Best Jewelers
in Buffalo

Why These Jewelers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored jewelers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best jewelers in Buffalo, NY.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks785419

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Airport Plaza Jewelers

Airport Plaza Jewelers is one of New York's most recognized jewelry stores. They are known for selling watches, gold, silver, and diamond pieces. With various designs for engagement rings, bracelets, necklaces, and other pieces; buyers will find what they are looking for. They also offer jewelry repairs. Customers can check out their store and website for more information.

Cheektowaga, NY(716) 632-6509


Aurum Jewelers

Aurum Jewelers has been Buffalo's go-to jewelry store since the 1960s. They deliver a broad range of jewelry designs at ranges that go from budget to extravagant and are dedicated to creating or finding the perfect design to suit each and every client. They make personalized pieces and also have an extensive collection of timeless, handcrafted pieces of jewelry such as watches, bracelets, rings, and necklaces. Interested clients can schedule an appointment with their store representatives.

Buffalo, NY(716) 886-1300


Barbara Oliver Jewelry

Barbara Oliver Jewelry is led by its founder, Barbara Oliver, who is a graduate, professional gemologist. Aside from selling beautiful engagement rings, wedding bands, necklaces, and other pieces of jewelry, Barbara Oliver herself offers consultations for those who want to buy lasting jewelry for memorable life events. They also provide appraisals as well as jewelry repairs.

Williamsville, NY(716) 204-1297


Ben Garelick Jewelers

For people looking for the perfect engagement ring, or beautiful gifts to give their loved ones, Ben Garelick Jewelers has a huge collection of options. The jeweler makes wedding bands, engagement rings, and other jewelry from diamond and other select materials and also offers professional jewelry repair services. For those with a limited budget, Ben Garelick Jewelers offers layaway plans and other easy financing options.

Williamsville, NY(716) 631-1584


Birzon Jewelers

Birzon Jewelers has been providing New Yorkers with gorgeous jewelry since 1952 when brothers Sidney and Gerald Birzon started the shop. Since then, the shop has sold thousands of beautiful jewelry creations around the United States. They make engagement rings, wedding rings, and other jewelry that can be given as a loving gift that can be passed on for generations.

Tonawanda, NY(716) 856-8255


Colosseum Jewelry

Colosseum Jewelry is a New York-based jewelry store established in 2005. The store offers timeless and one-of-a-kind pieces that can be given as a memorable, unique gift. They strive to provide beautiful jewelry pieces that are less expensive than their competitors, without compromising quality. Colosseum Jewelry's varied collection includes gold bracelets, diamond rings, and stylish pendants. Beyond the shop's jewelry selection, Colosseum also buys, sells, and appraises gold.

Buffalo, NY(716) 684-8384


Crinzi & Gullo Jewelers

Crinzi & Gullo Jewelers has been providing high-quality jewelry to New York residents since 1945 and strives to be the community's jeweler of choice. Aside from their custom-made pieces, Crinzi & Gullo Jewelers also offers an extensive collection from other jewelry vendors. They also repair watches, wedding bands, engagement rings, and other pieces of jewelry. Crinzi & Gullo Jewelers is GIA and IJO certified.

Orchard Park, NY(716) 662-8260


Firth Jewelers

Firth Jewelers is a jewelry store in Niagara Falls that offers fine jewelry to last a lifetime. Because diamonds last forever, they want their customers to know more about the products they offer. Their store professionals provide expert assistance to customers who want to find their perfect fit. Customers can compare rates and designs and save on deals. Firth Jewelers also provides free jewelry cleaning services for every diamond purchase.

Niagara Falls, NY(716) 297-2210


Flatwearable Artisan Jewelry

Flatwearable Artisan Jewelry was founded in 2013. Their professional team specializes in handcrafted jewelry, silverware, and offer a wide range of designs to meet each customer's needs. Their retail store in Seneca is open to serve customers, and those who do not live in the area can opt to purchase their pieces through their online store, where they also provide coupons, specials, and other discounts.

