Expertise.com Homepage

2024

Last updated:

Best Renter's Insurance Companies in Madison, WI

Our Recommended Top 14

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Madison Renter's Insurance Companies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

98Reviewed

64Curated

14Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.

Providers

featured provider = Featured Provider

505 Cottage Grove Road, Madison, WI 53716
WebsiteLicense: 8444444

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (8)
Google
5.0 (5)

Why choose this provider?

Gary Ellis Insurance is an independent insurance agency that serves clients in Madison. Gary Ellis started his career in the insurance industry working for a carrier in 2005. He has since become an independent agent, representing several carriers to give clients more options. His services include life, health, home, and car insurance. Gary also provides policies for condo and renters' insurance. Business insurance is also available, with policies for general liability, workers' compensation, and business interruption.

  • Multiple Policy Types

715 W. Main St, Ste B, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
WebsiteLicense: 6493269

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.9 (73)
Facebook
4.9 (38)
Yelp
4.5 (2)

Why choose this provider?

Homewood Insurance is a Madison-based agency that caters to individuals and businesses in and around the metro. It provides home and renters' insurance products that give liability coverages for personal properties, such as appliances, electronics, jewelry, furniture, and art. Other policies include auto, motorcycle, condo, RV, ATV, and boat and watercraft insurance. Homewood Insurance has been in the industry for over 25 years. It is a member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin and Couri Insurance Associates.

  • Multiple Policy Types

6405 Century Avenue, Middleton, WI 53562
WebsiteLicense: 361825

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (391)
Yelp
2.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Action Insurance Agency offers insurance options for renters of a house or an apartment in Madison and the rest of the state. It offers renters' insurance coverages that include financial protection for the clients and their possessions in case of theft or accidents. As an independent insurance agency, the team represents several insurance carriers in the industry. These carriers include Progressive, Foremost, Dairyland, Kemper, and Bristol West Insurance Group. Moreover, the company also offers other insurance policies such as life, auto, and personal insurance.

  • Multiple Carriers

Atwood Avenue, Madison, WI 53704
WebsiteLicense: 3000763178

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (67)
Facebook
5.0 (6)
Yelp
5.0 (2)

Why choose this provider?

Prairie Land Insurance Agency is a family-owned company located in Madison. The full-service brokerage offers a number of products, including renters', home, vacant lot, and cottage insurance. With access to policies from multiple providers like Progressive, Allstate, and Foremost Insurance Group, the agents can also furnish boat, motorcycle, and car protection plans. Prairie Land Insurance Agency was founded by Ron Lovaas. His daughter Linda Kraus joined the company in 1997, and his grandson James Gayton joined a year later.

  • Multiple Carriers
  • Multiple Policy Types

14 Ellis Potter Ct, Madison, WI 53711
WebsiteLicense: 3000992394

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (107)

Why choose this provider?

C4 Insurance is an independent agency that serves individuals, families, and businesses in Madison and nearby areas. It offers renters' insurance policies, conducting assessments for the needs and risks of each client. The agency provides life, long-term, and disability coverage, as well as plans for personal belongings. It assists businesses in acquiring general liability and commercial property protection. C4 Insurance is headed by Jason Stendalen, a Certified Insurance Counselor who has been in the industry since 2004. Jason works with the National REIA.

  • Multiple Policy Types

3565 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53705
WebsiteLicense: 17298096

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.9 (70)
Facebook
5.0 (14)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Meg Cano-Schuman serves clients in Madison and its surrounding areas who looking for suitable risk protection plans. She has been an affiliate of State Farm since 2013. Her agency offers the carrier's line of insurance products, including renters' policies. She and her two-member team abide by personalized service, working to understand the present circumstances of clients to provide them with indemnity plans tailored to their needs. They also cater to clients looking for pet, life, or health policies, as well as banking products.

  • Multiple Policy Types

2605 Monroe Street, Madison, WI 53711
WebsiteLicense: 2518291

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.8 (30)
Facebook
5.0 (6)
Yelp
1.0 (4)

Why choose this provider?

