homeowners Insurance policies and can assist customers with any questions or concerns they have concerning coverage options. It offers quotes to insure housing structures themselves as well as liabilities connected to owning land. Agents are available to consult clients about policies and handle any claims that they make if their properties do experience damage. Salanger & Hayward Insurance also sells car insurance, life insurance, and business insurance policies.

Click to Call

Rochester, NY

Website Facebook

Leave Feedback

(315) 463-9225 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Multiple Carriers
Renter's Insurance

The Getzoni Agency Inc. offers comprehensive homeowners insurance services to clients in the Rochester metro area. Its agents provide information to clients who are shopping for insurance and evaluates their circumstances to advise them on the types of coverage they need and in what amounts. This agency has over 40 years of experience and can consult clients on a wide range of coverage types for dwellings, personal property, or any other kinds of personal liability incurred by property owners.

Click to Call

Rochester, NY

Website Facebook Twitter Instagram

Leave Feedback

(716) 631-0363 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Fire

Vanner Insurance Agency offers homeowners insurance to clients and can assist them as they shop for quotes and select policies that fit their lives. Policies are available to cover incidents such as fire, weather damage, vandalism, or accidental damage. Clients can also insure personal items such as jewelry or pieces of fine art. Vanner Insurance Agency consults clients on personal injury protection to cover them in case guests file suit after being hurt on their properties.

Click to Call

Rochester, NY

Website Facebook

Leave Feedback

(716) 688-8888 Website

Multiple Policy Types
Personal Property Insurance

Willoughby Insurance offers coverage for single-family homes and condominiums, and it assists clients as they attempt to purchase policies. It offers a multitude of policy options so that clients can purchase complete coverage for their homes, their possessions, and other structures on their properties. Willoughby Insurance also provides renters insurance options so that clients can cover a wider range of needs. Auto insurance and motorcycle insurance policies are available as well.

Click to Call

Rochester, NY

Website Facebook Twitter

Leave Feedback

(716) 885-8100 Website