Last updated:

Best Wedding Cake Bakers in Madison, WI

Our Recommended Top 7

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Madison Wedding Cake Bakers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.



7Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.


featured provider = Featured Provider

Fitchburg, WI 53711 Rating

Review Sources

4.5 (223)
4.5 (222)
3.5 (84)

Why choose this provider?

The Rolling Pin Bake Shop is a Fitchburg bakery that was founded in 2002. The bakery offers a wide range of products such as breads, cakes, cheesecakes, cookies, cupcakes, pastries, pies, and tarts. The bakery also includes a café and serves breakfast, lunch, fresh soups, and specials. The Rolling Pin Bake Shop also offers custom-made wedding cakes and dessert buffets with a large number of fillings, flavors, and icings available.

Madison, WI 53704 Rating

Review Sources

4.0 (272)
4.5 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Daisy Café & Cupcakery is a Madison bakery that also provides services for on-site private events such as luncheons, business meetings, bridal showers, baby showers, family gatherings, and parties. The bakery has various offerings and specials for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Daisy Café & Cupcakery also provides gourmet cupcakes for weddings, bridal showers, graduations, baby showers, office parties, and more.

Middleton, WI 53562 Rating

Review Sources

4.6 (230)
4.6 (200)
4.0 (49)

Why choose this provider?

Clasen’s European Bakery is a Middleton bakery that was founded in 1959. The bakery offers a wide range of products such as breads and rolls, pastries, coffee cakes, quiche, cookies, tortes and desserts, quick breads and pound cakes, and more. Clasen’s European Bakery also offers custom wedding cakes with numerous flavors, icing, and fillings available.

Middleton, WI 53562 Rating

Review Sources

4.7 (489)
4.9 (179)
4.5 (143)

Why choose this provider?

Bloom Bake Shop is a Middleton bakery that was founded by owner Annemarie. The bakery offers a wide range of items such as cinnamon rolls, doughnuts, cupcakes, bars and brownies, cookies, pop tarts, and whoopie pies. The bakery also offers custom cake services with a large selection of flavors available. Bloom Bake Shop provides catering services for various events as well as wedding cakes, dessert tables, groom’s cakes, and more for weddings.

Verona, WI 53593 Rating

Review Sources

5.0 (25)

Why choose this provider?

Craig’s Cake Shop is a Verona bakery that was founded in 2000. The bakery specializes in wedding cakes as well as cakes for all occasions such as birthdays, celebrations, and more. The bakery provides custom made cakes with a wide variety of flavors, frostings, icings, and cake toppings available. In addition to wedding cakes, Craig’s Cake Shop also offers cupcakes, whoopie cookies, mini cakes, cake parfaits, and cake top cookies.

Sun Prairie, WI 53590 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Market Street Catering is a Sun Prairie catering company that specializes in wedding catering. The company provides catering services for weddings, breakfast and brunch, corporate events, and various occasions such as births, baptisms, communions, bar and bat mitzvahs, graduations, appreciations, retirements, and funerals. The company also works with Carl’s Cakes in order to provide custom-made wedding cakes throughout the Madison area.

Madison, WI 53703 Rating

Review Sources

4.5 (283)
4.8 (79)

Why choose this provider?

Madison Sourdough is a Madison bakery that operates a café and a mill as well. The bakery provides a wide range of breads and pastries. The bakery also operates a patisseries offering a full range of French styled desserts such as cakes, tarts, confections, sorbet, beer and wine, teas, macarons, and wedding cakes.

Compare our Top Wedding Cake Bakers

NameExpertise RatingAddressPromotionsLearn more
The Rolling Pin Bake Shop
Fitchburg, WI 53711
Daisy Café & Cupcakery
Madison, WI 53704
Clasen’s European Bakery
Middleton, WI 53562
Bloom Bake Shop
Middleton, WI 53562
Craig’s Cake Shop
Verona, WI 53593
Market Street Catering
Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Madison Sourdough
Madison, WI 53703


  • Introduction

    A wedding cake is a traditional dessert served at wedding receptions following ceremonies. In Ancient Rome, wedding cakes served as a symbolic centerpiece for the bride and groom, and they consisted of spiced bread buns.

    Today's wedding cakes are quite different but still symbolize a bride and groom's love for one another. Traditional cakes feature three tiers, and the most common cake flavor is vanilla (white cake) with buttercream frosting.

    In addition to traditional buttercream, custom cake toppings, icing, and fillings include fondant, mascarpone, berries, and even crushed rock candy. A wedding cake is one of the most important aspects of any wedding, as it serves as the main dessert for guests, and it's often the first thing guests see when entering the reception area.
  • What is the best wedding cake?

    There are many different types of wedding cakes with various flavors, designs, and icing options, so the best wedding cake comes down to personal taste. Some of the most popular wedding cake flavors include vanilla cake with buttercream, red velvet, vanilla cake with blackberries and sugar flowers, and pumpkin spice with cinnamon fondant.

  • How much should a wedding cake cost?

    Wedding cakes can cost anywhere between $75 and $1,500. The price of a wedding cake is determined by size, ingredients, specialty toppings, and cake decorations, so specific prices can deviate from the average based on your needs. 

  • How much wedding cake should I order?

    The size and quantity of wedding cake you should order depend on how many guests will be attending your wedding. A standard three-tier cake serves between 50 and 100 guests, and a quarter sheet cake provides 54 servings. A half sheet cake serves 108 single slices.

  • What are options for wedding cake flavors?

    There are many options for wedding cake flavors, and cakes can also be customized with nontraditional flavors. Common options include vanilla with buttercream frosting, red velvet with white buttercream frosting, chocolate and German chocolate, and marble cake. Less traditional options include lemon, carrot, and banana.

  • What is the traditional wedding cake flavor?

    The most common flavor of a traditional wedding cake is vanilla cake with buttercream frosting. However, chocolate is also considered traditional, especially for groom's cakes. German chocolate, red velvet, and champagne flavored cakes are also popular and fall into the traditional category.

  • How many layers should a wedding cake have?

    Traditional wedding cakes generally have three separate tiers, but cakes can be customized to meet the visions of the bride and groom. Each tier has its own significance. The top tier is to be saved by the bride and groom and eaten on the first wedding anniversary, and the bottom tier is to be served at the reception. The middle tier is distributed to guests after the wedding.