Aaron Perry is a State Farm insurance agent who provides individuals, businesses, and families in Madison with insurance solutions. His goal is to serve as a go-to place for insurance and savings assistance, offering comprehensive financing options through this process. Perry assists clients in securing policies such as life, home, auto, renters' and business insurance. He also has a team of associates who handles specific policy categories. Perry has been part of the insurance agency since 2009.

  • Multiple Policy Types

6602 University Avenue, Middleton, WI 53562
WebsiteLicense: 9571111

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (16)

Why choose this provider?

Compliance Insurance is a family-owned and family-operated agency that serves the residents and businesses of Madison. The company partners with multiple insurance carriers to offer a selection of insurance products, including homeowners' and renters' insurance. Its agents educate clients about their policy options, including high-risk auto, mobile home, travel trailer, or personal watercraft insurance policies. Compliance Insurance has been in service since 1988. With five decades of collective insurance experience, Mike Wilson and his daughter, Heather, bought the agency in 2007.

  • Multiple Carriers
  • Multiple Policy Types

402 Gammon Place, Suite 304, Madison, WI 53719
WebsiteLicense: 6927392

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.9 (7)

Why choose this provider?

Kevin Lease is a State Farm insurance agent who serves individuals, families, and businesses in Madison and neighboring areas. Since 2000, he has been providing renters' insurance for clients looking to protect their personal belongings—like furniture, TVs, bicycles, clothing, and electronic gadgets—in their apartment, condominium, or rental home. This type of insurance covers various causes of loss, such as accidents, weather impacts, malicious mischief, and loss of use. Other options available are home, car, health, life, and business insurance.

  • Multiple Policy Types

111 East Verona Avenue, Verona, WI 53593
WebsiteLicense: 7995614

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (78)
Facebook
5.0 (15)
Yelp
5.0 (1)

Why choose this provider?

Sarah Drew is an independent insurance agent serving clients in Madison. She has been in the industry for over 17 years, providing renters' insurance coverage to help protect clients' personal belongings. Madison also provides options for life, health, home, and auto insurance, in addition to pet, property, and business coverage. She offers mutual funds, annuities, and banking services, as well. Madison is an active member of various local organizations. In her free time, she enjoys cooking, gardening, and fishing.

  • Multiple Policy Types

810 Elm St., Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965
WebsiteLicense: 8830972

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
5.0 (14)

Why choose this provider?

Kristine Branton is an insurance specialist who serves individuals and families in Madison and nearby areas. She offers personal protection products, helping clients living in leasing properties obtain renters' insurance. She furnishes personal possession, liability, and additional living expense coverages to secure reimbursements in case of perils like fire, theft, and vandalism. In addition, she writes life, health, umbrella, auto, and condominium insurance. Kristine is an independent agent who works for Tricor Insurance.

  • Multiple Policy Types

6200 Mineral Point Road, Madison, WI 53705
WebsiteLicense: 100192662

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (117)
Facebook
5.0 (19)
Yelp
5.0 (3)

Why choose this provider?

Established in 1914, Neckerman Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency that serves individuals, families, and businesses in Madison. It offers renters' insurance policies, which cover clients' personal belongings against damage or loss from fire, lightning, smoke, theft, and vandalism. Its benefits also include additional living and medical expenses and legal defense costs. Doug Dittmann, the firm's president, joined the business in 1983. He is also currently serving on the Madison Downtown Rotary Board of Trustees.

  • Multiple Carriers
  • Multiple Policy Types

2418 Crossroads Drive, Madison, WI 53718
WebsiteLicense: 17145122

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.0 (25)
Facebook
5.0 (10)
Yelp
4.0 (9)

Why choose this provider?

Melissa Bizeau has been providing insurance services through State Farm since 2015. Her office is located in Madison and serves nearby areas, including Monona, Sun Prairie, Cottage Grove. Bizeau has devoted more than 15 years of her career in financial services, working in real estate lending then shifting her focus to insurance services. Working with State Farm, she offers clients different coverage options to protect their belongings in rental properties. In addition, she also offers auto, life, health, and pet insurance.