West Seneca, NY(716) 675-0585


Gem Design Jewelers

Gem Design Jewelers specializes in creating lasting and beautiful custom-made jewelry. Every piece they make is handcrafted on location, and professional jewelry repairs are often completed while customers wait. The store strives to provide the highest quality jewelry at competitive rates. Customers can browse through their website to learn more about their products and other services.

Buffalo, NY(716) 447-0217


Hertel Jewelers

Hertel Jewelers is Buffalo, New York's go-to jewelry store. They offer a collection of beautiful pieces of jewelry as well as repair services for customers who want to receive the highest quality craftsmanship. Their other services include jewelry appraisal, polishing and cleaning, ring sizing, and antique restoration. They also buy and sell coins, gold, silver, and diamonds. The store is open, and services are available from Monday to Saturday.

Buffalo, NY(716) 875-2200


Jewelry by Geno

Jewelry by Geno is a family-owned jewelry store that has been serving New York locals since 1988. They specialize in creating custom jewelry pieces and repairs, with all work done on-site to ensure customer satisfaction. For those looking to buy wedding bands and engagement rings, their friendly staff is happy to take customers through a wide selection of designs. Jewelry by Geno also offers convenient layaway payment plans.

Depew, NY(716) 656-0515


Korona Jewelry

Korona Jewelry has been providing its customers with the highest quality of exceptional pieces of jewelry since 1900. Their services include jewelry repairs, custom work, re-mounts, stone setting, pearl and bead stringing, and more. Their store is available from Tuesdays to Saturdays for visits and consultations. Interested clients can contact their staff for more information.

Buffalo, NY(716) 834-4755


Mills Jewelers

For people looking for the perfect engagement ring, or beautiful gifts to give their loved ones, Ben Garelick Jewelers has a huge collection of options. The jeweler makes wedding bands, engagement rings, and other jewelry from diamond and other select materials and also offers professional jewelry repair services. For those with a limited budget, Ben Garelick Jewelers offers layaway plans and other easy financing options.

Lockport, NY(716) 433-6456


Minnuto Jewelers

Minnuto Jewelers is a locally-operated and independent jewelry store in Cheektowaga, New York. Just some of their high-quality services include jewelry appraisals, custom design, and repairs. Customers can look through an exquisite collection of wedding bands, engagement rings, watches, and men's jewelry. Minnuto Jewelers specializes in diamond jewelry pieces as well as gold-dipped roses, which are specially grown and handpicked, then preserved in 24k gold.

Cheektowaga, NY(716) 897-6275


S & E Jewelers

S & E Jewelers is a trusted jewelry store in Western New York. With over 68 years in the business, they aim to be the best choice for customers based on quality, value, and personal service. They offer an extensive range of different pieces including diamonds, wedding bands, watches, and other luxurious jewelry. They offer layaway payment schemes as well. Interested buyers can check out their website for promotions and other specials.

Amherst, NY(716) 832-1595


Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry Inc.

Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry Inc. is located in Williamsville, New York, and offers beautiful custom jewelry and vintage collections that perfectly suit a wide variety of occasions. Each unique piece is inspected by a professional gemologist with over two decades of experience. For their clients' convenience, Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry accepts major credit cards and also offers gift cards.

Williamsville, NY(716) 633-3738


Scanlon Jewelers

Scanlon Jewelers has been providing Buffalo residents with the finest jewelry for over three decades. Founded by Todd Scanlon, the team is knowledgeable in jewelry design, repair, and sales, to help customers find the perfect piece of jewelry for any occasion. They make anniversary jewelry, necklaces, and bracelets, as well as watches. They also offer pre-owned pieces of jewelry for sale. Interested customers can check out their store for other specials.

Williamsville, NY(716) 633-6362


The Jeweler's Studio

The Jeweler's Studio, located at Orchard Park in New York, offers highly-styled and elegant jewelry pieces that stand the test of time. The store's owners, Dave and Rachel Cabin, are committed to providing their customers with quality services. All work is done in their store, and they offer same-day repairs while customers wait. Customers can check out their store or contact them for more information on their services.

Orchard Park, NY(716) 662-8228


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: