Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Erie, PA

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance is an independent agency that serves Erie and the surrounding cities. Established in 1955, the company has experienced car insurance agents that help clients find suitable coverage to meet their needs. It offers coverage for property damages caused by theft, vandalism, and disasters as well as medical coverage for rehabilitation and injuries caused by accidents. Hilling-Pfeffer also offers insurance with other types of vehicles, including motorcycles, boats, and outboard motors.

Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC, is a firm in Erie that provides auto insurance products to residents in the metro. The company, which was formed in November 1972, creates auto insurance policies for clients that cover expenses for liabilities, damages, and medical payments. Its auto insurance policies can be bundled with other personal lines, such as its homeowner's insurance plans. Northshore Insurance Agency has been woman-owned since 2012 and actively supports The Erie Women's Fund.

Nicklas Insurance Group is a local company that offers auto insurance plans to clients in Erie. Founded by Richard J. Nicklas in 1962, the agency employs a staff with 150 years of combined insurance experience. It partners with several insurance carriers to give customers extensive options when finding the best auto insurance policy that suits their requirements. Additionally, its team of agents offers a variety of auto coverages, including bodily injury liability, property damage liability, collision coverage, and personal injury protection.

Great Lakes Insurance works with more than 100 carriers to deliver customizable car insurance policies throughout the country. In addition to standard insurance policies, the agency also provides specialty programs to handle unique risks. The agency is one of only two companies in Erie County that are licensed to transact with Non-Admitted Pennsylvania, New York, and Ohio insurance carriers. Established in 1968 under a different name, the agency had several expansions over the years.

Lafaro Insurance Agency has been providing insurance products and services to residents of Erie and nearby communities since 1969. Its team of seasoned insurance agents provides personalized and comprehensive car insurance plans tailored to the clients' needs and driving experience. The agency's standard auto policy has coverage options for reparation or replacement costs for vehicle damage or theft; liability to others in case of property damage and bodily injuries; and medical expenses for injury treatments, rehabilitation, lost wages, and funeral expenses.

Loesel-Schaaf Insurance Agency is an independent agency that has been serving Erie for over 90 years. It offers a wide range of personal and commercial auto insurance coverage options to individuals and corporate clients for different types of vehicles. Its policies can protect customers and their personal assets from various covered losses. Its agents provide a variety of services, including risk review and policy change request. Insurance protection is also offered to individuals with special interests and passion, like collector cars, yachts, jewelry, and antique homes.

Located in Erie, Cronk Insurance Inc. has been providing various aspects of car insurance services for over five decades. Its team of experienced professionals provides access to multiple auto insurance carriers to better tailor the specific needs of clients. The company offers coverage for all-terrain vehicles, as well as motorcycles and sports bikes. Additionally, the team offers medical coverage and insurance protection for snowmobile vehicle owners. Clients handled by the locally owned Cronk Insurance Inc. have cited the team's efficiency and professionalism.

Bort Insurance Services is an Erie-based independent insurance agency that has been serving clients since 1975. The agency offers auto insurance beyond the minimum required coverage, with a policy that can be structured based on client needs and risk factors. Its policies can protect against the financial losses of vehicles stolen, damaged or destroyed by fire, or damaged in an accident. Specializing in a wide variety of insurance solutions to meet client needs, the firm also provides business, home, condo, and flood insurance.

Historic Square Agency is an Erie-based independent insurance agency. The agents of this full-service insurance agency have over a hundred years of combined experience in the insurance industry. The agency works with its clients in finding the most suitable auto insurance that meets their requirements. The auto insurance options it offers have property damage, injury liability, medical payments, and uninsured motorists' coverage. Additionally, Historic Square Agency has a strong focus on helping clients safeguard their assets through its insurance options.

Domino Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent insurance firm that services the Erie metro and the entire state of Pennsylvania. It aims to educate consumers about the benefits of insurance products through thorough assessment and guidance. Its expert insurance agents help clients navigate options offered by its partner insurance providers. Domino Insurance Agency writes auto insurance policies that provide coverage for collisions, physical damages, liabilities, medical payments, and personal injuries caused.

Burns & Burns Insurance - Erie is an independent insurance agency servicing the Erie community. Established in 1939, it has been providing personal and business car insurance coverage options to protect a vehicle or a whole fleet. The family-owned and operated agency also offers a wide range of life and health protections for individuals and groups, including a flexible spending account for healthcare expenses. It is committed to delivering its services with a professional risk management approach in protecting its clients' assets.

Mark Bruns Agency is a locally owned and operated firm that is dedicated to providing car insurance solutions to clients near Erie. The business has been operating since 1995. Its agents can help individuals build a personalized auto insurance policy that fits their driving style, level of activity, and vehicle value. They also offer home, business and commercial, life, and farm insurance products. Mark Bruns Agency's trusted carriers include Safeco, Nationwide, Progressive, and Travelers.

Wagner Giblin Insurance is a full-service insurance agency that has been serving the insurance needs of car owners and motorists in Erie and nearby communities for more than 150 years. Established in 1870, the company assists individual and commercial customers in selecting the right car insurance policy to match their needs. Its independent agents represent multiple providers that can provide several coverages like property damage liability, accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, and new car replacements. They also offer insurance options for motorcycles, RVs, boats, and watercraft.

Founded in the 1920s, Bush Insurance helps Erie drivers find the right auto insurance for them without spending a lot of money. Its agents ask the clients about their personal vehicles and any company vehicle. Using their clients' answers to these questions, they look for an insurance policy with the coverage that suits their situation. They also help their clients find new insurance providers should their first policy increase theor rates. Bush Insurance also offers other insurance for homeowners, farm, life and health, and business.