Expertise.com Homepage

2025

Last updated:

Best Pet Insurance Companies in Indiana

Our Recommended Top 6

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Indiana pet insurance companies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

127952Reviewed

76773Curated

6Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.

Providers

featured provider = Featured Provider

Best Pet Insurance Companies Serving Indiana
Indiana

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Facebook
4.6 (24)
Google
4.8 (15)

Why choose this provider?

Turner & Shepherd Insurance serves clients throughout Indiana. The agency offers policies for pet owners from the firm Figo that cover costs related to chemotherapy treatments, vaccinations, and diagnostic tests. It creates plans for owners of cats and dogs. The agency also sets up a personal articles insurance plan for clients that own valuable items like fine art, guns, and jewelry. The Independent Insurance Agents of Indiana honored the agency in 2014 with the Agency of the Year award.

  • Policy Bundle Discount

Best Pet Insurance Companies Serving Indiana
Indiana

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.2 (36)
Facebook
5.0 (28)

Why choose this provider?

Tribbett-Rich Insurance Group is an independently owned and operated agency that has been serving clients in the state of Indiana since January 2014. It provides pet insurance plans, which help cover medical expenses in the event of the pet's illness or injury. Other personal products it offers include auto, home, renters', and personal umbrella insurance. Tribbett-Rich Insurance Group also provides different types of business policies. Owners Travis Rich and Jay Tribbett have more than two decades of combined industry experience.

  • Accident Only
  • Policy Bundle Discount

Best Pet Insurance Companies Serving Indiana
Indiana

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
5.0 (3)

Why choose this provider?

Integrity Insurance & Associates, LLC, is an agency that helps families and individuals across Indiana. It partners with Figo, a third-party insurance provider, and offers pet insurance plans that reimburse vet bills incurred from accidents or sickness. The policy covers medications, vaccines, and diagnostic tests for both dogs and cats. The firm also provides other personal insurance products, such as auto, health, homeowners', life, and long-term care. The agency's president, Douglas Baim, has been in the financial services industry since 1981.

  • Policy Bundle Discount

Best Pet Insurance Companies Serving Indiana
Indiana

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.7 (18)

Why choose this provider?

Duling Insurance Agency caters to the residents of Indiana. It offers pet insurance policies to help clients protect themselves from financial losses in the event that their animal companions get sick or injured. Its other insurance products include auto, health, motorcycle, and life. As an independent firm, the company has access to various carriers, like Hagerty, Progressive, and Anthem. Its principal agent, Mark H. Duling, has served as president of the Professional Insurance Agents of Indiana and holds the CIC and CPIA designations.

Best Pet Insurance Companies Serving Indiana
Indiana

Expertise.com Rating

Review Sources

Google
4.8 (5)

Why choose this provider?

Wilmington Insurance Agency caters to clients across Indiana. It assists individuals and families in preparing their finances for the unexpected veterinary expenses of their cats and dogs by applying for pet insurance policies. These policies allow clients to reimburse their pet's bills and treatments due to sickness or injuries. The agency also helps clients receive updates on their pets' appointments, obtain lost pet alerts, and access pets' records for emergencies and travels. Wilmington Insurance Agency has auto, life, home, and business insurance products.

  • Multi-Pet Discount

Best Pet Insurance Companies Serving Indiana
Indiana

Expertise.com Rating

Why choose this provider?

Source Insurance Group & Financial Services, LLC, is an independent agency that serves residential and commercial clients in Indiana. It provides pet insurance options that cover a dog or cat's medical bills due to injuries or illnesses. It gives clients access to Figo's Pet Cloud mobile app that offers health appointment reminders, pet travel and emergency records, and lost pet GPS technology. It creates customized options through its partnership with multiple national and regional carriers, including Humana, Safeco, and Travelers.

Compare our Top Pet Insurance Companies

NameExpertise RatingAddressPromotionsLearn more
Turner & Shepherd Insurance
101 E Main Street, Indiana, IN 47330
Tribbett-Rich Insurance Group
107 East Main Street, Indiana, IN 46052
Integrity Insurance & Associates, LLC
2130 S. West Street, Indiana, IN 47396
Duling Insurance Agency
430 Fletcher Ave, Indiana, IN 47460
Wilmington Insurance Agency
551 Beck Lane, Suite C, Indiana, IN 47909
Source Insurance Group & Financial Services, LLC
8388 E 116th Street, Indiana, IN 46038

Indiana Pet Insurance FAQs

  • What is the yearly cost of pet insurance in Indiana?

    In Indiana, annual pet insurance rates begin at approximately $170 and can escalate to around $1,175, varying by breed. However, these figures don't encapsulate your share of medical bills, as insurers typically reimburse just a percentage. Consequently, owners bear some costs directly. The exact yearly expense remains undetermined until all options are selected due to influencing factors.

  • How can Indiana residents adjust pet insurance to meet their financial situations?

    Residents in Indiana can tailor their pet insurance policies to budget preferences. To maintain a low premium while ensuring substantial coverage, a high-deductible policy paired with a significant annual cap, like $10,000, is recommended. Conversely, those, including students and seniors, wanting minimal upfront costs might opt for lower deductibles and co-pays. Fortunately, policyholders have the flexibility to determine their and their insurer's contribution to veterinary bills.

  • What types of waiting periods exist for pet insurance in Indiana?

    Pet insurance in Indiana typically has distinct waiting periods. There's a one to 14-day period for accidents, a standard 14-day period for illnesses, and for certain conditions, a six to 12-month extended period. Not every insurance company enforces the extended timeframe. Importantly, waiting periods might differ among companies. Some might even offer policies devoid of any waiting time.

  • For insurance claims in Indiana, what veterinarian documents are required for pets?

    When claiming pet insurance in Indiana, owners must provide the itemized invoice from their veterinarian. This detailed bill covers all treatments and services. Apart from that, the vet's office retains crucial documents, encompassing the veterinarian's observations, lab findings, and other pertinent records from each visit. If needed, your vet might have to supply additional medical information for the claim.

  • Does pet insurance in Indiana include spaying or neutering procedures?

    While numerous Indiana pet insurance providers offer coverage for spaying or neutering, it's typically not included in standard policies. Such procedures, being one-time events, often require additional coverage at an extra cost. Consequently, pet owners might find it more economical to pay these expenses out-of-pocket instead of expanding their insurance coverage.