  • Multiple Policy Types

1001 Fourier Drive Suite 100, Madison, WI 53717
WebsiteLicense: 100195967

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.6 (13)
Yelp
3.0 (2)

Why choose this provider?

Thomas Bradley Insurance caters to clients in the Madison metro. The independent insurance agency provides coverage for renters and their belongings against uncertainties such as unexpected additional living expenses and dangers including fire, riots, theft, and hail. It also provides coverage for property improvements like renovations and remodeling. Other policies offered include business and commercial insurance, auto, and home insurance. In addition, it provides professional liability, workers' compensation, and life insurance coverage. The company has been in service for ten years.

  • Multiple Policy Types

Compare our Top Renter's Insurance Companies

NameExpertise RatingAddressPromotionsLearn more
Gary Ellis Insurance
505 Cottage Grove Road, Madison, WI 53716
Homewood Insurance
715 W. Main St, Ste B, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Action Insurance Agency
6405 Century Avenue, Middleton, WI 53562
Prairie Land Insurance Agency
Atwood Avenue, Madison, WI 53704
C4 Insurance
14 Ellis Potter Ct, Madison, WI 53711
Meg Cano-Schuman
3565 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53705
Aaron Perry
2605 Monroe Street, Madison, WI 53711
Compliance Insurance
6602 University Avenue, Middleton, WI 53562
Kevin Lease
402 Gammon Place, Suite 304, Madison, WI 53719
Sarah Drew
111 East Verona Avenue, Verona, WI 53593
Kristine Branton
810 Elm St., Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965
Neckerman Insurance Services
6200 Mineral Point Road, Madison, WI 53705
Melissa Bizeau
2418 Crossroads Drive, Madison, WI 53718
Thomas Bradley Insurance
1001 Fourier Drive Suite 100, Madison, WI 53717

FAQs

  • Does Madison compel tenants to have renter's insurance?

    Tenants in Madison are not required by law to obtain renter's insurance. However, landlords may require you to purchase coverage as a condition of your lease. The renter's insurance may be beneficial regardless of whether coverage is required by the lease. A renter's insurance policy can protect you from weather-related disasters, theft, water damage caused by building defects, and personal liability claims.

  • What are the typical reasons Madison residents file claims with their renters' insurance provider?

    Madison renters face a variety of dangers, but property crimes including theft and vandalism, fire damage, and weather-related losses are the most frequent claims. The Federal Bureau of Investigations reported as many as 6,722 property crime incidents in Madison in 2018. Additionally, Wisconsin experiences 23 tornadoes on average per year.

  • Does Madison renter's insurance cover damage caused by an ex-spouse while you're at work?

    Although coverage varies depending on the circumstances, there are a few common ways Madison renters insurance could respond to such a loss. If items are taken as a result of the circumstances, theft is covered. If you discover disparaging statements scribbled on your possessions, it is considered vandalism or intentional mischief; you may be covered for that loss. Liability coverage will also protect you if someone uses a key you gave them and you forget to change the locks.

  • Does Madison renters insurance cover damage caused by pets to apartments?

    Madison renter's insurance does not cover pet-related damage to your apartment. However, if your pet injures someone else or damages their property, liability insurance can help cover the costs. When purchasing Madison renter's insurance, it's critical to inform your agent so that they can provide you with options for meeting such needs.

  • In Madison, how much does renter's insurance cost?

    The average monthly premium for renter's insurance in Madison is between $10 and $20; however, this price is subject to a variety of factors. This includes the specific Madison neighborhood you live in, the type of building you occupy, the fire safety rating of the area, the types and amounts of insurance you purchase, and your deductibles.

Related Articles

FeaturedHome-Remodel-Hero

Survey: COVID-19 Pandemic Leads to Surge in Demand for Renters Insurance

We surveyed 1,000 renters in the U.S. to see how the pandemic changed their thoughts about renters insurance, what they look ...