Best Car Insurance Agencies in St. Louis

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored St. Louis Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 215 135 15

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

A. Jay Meier & Associates

Founded in 1972, A. Jay Meier & Associates is an independent insurance agency located in Saint Louis, Montana. The company offers owned policies for individuals or families that own a vehicle and unowned coverage for clients that don't own a car and need insurance. Other auto options include motorcycles, boats, classic car and antique policies, and protection plans for commercial use vehicles. A. Jay Meier & Associates also provides home, condo, renters, and personal umbrella policies.

2115 S Brentwood Blvd
Saint Louis, MO 63144


Clayton-Hanley Insurance Service, Inc.

Clayton-Hanley Insurance Service Inc. is a local independent insurance broker serving the St. Louis, Missouri, area. The company offers liability, no-fault, collision and comprehensive auto insurance, working with major insurance providers to help clients find affordable rates on auto coverage required by Missouri law. Customers can request an auto insurance quote on the company website. Clayton-Hanley Insurance also offers home, business, and life insurance. Agents are licensed to write policies in Missouri and Illinois.

9545 Yuma Dr
Saint Louis, MO 63123


Crestwood Insurance Agency

Crestwood Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency based in St. Louis, Missouri, and serves the states of Illinois and Texas as well. With more than 25 years of service in the community, the agency works with a range of major firms that specialize in automobile insurance. Experienced agents help clients select from a range of comprehensive auto insurance packages for accident, liability, and passenger injury coverage. Crestwood Insurance Agency also provides customized business, personal, life, and homeowners insurance policies.

9800 Watson Rd Ste 4
Saint Louis, MO 63126


Goetz Insurance Agency LLC

Goetz Insurance Agency LLC, founded in 2006, provides clients in the St. Louis, Missouri and Illinois areas with comparative auto insurance quotes from a variety of insurers to help them receive appropriate levels of coverage. In addition to automobiles, Goetz Insurance Agency writes policies for motorcycles and scooters, RVs, classic cars, and watercraft. Progressive, Allied, and Travelers are just a few of the insurers Goetz works with; these three offer clients one-stop services on personal and commercial auto insurance policies.

4586 Telegraph Rd
Saint Louis, MO 63129


Lewis & Clark Insurance Agency Inc.

Located in Wood River, Illinois, Lewis & Clark Insurance Agency Inc. has more than five decades of experience serving clients throughout the Saint Louis metro area. The agency's most robust auto policies include property damage, comprehensive, liability, and uninsured motorist coverage. Partnerships with national carriers such as Hagerty and Progressive enable the agency to offer auto insurance for all types of vehicles and drivers, including classic cars and high-risk clients requiring SR22s. Lewis & Clark also offers homeowners and business insurance.

160 E Ferguson Ave
Wood River, IL 62095


Mid States Agencies

Founded in 1933, Mid States Insurance Agency is a full-service independent insurance agency located in Saint Louis, Missouri, with three locations in St. Louis and a fourth office in Shreveport, Louisiana. Auto coverage representatives work with several carriers to offer drivers the right amount of insurance to cover their risk at competitive rates. Options include property, liability, and medical coverage, with additional choices for collision and comprehensive policies that pay for full repairs or replacement following a claim.

9201 Watson Rd Ste 100
Saint Louis, MO 63126


Missouri General Insurance Agency

Founded in 1981, the Missouri General Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company located in Saint Louis, Missouri. Auto coverage specialists work with several trusted carriers, such as Progressive, State Auto, and Liberty Mutual, to help drivers get the best coverage at a competitive rate. Missouri General Insurance Agency offers policies to match clients' lifestyles and meets the state's minimum requirements. Other protection plans are available for homes, health, and businesses.

1227 Fern Ridge Pkwy
Saint Louis, MO 63141


O'Shea-Ward Insurance Group

O'Shea-Ward Insurance Group serves clients in the Saint Louis, Missouri, metro area, offering auto insurance policies for coverage of repair or replacement, personal injury, and liability. Besides common vehicles, this agency also handles policies for antique and classic cars, high-value luxury vehicles, and boats. It offers businesses large-scale policies for commercial fleets of cars and trucks. Other practice areas include insurance for homes, businesses, and personal concerns including property, health and life insurance.

12015 Manchester Rd Ste 115
Saint Louis, MO 63131


Partners Insurance Agency

Partners Insurance Agency is one of several independent insurance agencies and a member of the National Independent Insurance Agents Association providing auto insurance services to clients in the Saint Louis, Missouri, metro area. This agency works with multiple providers, allowing customers to compare rates from several different underwriters within the same category. It typically structures policies to cover property damage, personal injury, and liability related to car accidents, along with optional coverage areas. Partners Insurance Agency also covers teenage drivers.

131 N Bellwood Dr Ste D
East Alton, IL 62024


Powers Insurance & Risk Management

Powers Insurance & Risk Management is a family-owned and operated business serving clients in the Saint Louis, Missouri, metro area. It provides consultation and brokerage services for auto insurance policies which consist of coverage for property damage and personal injury along with both mandated and optional liability coverage areas. This agency handles insurance for a variety of vehicles including luxury automobiles, motorcycles, recreational sport vehicles, and watercrafts. Home and business insurance services are also available.

6825 Clayton Ave
Saint Louis, MO 63139


The Charles L. Crane Agency

The Charles L. Crane Agency was established in 1885 and is an independent insurance agency located in St. Louis, Missouri. It offers its clients comprehensive auto insurance and utilizes innovative technology to reliably exceed customer expectations in the event of a collision, hit-and-run, or incident with an uninsured driver. Its services include additional protection with claims consulting, quality control, and risk management consulting services. Crane's brokers and clients work together to find the policies and products that best fit their needs.

100 N Broadway Ste 900
Saint Louis, MO 63102


Webb Insurance

Located in Saint Charles, Missouri, Webb Insurance is a full-service insurance agency founded in 1979 that sells auto insurance throughout the Saint Louis metro area. Webb Insurance provides auto coverage that includes protection against liability as well as collision and comprehensive coverage, including discounts for defensive driving courses, having home insurance through the same carrier, good grades, age milestones, mature discounts, and accident-free driving histories. As an independent insurance agency, it offers commercial and personal insurance products through reputable carriers.

571 Jefferson St
Saint Charles, MO 63301


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: