Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Indianapolis

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Indianapolis Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 462 281 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Don Culberson Insurance Agency

The Don Culberson Insurance Agency is an independent agency based in Indianapolis, Indiana. A provider of home insurance and other types of coverage, the agency has over 13 years of experience finding and shaping home insurance for its clients. It is partnered with many carriers, giving it the space to find the right policy for its client's needs and budget. The agency helps its clients understand the complexities of named-peril and all-risk policies, so they know what they're paying for.

8152 Zionsville Rd
Indianapolis, IN 46268


Hometown Insurance

Hometown Insurance, which was founded in 1918 in Brownsburg, Indiana, has three offices to serve clients throughout central Indiana. It offers comprehensive homeowners and renters insurance to protect possessions or to rebuild if a home is damaged. Liability insurance is available to protect clients from lawsuits. Agents help clients choose affordable policies, combining policies as appropriate, including flood and earthquake insurance, fidelity and surety bonds, personal umbrella, and business interruption insurance.

1233 W Oak St
Zionsville, IN 46077


Insure Rite

InsureRite is an independent insurance agency in Greenfield, Indiana, that sells home insurance and has been serving the Indianapolis metro for over 30 years. InsureRite offers homeowners protection for the structure of their residence as well as their personal belongings and liability should someone be injured on the property. The agency additionally offers insurance solutions that include long term care coverage, life and health policies, a variety of commercial insurance, and pet insurance.

5151 W US Highway 40
Greenfield, IN 46140


Larkey Insurance

Larkey Insurance is a family-owned and operated home insurance company that has been serving the residents of Indianapolis, Indiana, since 1954. As an independent agency, it works with multiple nationwide insurance carriers, such as Auto-Owners Insurance and Progressive. This allows them to offer clients different packages and plans to fit their unique desires. Homeowners and renters policies cover damage to the home due to a natural disaster, loss of personal possesions, loss of use, and liability.

107 W Washington St
Fairland, IN 46126


McBee Insurance Agency

McBee Insurance Agency is an independent, family-owned insurance agency located in Indianapolis, Indiana, with a second office in Anderson. Founded in 1975, trained specialists work with several insurance carriers to find clients policies that provide coverage for their homes, personal belongs, and medical expenses for guests injured on the property following an accident, theft or vandalism, or destruction by fire and some natural disasters. Agents also check for discounts and help find insurance that fits any budget.

1641 N Shadeland Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46219


Morgan Insurance Group

Morgan Insurance Group is an independent insurance company located in the Indianapolis, Indiana, metro area, with offices in Martinsville, Greenwood, and Plainsfield. Coverage specialists analyze risk and search through quotes from over a dozen carriers, such as Allstate, Homeguard, and The Hartford, to find the best policy at a competitive rate. Options include insurance plans that cover losses from fire, weather events, theft, and certain legal costs. Other coverage choices include auto, motorcycle, life, and business.

1464 S State Road 135
Greenwood, IN 46143


Osborn Insurance Agency

Osborn Insurance Agency operates within the Indianapolis, Indiana, metro area, assisting clients with home insurance policies. It offers home owner's insurance for coverage of structural damage, assets, injury and liability, as well as coverage for condominiums and renter's insurance. Its agents are experienced in both named perils-policies and all-risk policies. Flood insurance policies are also available as an additional coverage. Functioning as a full-service agency, Osborn Insurance Agency handles auto, life, and business insurance as well.

8767 South St
Fishers, IN 46038


Rupp Insurance

Operating since 1973, Rupp Insurance is an Indianapolis, Indiana-based agency consulting clients on home insurance policies. It structures coverage plans that protect from significant financial loss in instances of extensive property damage to the home or structures on the same premises, loss or destruction of personal items, and legal liabilities incurred because of third parties. This company provides auto, life, and health insurance services, and the option to bundle home and auto insurance coverage into one policy at a lower rate.

40 Executive Dr Ste C
Carmel, IN 46032


Schoolhouse Insurance

Schoolhouse Insurance is a small, independent insurance agency located in Indianapolis and providing insurance services throughout the state of Indiana. It specializes in providing coverage from Erie Insurance but also works with most major providers, such as Progressive, MetLife, and Travelers. Schoolhouse Insurance provides free comparative quotes from multiple homeowners insurance companies to help clients find the right coverage, and it also offers renters insurance quotes. Customers mention the agency's personalized service and affordable prices.

3725 E Southport Rd Ste D
Indianapolis, IN 46227


WalkerHughes Insurance

WalkerHughes Insurance is an insurance company based in Indianapolis, Indiana. It serves homeowners and condo owners in Indianapolis, Albio, Huntington, and the surrounding areas. The company provides basic property and liability insurance and additional coverage options, including water damage, other structures, contents, and medical cover. WalkerHughes Insurance also assists with alternative personal insurance needs, such as boat, PWC, motorcycle, and auto insurance policies, as well as business insurance for clients in a range of industries.

6510 N Shadeland Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46220


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: